Not your typical pizza very bready, pleasantly sweet, decadent toppings.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ken Brown
Awesome pizza, for being carry out i order online 1 hour ahead of time, and arrived on time but had to wait 20 minutes to get my pizza
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Teresa Bichsel
Delish! We just got our regular pizza combo of pepperoni,sausage and mushrooms. Red sauce has a little heat, but that's fine. The House Salad was awesome. Very pleasant experience!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jim Conger
Hand tossed crust. Spicy sauce. Great toppings. Don't forget to try the fresh salads.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Peppercorn Ranch Salad, House Candied Walnut & Grape and Peppercorn Ranch, Bronx Bomber, Porky Fig Pizza, Meatball, Dewey's Original
Allen Jones
Decent. Might have been my mistake by getting two half and half pizzas, but didn't have much flavor. Red sauce may or may not just be the same as the chef boyardee pizza kit we made as kids. Good beer selection. Easy to get a table. The large window to the kitchen is nice so that kids can watch the dough get tossed. Don't hate it, didn't love it.
Recommended dishes: Peppercorn Ranch Salad, Dr Dre
Nick S.
Dewey's offers reasonably priced pies with numerous options to mix and match by doing a "half and half." The 17inch pie is pictured. I believe the one on the right with ham and pickles was called the Cuban. It seemed to be a special option that will be offered for only a limited time. It was definitely the star of the night and reminded me of a traditional Cuban sandwich. The Bronx Bomber was more in the style of a traditional supreme pizza. It was ok, but I felt it was lacking a bit in flavor. The sausage in particular was too mild for my taste, although others may like that it's not too spicy. Both pies had a fantastic crust and a nice crunch to them. Service was great and we could definitely sense the friendly demeanor of the employees. Overall, Dewey's offers great pizza options and great service. I'll be back to try more combinations.
Joe Polidore
Great pie in the middle of Ohio. Who would've thunk? Don Corleon on point. I will be back.
They have the greatest smell when you walk in. There is nothing quite like real pizza dough rising and cooking. Yum.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Mark Toscano
Old world, New York style pizza with a Midwest flair. I love the pizza here, it's a comforting reminder of growing up on the east coast combined with really interesting topping combinations. It's our go to, favorite pizza in Columbus.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Don Corleone, House Salad, Caprice, Bronx Bomber, Meatball, Porky Fig Pizza
JD Hook
The last two times I have ordered have had to wait 15 min past confirmed pickup time. Today it was clearly cold when they brought it to car. Made me late for a meeting and not even a “we are sorry for the wait.” When paying a premium for Za expect better.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 3
Service: 2
Michael Mahaffey
Consistently great pizza & salad with lettuce that’s green (which seems to be hard to find these days)
Food: 5
K Miller
Picked up a Bleu Ribbon gluten-free pizza. The various flavors were delicious. A little lacking on toppings. The crust was good, though a little chewy on the outer inch. I would get again.
Not your typical pizza very bready, pleasantly sweet, decadent toppings.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Awesome pizza, for being carry out i order online 1 hour ahead of time, and arrived on time but had to wait 20 minutes to get my pizza
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Delish! We just got our regular pizza combo of pepperoni,sausage and mushrooms. Red sauce has a little heat, but that's fine. The House Salad was awesome. Very pleasant experience!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Hand tossed crust. Spicy sauce. Great toppings. Don't forget to try the fresh salads.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Peppercorn Ranch Salad, House Candied Walnut & Grape and Peppercorn Ranch, Bronx Bomber, Porky Fig Pizza, Meatball, Dewey's Original
Decent. Might have been my mistake by getting two half and half pizzas, but didn't have much flavor. Red sauce may or may not just be the same as the chef boyardee pizza kit we made as kids. Good beer selection. Easy to get a table. The large window to the kitchen is nice so that kids can watch the dough get tossed. Don't hate it, didn't love it.
Great pizza! I just wish they had delivery!
Great food and service as always!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Peppercorn Ranch Salad, Buffalo Chicken Pizza, Bronx Bomber
Vegetarian options: MultipleDietary restrictions: Gluten free pizza
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Peppercorn Ranch Salad, Dr Dre
Dewey's offers reasonably priced pies with numerous options to mix and match by doing a "half and half." The 17inch pie is pictured. I believe the one on the right with ham and pickles was called the Cuban. It seemed to be a special option that will be offered for only a limited time. It was definitely the star of the night and reminded me of a traditional Cuban sandwich. The Bronx Bomber was more in the style of a traditional supreme pizza. It was ok, but I felt it was lacking a bit in flavor. The sausage in particular was too mild for my taste, although others may like that it's not too spicy. Both pies had a fantastic crust and a nice crunch to them. Service was great and we could definitely sense the friendly demeanor of the employees. Overall, Dewey's offers great pizza options and great service. I'll be back to try more combinations.
Great pie in the middle of Ohio. Who would've thunk? Don Corleon on point. I will be back.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Don Corleone
Restaurantji Recommends
They have the greatest smell when you walk in. There is nothing quite like real pizza dough rising and cooking. Yum.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Old world, New York style pizza with a Midwest flair. I love the pizza here, it's a comforting reminder of growing up on the east coast combined with really interesting topping combinations. It's our go to, favorite pizza in Columbus.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Don Corleone, House Salad, Caprice, Bronx Bomber, Meatball, Porky Fig Pizza
The last two times I have ordered have had to wait 15 min past confirmed pickup time. Today it was clearly cold when they brought it to car. Made me late for a meeting and not even a “we are sorry for the wait.” When paying a premium for Za expect better.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 3
Service: 2
Consistently great pizza & salad with lettuce that’s green (which seems to be hard to find these days)
Food: 5
Picked up a Bleu Ribbon gluten-free pizza. The various flavors were delicious. A little lacking on toppings. The crust was good, though a little chewy on the outer inch. I would get again.
Food: 4
Recommended dishes: 12 Gluten-Free Crust