Renaldi's Pizzeria

54 W Waterloo St, Canal Winchester
(614) 833-1221

Recent Reviews

Heather Quinn

I love this pizza!!! It's so good, my favorite pizza place!! They don't skimp on the toppings, which I love. And I love their spicy pizza sauce ?

T Frazee

Absolutely the best pizza around! The boy and I wanted to try a local pizza joint and we weren’t disappointed! We both loved it. We will be back!

Alex S

The inside of this place is borderline health violation, but good lord the pizza is amazing. If you are in between Grape vine (I've always had super dry crust from them), Kingys (just overpriced donatos), or this place, I would give Renaldis a try. The spicy sauce is right on the money, crust is above average, and toppings/cheese are generous but not overdone.

Its me Edna

Pizza is delicious! And always on time.

Matt S

The best pizza I've had in more than 10 years!!! I love their Pepperoni pizza, my wife loves their bbq chicken pizza!

Godfather ..

This was our first time trying Renaldi's. We ordered a large Supreme Pizza but, without mushrooms and banana peppers. We also wanted to try their Italian Sub and Meatball Sub. We also ordered their Parmesan Garlic Breadsticks and Cinnamon Pie for dessert. I thought the guy who took my order on the phone was nice and he ended up being the guy who delivered our food which took about 75 minutes to get here. That was ok with us because we knew it was a Saturday and they were probably busy so that was fine with us. The pizza was very good! The crust was perfect and wasn't too thin or too thick. The sauce tasted good and they really load up on the toppings! The Italian Sub was toasted which I like and tasted good. The only problem I had with it was, I said NO BANANA PEPPERS! They put banana peppers on my Italian sub which I had to scrape off. Next time, please make my sub the way I order it. But, other than that minor issue it tasted good. The meatball sub my wife said was just ok. I tried it and I liked the taste of the meatballs and sauce. The Parmesan Garlic Breadsticks were ok. They had good flavor. The Cinnamon Dessert Pie was great! I highly recommend trying it. I highly recommend trying Renaldi's if you haven't tried them yet. We will definitely be ordering from them again soon.

GoBlu Rick

I would give a zero but it wouldn't let me. The most disorganized food service I have EVER had the displeasure of ordering from. Last time we were told 35 minutes it was well over an hour. This time I was told 35-40 min. Arrived 40 min later and paid for my pizza. Waited for 15min and enjoyed conversation with a sheriff deputy whose pizza took over an hr, was then told by an employee they forgot to make my order. I will NEVER enter this DUMP again!!

Carol Estabillo

We got a pizza that was loaded with meat it was so good !

Don Weirather

Sub was good but, didn't care for the pizza nice people

ty David

Amazing pizza, good prices and friendly staff

Erin P.

Lived here for 3 yrs and until a neighbor bought me Renaldis during a home issue I had no idea how great it was! Will order again myself

Victor A.

Just got 2 Clarke pizzas tonight. 1st time here; pep&cheese And cheese pizza. Very very good; the sauce was very tasty and the crust not a thin crust. I will definitely be back for more.

Kim T.

Awesome pie! Very consistent with quality and definitely won't disappoint. One of our go to top 4

Roy Goudy

Renaldi's Pizzeria is (in my opinion) the best pizza shop around. I know that pizza is a contentious subject, but this shop just makes the best pizza in town. The parking lot is little small but there's street parking very close by.

Sam Zungri

Always delicious. Not a fan of the casing still on the pepperoni, but otherwise everything is good!

Load More