14 Best American Restaurants in Celina

The Fountain Restaurant Family • $
116 W Market St, Celina

Customers` Favorites

The Billy Bob Plus Pancakes and Bacon
Fried Potatoes Bacon Scrambled Eggs
Homefries and Gravy
Biscuits and Gravy
Biscuits & Gravy
Country Omelette
Chocolate Milk
Cornbeef Hash
Sausage Gravy
French Toast

“Another great diner to eat at. Food was fantastic and everyone was extremely friendly and provided great service, despite how slammed with so many waiting to get in. Proof of how good the food and nostalgic this restuarant is. The prices were amazingly low as well.“

4.8 Superb77 Reviews
The Anchor Burgers • $
109 S Main St, Celina

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Bacon Ranch Wrap
Street Corn Chori Queso
Hamburger and Fries
Reuben Sandwich
Chicken Tenders
Pretzel Sticks
Cowboy Burger
Waffle Fries
Cheeseburger
Pan Seared

“For my 1400th review, I am going to write about my families experience at The Anchor. Ever since my family started to explore Celina's shops and restaurants about a year ago, The Anchor has been on my list of places to try. I am very glad we finally got around to it, as the entire experience was stupendous! We came one Friday night after work and parked next to The Anchor. We walked into this intimate and cozy pub and were immediately seated. The server gave us sometime to peruse the drink and food menus as we never had been to the pub. My brother got a beer, my mother and I both ordered some mixed drinks. My mother ordered the Tiki Torch, which is a mix of Bacardi Silver Rum, Malibu Coconut Rum, pineapple juice, orange juice, and grenadine. She absolutely loved it! I also tried some and found if quite refreshing. I ordered the Sailboat Sour, which is a blend of Four Roses Bourbon, simple syrup, lemon juice, blackberry brandy, sugar rim, garnished with a lemon slice. The drink was fantastic! I strongly recommend! We also ordered the cheese curds as an app, some of the best I have ever had! My brother and I both ordered burgers. He went with the cowboy burger, while I went with the bacon double. The burgers were perfection and the fries it came with were crunchy and hot. My mother ordered some chicken tenders with fries, which she thoroughly enjoyed! She couldn't finish the meal, as it was too much chicken for her. No worries, i had one bite and i couldn't stop until i finished what she left! Chicken was perfectly seasoned! The service was excellent throughout the time we were there! It is a wonderful little pub in Celina that I recommend everyone try!“

4.7 Superb57 Reviews
3

Willow

Willow American • $
1011 N Main St, Celina

Customers` Favorites

Tenderloin and Old Style Fries
French Fries & Slaw
Chili Cheese Fries
Double Cheeseburger
Burger and Fries
Root Beer Float
Sugar Cream Pie
Homemade Pie
Onion Rings
Pizza Steak

“Always love the Willow, but last night the fries were very soggie, like they had been laying around for awhile.for as busy as they were, you would have expected fries to be crispy& fresh. & the sugar cream pie tasted like wallpaper paste. (Would not recommend, the Sugar cream pie at all) We ate their about 6.45pm. As far as recommending what foods are good, it is all delicious, but the fries, & pie was not acceptable.“

4.6 Superb80 Reviews
The Bay Family • $
117 Lake Shore Dr, Celina

Customers` Favorites

Breakfast Club with Sausage and Pepperjack
Captain Ryely and Broasted Potatoes
Pancakes w Slice of Strawberry Pie
Buckeye Pie Slice of Heaven
Chili and Cheese Omelette
Breaded Tenderloin
Peanut Butter Pie
Burrito and Taco
Western Omelette
Mashed Potatoes

“The Bay was absolutely the right choice for an early Sunday breakfast, before our trip home from Grand Lake. This is an old school, diner style restaurant with a very nice service staff and a very nice breakfast selection, served fast and delicious. We'll be back for sure.“

4.5 Superb51 Reviews
IN-OH's Stateline Bar & Grill, LLC. Bar • $$
30 OH-29, Celina

“Bit late to review, but I came down with family to go see the eclipse, and we stopped here to get a bite to eat. The wait staff was extremely friendly and even offered to let us stay for the eclips, and the establishment was extremely clean from bar to bathroom. While I might not be able to make it out to this place again, I very much enjoyed my time here.“

4.7 Superb21 Reviews
Duckfoots bar & grill Bar • $
5445 Behm Rd, Celina

Customers` Favorites

Loaded French Fries
Breaded Tenderloin
Breaded Mushrooms
Grilled Cheese
Pretzel Sticks
Quesadilla
Pizza Sub

“Hey right nearby. Weekend has bands, buses and bikes. Serves starters, salads, and sandwich foods. Hamburger was good but a bit dry. May be my fault for not choosing how done. Your brew should be there, huge variety and some drafts. Grab a Duck Poo or Duck Fart. Liquor also available.“

4.5 Superb37 Reviews
Speakeasy Steak & Ale House Steak House • $$
211 S Main St, Celina

Customers` Favorites

8oz NY Strip Steak Loaded Mashed Potatoes and Parmesan Herb Fries
Firecracker Shrimp with the Lettuce Wrap
Bacon Wrapped Scallops
Bourbon Glazed Salmon
Western Style Ribs
Death by Chocolate
Signature BBQ Ribs
Bone-In Ribeye
Bacon Scallops
Blue Corn Chips

“Oh my goodness the atmosphere is incredible. I really love the laid back easy vibe of this place. The food was top notch! Definitely try the frog legs and bacon wrapped scallops. Devine! Huge selection of specialty and craft beers. The kind of place I wish was closer to home. I'd be a regular for sure.“

4.4 Superb67 Reviews
Shingle Shack Restaurant Bar & Grill • $
5477 Karafit Rd, Celina

“remember my first rodeo on this side of the mississippi, about 50-60 years back, sailed across the lake; vicious ride -- lost my wife, dog, 3 kids, if you can name it, i lost it out those rolling waves that fateful month. stopped at the shingle shack just a child, left a man the way those shingles ran through me. got the roofer's special: a treat of around 3 dozen 1/4lb burgers topped with a spoon of canned corn, ketchup, and a side of antifreeze for dippings (our stomachs were stronger back then on account of all the lead). i ate them all in a half hour -- rather slow, considering humans were on average 200-300lb heavier and 2 feet taller those days, before soy products and all -- and before i knew it they beckoned; hit an eject button of sorts, to leave from mouth to colon within minutes.i entered the bathroom with a dread: yet to this day that is as far as i truly remember. the food was just alright; my gastrointestinal tract has not yet and seemingly never will recoverREST IN PEACE LADY DI 1961-1997“

4.4 Superb16 Reviews
Beach Point Bar • $$
6903 OH-219, Celina

“If you liked Beach Point when the previous owners had it, then it’s safe to say you will like it now! There is a different atmosphere, which is a compliment, and quite a few menu additions along with almost all of the previous menu items. If you have yet to try Beach Point since the new owners have taken over, or you have never tried it in the first place, I highly recommend stopping in to grab a couple drinks with your meal or taking it out and enjoying it at home!“

3.8 Good9 Reviews
CJ's Highmarks Fine Dining • $
1211 Irmscher Blvd, Celina

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Tenders and Fries
Chocolate Brownie
Pot Roast Beef
Shrimp Tempura
Chicken Salad
French Dip
Ribs

“A fantastic place to eat at. My only gripe was for some reason when they're fries got a little cold they had a funny greasy taste. Beyond that I had the CJ club. The sandwich was really good. But when you get the sandwich don't be surprised. When the sandwich arrived the bread was cut in half. When they did that the sandwich looks like you're only getting a half of a sandwich. But it's still is a big decent sandwich. I would recommend this location for other individuals. The staff were very polite and kind. The restaurant was very clean and tidy.“

3.9 Good52 Reviews
Happy Daz American • $
911 Wayne St, Celina

Customers` Favorites

Mushroom Steak Burger with Onion Rings
Grilled Cheese Waiting on Tomato Soup
Turtle Pecan Caramel Brownie Sundae
Footlong All Beef Coney Dog
Mushroom Swiss Burger
Chili Cheese Fries
Double Cheeseburger
Bacon Cheeseburger
Root Beer Float
Chicken Strips

“BEST burger I’ve ever had! I was passing through town and throught I would try it out. SO good. The ingredients were so fresh - a total difference in their burger taste as compared to others’. It took about 10 min to get through the drive thru, but I appreciate the signs that warn you beforehand.“

3.9 Good63 Reviews
Boardwalk Grill Bar & Grill • $
725 W Bank Rd, Celina

Customers` Favorites

Crispy Garlic Shrimp
Boardwalk Burger
Fish and Chips
Fish Sandwich
Loaded Fries
Loaded Nachos
Shrimp Tacos
Fish Tacos

“Absolute 10/10. Grace was our waitress tonight. She went ABOVE AND BEYOND! She provided amazing service & was the sweetest EVER. My first time eating there & definitely not my last.Food is a little pricey, but still delicious, and the hospitality makes up for it.I would recommend to anyone & would definitely recommend Grace. ❤️“

3.9 Good90 Reviews
Shandy's Grill & Bar American • $
129 W Fayette St, Celina

Customers` Favorites

Build Your Own Burger
Fish and Chips
Buffalo Wing
Tater Kegs
Hamburger
Coleslaw
Fish

“Husband wanted to watch football ? and I was happy to join him with my boyfriend, Mr. iPad ?. We were there during a football game and our waitress was wonderful, patient and served us when we were ready. We ordered spinach dip then later on, we had chili. Well worth the visit. Thank you for making my husband satisfied ?“

3.8 Good67 Reviews
Behm's America American • $
5494 Behm Rd, Celina

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Strips Served with Choice of Sauce
Mashed Potatoes
Hamburger
Coleslaw
Pizza
Fries

“My wife and I had the best experience at Behms America! The service was great! My wife had the butterfly shrimp and I had the lobster rolls and wow! The table next to use ordered tenderloins and some other foods that looked fantastic! I will definitely be back for the tenderloin! Great view! Got to see some pelicans. Definitely recommend!“

3.5 Good32 Reviews