I stopped by to grab some lunch and I was not disappointed! What an incredibly freindly atmosphere they have here. From being greeted upon entering, to mentioning they are there to answer any questions, and being thanked upon leaving. The service itself already makes me want to return.The food was delicious. They have many offerings: grab and go meals, desserts to go (bars, cookies, etc.), and sandwiches/salads that are freshly prepared. I ordered the chicken pesto sandwich ($9). The chicken wrap looked equally tasty and I will get that next time. The sandwich did not shy from chicken or pesto. It was very filling and tasted fresh. I also got the lemon bar and blueberry bar. Both were tasty. For the blueberry bar, I recommend heating it up for 20 seconds before eating. It was a game changer for me. They have weekly specials for their grab and go meals and desserts. Join their Facebook page to view the most updated weekly offerings. Overall, a high quality food and friendly local business. It is also woman owned, which is amazing. I will definitely be back to try other items and get some grab and go meals too.
Harvey Rossetti
Wow!! Was told about this place from a lifetime friend. What a wonderful establishment, prepared food to take home and heat up. Baked goods were wonderful too.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Turkey, Chicken Salad
Amanda Lute
We pick up salads from Preston Eatery once per week and we are always happy! They have high quality and great tasting salads and friendly staff. My kids always want to add one of their handmade bakery items and those are really good too. I recommend this place to everyone in the area who likes a good salad!
We ordered 10 subs for a Pickle Ball, 75 th Birthday party and they were delicious! All the trimmings on the side packaged very safe! We will definitely call on Preston's for catering needs in the future!
Kim Roche
Kim Roche
I have NEVER been disappointed with anything I have purchased at Preston Eatery. Quality ingredients and creative quality chefs makes for amazing meals and happy customers! :) The Hummus is the best I have ever had!! Thank you for always giving your customers your very best!!!
Brad Jenkins
I am seriously impressed with the food here. Very friendly owners as well. All of the positive reviews are true. You can sign up for their Sunday night e-mail to see what will be on the menu for the week. Most of it changes every week, but they keep certain dishes on the menu every week. The chicken salad is some of the best I have found anywhere in Columbus and the key lime pie bar is my new favorite dessert.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicken Salad
Emily K.
Food is so delicious but my only complaint is that everything tastes like it's loaded in salt. Even my kids think it's too salty.
Ali Achour
Great high quality fresh food with good prices and very friendly people!
Their take and heat meals are an absolute life-saver. They are perfect for when you aren't going to be able to cook meals (or don't want to). They may be pre-made but they are still very fresh and nutritious; cheaper than eating out at a restaurant; BETTER than many meals at restaurants (If you see the Italian pot roast-- get it!); and far, far better than grocery store pre-made or frozen meals. They rotate to a different selection each week, so there is always something new to try. It's worth ordering a salad to take home while you are there. And, as an added plus, the desserts are amazing. I highly recommend the carrot cake and peanut butter bar.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Kelly C.
Delicious sandwiches! Order a sandwich to go, especially the chicken pesto or Italian sub
Karli Kididis
Wow! This place delivers! I came in for the first time on a Monday and they were busy. I grabbed my meals from the coolers and it was so easy. I'm partnered with a chef and even he did a double thumbs up. We will be back.
Laura Esterline
Wow different menu weeklyGreat food Reasonable priceAsked for no mushrooms and they made it
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Michael G.
Absolutely delicious food. Everything is very fresh and flavorful. We stumbled on Preston while visiting from out of town, and made a point to return a second time just so we could try other things. Whether it was the variety of salads, or the Italian sub I tried the second time, we found everything to be very flavorful. And then the desserts. The carrot cake may be the best I've ever had. On our second visit we tried the Texas sheet cake, another piece of carrot cake and a Buckeye bar, which I now find myself craving ever since. This is a small place that appears to mainly serve carry out and grab and go prepared meals and items that could be taken home and heated, and they all looked great as well. On top of it all, the people working there were among the most friendly and accommodating folks I've ever encountered. This is truly an exceptional establishment and we will certainly return on future visits to Columbus.
I'd drive hours for the Chicken Pesto
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicken Pesto
I stopped by to grab some lunch and I was not disappointed! What an incredibly freindly atmosphere they have here. From being greeted upon entering, to mentioning they are there to answer any questions, and being thanked upon leaving. The service itself already makes me want to return.The food was delicious. They have many offerings: grab and go meals, desserts to go (bars, cookies, etc.), and sandwiches/salads that are freshly prepared. I ordered the chicken pesto sandwich ($9). The chicken wrap looked equally tasty and I will get that next time. The sandwich did not shy from chicken or pesto. It was very filling and tasted fresh. I also got the lemon bar and blueberry bar. Both were tasty. For the blueberry bar, I recommend heating it up for 20 seconds before eating. It was a game changer for me. They have weekly specials for their grab and go meals and desserts. Join their Facebook page to view the most updated weekly offerings. Overall, a high quality food and friendly local business. It is also woman owned, which is amazing. I will definitely be back to try other items and get some grab and go meals too.
Wow!! Was told about this place from a lifetime friend. What a wonderful establishment, prepared food to take home and heat up. Baked goods were wonderful too.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Turkey, Chicken Salad
We pick up salads from Preston Eatery once per week and we are always happy! They have high quality and great tasting salads and friendly staff. My kids always want to add one of their handmade bakery items and those are really good too. I recommend this place to everyone in the area who likes a good salad!
Can't be beat!!!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicken Salad, Carrot Cake, Roast Beef Focaccia, Chicken Caesar Salad Wrap
We ordered 10 subs for a Pickle Ball, 75 th Birthday party and they were delicious! All the trimmings on the side packaged very safe! We will definitely call on Preston's for catering needs in the future!
Kim Roche I have NEVER been disappointed with anything I have purchased at Preston Eatery. Quality ingredients and creative quality chefs makes for amazing meals and happy customers! :) The Hummus is the best I have ever had!! Thank you for always giving your customers your very best!!!
I am seriously impressed with the food here. Very friendly owners as well. All of the positive reviews are true. You can sign up for their Sunday night e-mail to see what will be on the menu for the week. Most of it changes every week, but they keep certain dishes on the menu every week. The chicken salad is some of the best I have found anywhere in Columbus and the key lime pie bar is my new favorite dessert.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicken Salad
Food is so delicious but my only complaint is that everything tastes like it's loaded in salt. Even my kids think it's too salty.
Great high quality fresh food with good prices and very friendly people!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Their take and heat meals are an absolute life-saver. They are perfect for when you aren't going to be able to cook meals (or don't want to). They may be pre-made but they are still very fresh and nutritious; cheaper than eating out at a restaurant; BETTER than many meals at restaurants (If you see the Italian pot roast-- get it!); and far, far better than grocery store pre-made or frozen meals. They rotate to a different selection each week, so there is always something new to try. It's worth ordering a salad to take home while you are there. And, as an added plus, the desserts are amazing. I highly recommend the carrot cake and peanut butter bar.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Delicious sandwiches! Order a sandwich to go, especially the chicken pesto or Italian sub
Wow! This place delivers! I came in for the first time on a Monday and they were busy. I grabbed my meals from the coolers and it was so easy. I'm partnered with a chef and even he did a double thumbs up. We will be back.
Wow different menu weeklyGreat food Reasonable priceAsked for no mushrooms and they made it
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Absolutely delicious food. Everything is very fresh and flavorful. We stumbled on Preston while visiting from out of town, and made a point to return a second time just so we could try other things. Whether it was the variety of salads, or the Italian sub I tried the second time, we found everything to be very flavorful. And then the desserts. The carrot cake may be the best I've ever had. On our second visit we tried the Texas sheet cake, another piece of carrot cake and a Buckeye bar, which I now find myself craving ever since. This is a small place that appears to mainly serve carry out and grab and go prepared meals and items that could be taken home and heated, and they all looked great as well. On top of it all, the people working there were among the most friendly and accommodating folks I've ever encountered. This is truly an exceptional establishment and we will certainly return on future visits to Columbus.