Don't say you were not warned about this place! and I salivate for a response from this Wack mgr. First off, he's as corny as they get. The delusional manager Missy Messy whatever his name is had the nerve to send pizzas that were unsightly, cold and incorrect. A real man takes accountability. This loud unprofessional girly mouth manager apparently hasn't owned anything significant in life to tell me nothing was wrong with the pizzas and this foolishness here " I make the best pizzas in Cincinnati" No you make the worst representative of Papa John's entire corporation down to janitorial, the pizzas arrived 30 mins after the promised time. A lame a weirdo a duck. Instead of taking accountability you want to lie to yourself and deny an error anyone could've made. I can't stand people that don't take the real risk to own your own business, but you'll make effort to screw up someone else's business with your horrible attitude and lack of inspiration. He has nothing to lose by causing losses for his company. That's called NO INHERITED BRAVERY. I'm sure the staff has more qualified individuals to run that store and despise being under this clown's leadership. Everyone I mentioned it to said they avoid that Papa John's That's not Missy the mgrs. losses it's Papa John's so that says a lot about him. My significant other stopped me from going to the store and confronting this man child to his no doubt dumb looking, sloppy looking stupid looking girly mouth face because he wouldn't be worth it. All the invites wouldn't budge me because I won't lose my worth to a sale out over the phone rabbit bitten rabies in the throat chirp chirp chirp bird brain no body manager that has all the balls to argue a female customer, be wrong, and lie about himself and the products he had delivered. Papa John's can do better! until then I will not return to any establishment in fear they may be like this fool! Too many other places to spend my $61.00! Period
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
1234 Osmo
Just bad
Marquetta Rattler
Ordered pizza online. Pizza was OK but lacked sauce and the normal taste. Sauce tasted different. It served its purpose, and the cookie was great as
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Any Large Pizza
Will WITAKER
Worst of the worst very very very bad
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 3
Service: 1
Swagger
They’re incredibly slow. Order some where else.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Patricia Hesse
Placed order in person, waited for the pizza to cook. Only took 15 minutes to get it and it was great.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jason Ackerman
I ordered from papa John's not door dash I didn't get my 2 litter and door dash driver that I didn't want to use didn't speak any English couldn't explain what was going on so I'm without my drink for my fn dinner got to leave to go get something to drink that's why I got delivered to me didn't to leave but I get kinda thirsty eating food !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Kevin Lacey
Exsalent service friendly staff great
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Zach Baker
This place makes okay food. The question is will they get your order right? I ordered food back in March and the order was wrong. I called in and the manager offered me a free pizza except I'd have to call in to redeem. Of course when I finally decide to give them another chance they deny the offer then put me on hold to tell me that instead it was too far back to redeem. I may never order Papa John's again. If I do it won't be from this location if I can help it.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 3
Service: 1
Recommended dishes: Any Large Pizza
John Howard
Papa John's Pizza Evendale is my family's pizza choice. I recently went by the store and was surprised at how clean and upbeat it was. The staff looked like they were having a good time working with each other. The food quality was high, especially for the low price. They're constantly coming up with new menu items. It's hard to beat their Famous pizza. The counter woman was very friendly and professional. She took care of my pickup order while at the same time handling the phones and the register. The parking lot is easily accessible, well lit and feels safe.The next time you're in the Evendale area, make sure you order a pizza and other goodies from Papa John's Pizza Evendale. You and your family will be glad that you did!Vegetarian options: Vegetarian pizzas are availableParking: Veggie pizzas are availableKid-friendliness: The 10-in pizza is ideal for children
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Double Chocolate Chip Brownie, Unsauced Roasted Wings 8, Extras-Large Zesty Italian Trio Pizza, Buffalo Wings 8, Large Extra Cheesy Alfredo Pizza, Papabowl
Papa John's Pizza Evendale is my family's pizza choice. I recently went by the store and was surprised at how clean and upbeat it was. The staff looked like they were having a good time working with each other. The food quality was high, especially for the low price. They're constantly coming up with new menu items. It's hard to beat their Famous pizza. The counter woman was very friendly and professional. She took care of my pickup order while at the same time handling the phones and the register. The parking lot is easily accessible, well lit and feels safe.The next time you're in the Evendale area, make sure you order a pizza and other goodies from Papa John's Pizza Evendale. You and your family will be glad that you did!Vegetarian options: Vegetarian pizzas are availableKid-friendliness: The 10-in pizza is ideal for childrenParking: Veggie pizzas are available
I ordered a pizza and told the crew to text me upon an arrival. I waited more than 30 min., no text. 45 min. later, I checked outside and found the slightly opened pizza box. I was about to type a complaint online, but it demanded the order number. I didn't get the receipt. ??
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 1
Zack Parton
Ordered a delivery order over an hour before close while only being a 5 minute drive down the road. The order went through and 10 minutes later when i checked the progress they cancelled the order and refuse to answer the phone. If you dont wanna work your whole shift then change your hours
Food: 5
Service: 1
Michelle Fancher
Ordered extra sauces (pizza and spicy Garlic) and didn't receive. Hoagie was very dry and olives were ordered for the papadia and as you can see there were maybe 2.
Food: 2
Service: 2
JoAnn
Really really nice staff. Knowledgeable. I would definitely return to this store even if it were out of my way.
Don't say you were not warned about this place! and I salivate for a response from this Wack mgr. First off, he's as corny as they get. The delusional manager Missy Messy whatever his name is had the nerve to send pizzas that were unsightly, cold and incorrect. A real man takes accountability. This loud unprofessional girly mouth manager apparently hasn't owned anything significant in life to tell me nothing was wrong with the pizzas and this foolishness here " I make the best pizzas in Cincinnati" No you make the worst representative of Papa John's entire corporation down to janitorial, the pizzas arrived 30 mins after the promised time. A lame a weirdo a duck. Instead of taking accountability you want to lie to yourself and deny an error anyone could've made. I can't stand people that don't take the real risk to own your own business, but you'll make effort to screw up someone else's business with your horrible attitude and lack of inspiration. He has nothing to lose by causing losses for his company. That's called NO INHERITED BRAVERY. I'm sure the staff has more qualified individuals to run that store and despise being under this clown's leadership. Everyone I mentioned it to said they avoid that Papa John's That's not Missy the mgrs. losses it's Papa John's so that says a lot about him. My significant other stopped me from going to the store and confronting this man child to his no doubt dumb looking, sloppy looking stupid looking girly mouth face because he wouldn't be worth it. All the invites wouldn't budge me because I won't lose my worth to a sale out over the phone rabbit bitten rabies in the throat chirp chirp chirp bird brain no body manager that has all the balls to argue a female customer, be wrong, and lie about himself and the products he had delivered. Papa John's can do better! until then I will not return to any establishment in fear they may be like this fool! Too many other places to spend my $61.00! Period
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Just bad
Ordered pizza online. Pizza was OK but lacked sauce and the normal taste. Sauce tasted different. It served its purpose, and the cookie was great as
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Any Large Pizza
Worst of the worst very very very bad
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 3
Service: 1
They’re incredibly slow. Order some where else.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Placed order in person, waited for the pizza to cook. Only took 15 minutes to get it and it was great.
Food: 5
Service: 5
I ordered from papa John's not door dash I didn't get my 2 litter and door dash driver that I didn't want to use didn't speak any English couldn't explain what was going on so I'm without my drink for my fn dinner got to leave to go get something to drink that's why I got delivered to me didn't to leave but I get kinda thirsty eating food !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Exsalent service friendly staff great
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This place makes okay food. The question is will they get your order right? I ordered food back in March and the order was wrong. I called in and the manager offered me a free pizza except I'd have to call in to redeem. Of course when I finally decide to give them another chance they deny the offer then put me on hold to tell me that instead it was too far back to redeem. I may never order Papa John's again. If I do it won't be from this location if I can help it.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 3
Service: 1
Recommended dishes: Any Large Pizza
Papa John's Pizza Evendale is my family's pizza choice. I recently went by the store and was surprised at how clean and upbeat it was. The staff looked like they were having a good time working with each other. The food quality was high, especially for the low price. They're constantly coming up with new menu items. It's hard to beat their Famous pizza. The counter woman was very friendly and professional. She took care of my pickup order while at the same time handling the phones and the register. The parking lot is easily accessible, well lit and feels safe.The next time you're in the Evendale area, make sure you order a pizza and other goodies from Papa John's Pizza Evendale. You and your family will be glad that you did!Vegetarian options: Vegetarian pizzas are availableParking: Veggie pizzas are availableKid-friendliness: The 10-in pizza is ideal for children
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Double Chocolate Chip Brownie, Unsauced Roasted Wings 8, Extras-Large Zesty Italian Trio Pizza, Buffalo Wings 8, Large Extra Cheesy Alfredo Pizza, Papabowl
Restaurantji Recommends
Papa John's Pizza Evendale is my family's pizza choice. I recently went by the store and was surprised at how clean and upbeat it was. The staff looked like they were having a good time working with each other. The food quality was high, especially for the low price. They're constantly coming up with new menu items. It's hard to beat their Famous pizza. The counter woman was very friendly and professional. She took care of my pickup order while at the same time handling the phones and the register. The parking lot is easily accessible, well lit and feels safe.The next time you're in the Evendale area, make sure you order a pizza and other goodies from Papa John's Pizza Evendale. You and your family will be glad that you did!Vegetarian options: Vegetarian pizzas are availableKid-friendliness: The 10-in pizza is ideal for childrenParking: Veggie pizzas are available
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Double Chocolate Chip Brownie, Unsauced Roasted Wings
I ordered a pizza and told the crew to text me upon an arrival. I waited more than 30 min., no text. 45 min. later, I checked outside and found the slightly opened pizza box. I was about to type a complaint online, but it demanded the order number. I didn't get the receipt. ??
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 1
Ordered a delivery order over an hour before close while only being a 5 minute drive down the road. The order went through and 10 minutes later when i checked the progress they cancelled the order and refuse to answer the phone. If you dont wanna work your whole shift then change your hours
Food: 5
Service: 1
Ordered extra sauces (pizza and spicy Garlic) and didn't receive. Hoagie was very dry and olives were ordered for the papadia and as you can see there were maybe 2.
Food: 2
Service: 2
Really really nice staff. Knowledgeable. I would definitely return to this store even if it were out of my way.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5