J. Alexander's Restaurant

4000 Stelzer Rd, Columbus
(614) 476-8348

Recent Reviews

Jacob S.

Have been to this establishment before, but at a different location. You absolutely cannot go wrong with the chicken strips. This portion size is huge! Great flavor, crisp tenders juicy chicken. The Mac n cheese was awesome! Overall nice interior, great service. We had a bit of a wait, but it was to be expected for a Saturday evening in Easton.

SaluteDabadd1YaDigg “Kells SaluteDabadd1yadigg”

You gotta check on take out!! I ordered a salad to go and had no croutons, so I went back in to ask for them.. they gave me some but not the cornbread ones that the salad is supposed to come with!Food is too expensive here to be getting it wrong!! Maintain your in-house standard!!!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 3

Service: 4

Joshua Jones

Calamari was basic......no tentacles....Prime rib was bland at best.....no bread or salad served with entree..server definitely hated her job....0 enthusiasm.......kitchen staff was very polite when I walked by. But won't be back.....39.99 bland prime rib......

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 2

Service: 1

Regina Tiano

Fall apart ribs to dream about! Wait staff was very friendly and eager to make your dining xperience enjoyable.

Maple S.

Ordered a steak and fries, asked for rare...received well done steak. Terrible way to spend $38.

Sandi O.

Went for a very special birthday and didn't want to make a fuss there and ruin the evening...but no one received a steak cooked to order. Steak for steak frites was WAY overcooked. My filet was almost purple and not a warm red center. I ordered a cosmo and it was way too strong. Spent $250 for a very average meal. Salads were exceptional, but not enough to make up for the steaks. Sad to see a good restaurant going downhill.

Phil Edelsberg

Never received the coffee my wife ordered, fortunately it was not included on our bill.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Slow Roasted Prime Rib

Linda Wilson

Best prime rib I've had in decades! Nice super thick cut... Lots of flavor... Very minimal fat. Smashed red skin potatoes were delicious too.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 4

Cassandra Palmieri

Nick was our server tonight, let me just start by saying wow, he was so kind and professional! He made the experience so good for my husband and I on our date night!Also the food was delish!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Judy C.

The food and service is excellent.I could only give 4 stars because the steak is well seasoned,but the chicken is too dry for me,The coleslaw taste like they had just opened a bag of slaw mix and threw some dressing on it. Keep in mind this has been over three visits,mainly for birthdays.I do like this place for dining out,but,I am just going to stay away from the coleslaw and boneless chicken.

teresa jeffers

I have always loved to go to j alexander's...until now. The steak maui was great; however, the not so ordinary mac and cheese was AWFUL. It used to be creamy and cheesy. This time the mac and cheese was dry and tasteless. The smashed potatoes weren't up to par either. I was very disappointed in the meal. At these prices, the quality should not be this low.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 2

Service: 3

Recommended dishes: Steak Maui

Janice G.

Tried the Cajun cod and it was perfectly prepared. Couscous was a bit overdone. Coleslaw was excellent. Good service by several so never sure who was waiting on me. Light lunch crowd the day I visited.

Jerry Feng

Low and slow cooked steaks are really great! Totally just takes steak to a whole new level! The crab cakes were very good! Unexpectedly firm meat, not a lot of flour coating at all, which was nice!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Tim R.

Horrible bar service! One should not beg to order and and later beg to pay (wait way too long). During ordering time bar was 70% packed, so I was patient; but one bartender disappeared and a lazy waiter walked over a couple with a to go order as I was trying to order. Was not busy when I was trying to pay. Minimal management oversight. The food's good if you can get it and don't expect to leave when you want.

Sheila Gossett

California roll and prime rib were very good. Our server was the best. Will definitely go back.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Slow Roasted Prime Rib, Roll

Load More