I was torn between the Chocolate Mousse cake and the Black Forest Cake. Andie’s Cakery/Kelly was so patient with me when I was trying to make my decision. I ended up with a Chocolate Black Forest Cake — the best of both worlds! Funny thing is I am typically not a big chocolate fan but this cake was amazing! It was so moist and so delicious! It was my birthday cake and my family thoroughly enjoyed it! I found a new place to buy all my cakes!!! Thank you, Andie’s Cakery!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Kaelan Hayes
It is no exaggeration when I say the cakes this place makes are touched by the hand of Midas himself. We ordered a banana peanut butter cake and I'm pretty sure I experienced a glimpse of heaven when I first tasted it. Highly recommend!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ron H.
Andie's CakeryRecently discovered in CentervilleShe - I am ready for a Sacher Chocolate Torte, and she is referencing our several visit to Vienna for the famous Sacher Torte from Café Sacher Wien. At any rate, when we visit Vienna, we are certain to order Sacher Torte from Café Sacher Wien in the Hotel Sacher.He - I'll make a few calls, and following abject failure, I discover and I talk with Kelly at Andies'.Kelly - yes, we know Sacher Chocolate Torte; however, Andie's tortes are better!He - Now this is a challenge I am willing to accept.Kelly - Andie's Torte is 5" high and comes in 6", 9", and 12" all covered with dark frosting - 4 cake layers and 4 layers of icing.Later: She - this is better than Sacher Torte from Café Sacher Wien.Two months later:She: I am in the mood for German Chocolate cake.He: I exist to fulfill your romantic moods.He: Kelley, we need a German Chocolate with dark chocolate.Kelley: German Chocolate cakes do not come in dark.He: let's improvise; how about a dark chocolate cake with German frosting and layers.Kelley: fine, it will be ready at 2:00 PM tomorrow.Later: She - this is the best chocolate cake ever....He: Your wish is my commandNow on adventure to find Real German Strudel.
Cynthia Williams
Ordered a Carrot Cake & it was the best I've eaten, then ordered a Fresh Strawberry Cake absolutely delicious!
ABC 1148
Holy cake!!!! I ordered a buckeye cake and a pink strawberry cake for a party. Both cakes were superb. The buckeye cake was exactly like a buckeye and so creamy and moist. The pink cake was lite and moist. So so so good. Thank you Andie’s!
Carly Carmack
Ordered the Buckeye peanut butter cake for my mom's birthday. It was FANTASTIC. So fresh and delicious!
Gabriel Portillo-Ramos
Fantastic cakes, great service.
E. Kibby
We ordered enough cupcakes to celebrate four kids’ birthdays during an out-of-town hockey tournament. Kelly was so helpful in figuring out how to best store and transport them so that no matter when we got to celebrate they’d still be delicious. Thanks to Kelly’s care, boy were they ever! Four dozen cupcakes (some even with whipped cream frosting) made it there in excellent condition— parents and players said they were the best they’ve ever had, they’re that good! Thanks again. We will always order from Andie’s from now on.
Akshya Paathra
Ordered a pumpkin pie and a bourbon pecan pie for Thanksgiving. Both were outstanding! I am typically not a fan of pumpkin pie, but still get one every year for the sake of tradition. This year we all absolutely enjoyed it. Served cold, it was simply heavenly. And as for the bourbon pecan pie, it was a winner as well!
Natalie Russell
We had Andie's Cakery for the dessert for our rehearsal dinner and for our wedding cake. The cookies, brownies, and cake were all delicious! We had multiple guest tell us how great the dessert was for both nights. Very reasonably priced compared to other bakeries in the area and Kelly was a joy to work with!
Cupcakes were purchased for a corporate event. As soon as I took a bite, I envisioned rainbows and unicorns... Delectable is an understatement. Had to ask where they came from and was advised that they came from Andie's Cakery. If a simple vanilla and chocolate cupcake made me feel this way, imagine their other options/flavors. I'm making a b-line to their bakery.
Karthik Jayaram
We got chocolate mousse cake for a Graduation party and a special request Birthday cake for our younger daughter, a chocolate brownie cake from here. I am from Virginia and wow, Andie's cakes are a national treasure. How can they make brownies so decadent yet balance the richness? Exquisite piping, multi dimensional flavor spectrum and simply amazing taste makes these cakes worthy of joyful accolades. (Thank you Kelly, we enjoyed the brownie cake.)
Natalie Shanks
We had Andie's Cakery for the dessert for our rehearsal dinner and for our wedding cake. The cookies, brownies, and cake were all delicious! We had multiple guest tell us how great the dessert was for both nights. Very reasonably priced compared to other bakeries in the area and Kelly was a joy to work with!
Jenna Knopf
I ordered the Italian wedding cake for my birthday, and it's one of the best cakes I've ever had. The people there are wonderful and friendly. In the past we've had the chocolate and carrot cakes for different events; both were equally delicious. I can't wait to call them again when a pastry need arises!
Allen & Kimberly Keiter
These fine ladies are experts in their craft. We are always happy for our sweet treats when we visit from TN. Highly recommend!
I was torn between the Chocolate Mousse cake and the Black Forest Cake. Andie’s Cakery/Kelly was so patient with me when I was trying to make my decision. I ended up with a Chocolate Black Forest Cake — the best of both worlds! Funny thing is I am typically not a big chocolate fan but this cake was amazing! It was so moist and so delicious! It was my birthday cake and my family thoroughly enjoyed it! I found a new place to buy all my cakes!!! Thank you, Andie’s Cakery!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
It is no exaggeration when I say the cakes this place makes are touched by the hand of Midas himself. We ordered a banana peanut butter cake and I'm pretty sure I experienced a glimpse of heaven when I first tasted it. Highly recommend!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Andie's CakeryRecently discovered in CentervilleShe - I am ready for a Sacher Chocolate Torte, and she is referencing our several visit to Vienna for the famous Sacher Torte from Café Sacher Wien. At any rate, when we visit Vienna, we are certain to order Sacher Torte from Café Sacher Wien in the Hotel Sacher.He - I'll make a few calls, and following abject failure, I discover and I talk with Kelly at Andies'.Kelly - yes, we know Sacher Chocolate Torte; however, Andie's tortes are better!He - Now this is a challenge I am willing to accept.Kelly - Andie's Torte is 5" high and comes in 6", 9", and 12" all covered with dark frosting - 4 cake layers and 4 layers of icing.Later: She - this is better than Sacher Torte from Café Sacher Wien.Two months later:She: I am in the mood for German Chocolate cake.He: I exist to fulfill your romantic moods.He: Kelley, we need a German Chocolate with dark chocolate.Kelley: German Chocolate cakes do not come in dark.He: let's improvise; how about a dark chocolate cake with German frosting and layers.Kelley: fine, it will be ready at 2:00 PM tomorrow.Later: She - this is the best chocolate cake ever....He: Your wish is my commandNow on adventure to find Real German Strudel.
Ordered a Carrot Cake & it was the best I've eaten, then ordered a Fresh Strawberry Cake absolutely delicious!
Holy cake!!!! I ordered a buckeye cake and a pink strawberry cake for a party. Both cakes were superb. The buckeye cake was exactly like a buckeye and so creamy and moist. The pink cake was lite and moist. So so so good. Thank you Andie’s!
Ordered the Buckeye peanut butter cake for my mom's birthday. It was FANTASTIC. So fresh and delicious!
Fantastic cakes, great service.
We ordered enough cupcakes to celebrate four kids’ birthdays during an out-of-town hockey tournament. Kelly was so helpful in figuring out how to best store and transport them so that no matter when we got to celebrate they’d still be delicious. Thanks to Kelly’s care, boy were they ever! Four dozen cupcakes (some even with whipped cream frosting) made it there in excellent condition— parents and players said they were the best they’ve ever had, they’re that good! Thanks again. We will always order from Andie’s from now on.
Ordered a pumpkin pie and a bourbon pecan pie for Thanksgiving. Both were outstanding! I am typically not a fan of pumpkin pie, but still get one every year for the sake of tradition. This year we all absolutely enjoyed it. Served cold, it was simply heavenly. And as for the bourbon pecan pie, it was a winner as well!
We had Andie's Cakery for the dessert for our rehearsal dinner and for our wedding cake. The cookies, brownies, and cake were all delicious! We had multiple guest tell us how great the dessert was for both nights. Very reasonably priced compared to other bakeries in the area and Kelly was a joy to work with!
Restaurantji Recommends
Cupcakes were purchased for a corporate event. As soon as I took a bite, I envisioned rainbows and unicorns... Delectable is an understatement. Had to ask where they came from and was advised that they came from Andie's Cakery. If a simple vanilla and chocolate cupcake made me feel this way, imagine their other options/flavors. I'm making a b-line to their bakery.
We got chocolate mousse cake for a Graduation party and a special request Birthday cake for our younger daughter, a chocolate brownie cake from here. I am from Virginia and wow, Andie's cakes are a national treasure. How can they make brownies so decadent yet balance the richness? Exquisite piping, multi dimensional flavor spectrum and simply amazing taste makes these cakes worthy of joyful accolades. (Thank you Kelly, we enjoyed the brownie cake.)
We had Andie's Cakery for the dessert for our rehearsal dinner and for our wedding cake. The cookies, brownies, and cake were all delicious! We had multiple guest tell us how great the dessert was for both nights. Very reasonably priced compared to other bakeries in the area and Kelly was a joy to work with!
I ordered the Italian wedding cake for my birthday, and it's one of the best cakes I've ever had. The people there are wonderful and friendly. In the past we've had the chocolate and carrot cakes for different events; both were equally delicious. I can't wait to call them again when a pastry need arises!
These fine ladies are experts in their craft. We are always happy for our sweet treats when we visit from TN. Highly recommend!