18 Best Pizza Restaurants near Creston

“Warm and friendly in a small town rich in history.Sitting near the Sterling Crossover Railroad Crash site.The food is good and the staff is great, with a nice variety of choices on their menu all affordable priced.Tables and booths are surrounded by historic photos and has a nice railroad vibe. The site is an actual historic building.“

“Our band stopped and ate here after show in Cleveland. The food was homemade and delicious. Great portions and flavor and attention to detail. Service was that good old school service- Friendly and thorough and thoughtful! Would highly recommend and would definitely return“

“THIS PIZZA WAS AMAZING!We shared the meat lovers and the crust was so good (fresh made dough) it was unlike any other. The toppings were abundant and the flavor exceptional. The restaurant was quaint and the service was friendly. Very busy also.It's my favorite pizza so far!Ya GOTTA TRY IT.“

“The Village Inn in Chippewa Lake is always a fun time. They recently underwent a major renovation which included adding more beer taps! Great local place to enjoy craft beer with friends. They have a patio with picnic tables and cornhole. They have 2 pool tables. They have live music. Back door entrance is handicap accessible. After a long day on the lake, this is a great place to grab dinner!Parking: New blacktop this year!Wheelchair accessibility: Back door is wheelchair accessible.“

“Today I had the pleasure of being introduced to contessa in the lake. I was questioning the location because I had simply never seen it before. Upon arriving the indoor was inviting and the aroma outside was astounding and had my mouth watering, on the phone the wait time was expected to be 25 minutes but when I arrived in 15 they had almost everything ready. Service was exceptional. The staff was friendly and when the man behind the pizza window said merry Christmas and smiled I really felt like he meant it. All in all, 10/10 highly recommend“

“I have ordered pizza, chicken and JoJo's loved pizza and the chicken is delish! JoJo's are good but wish they would cut a bit thicker and batter them a bit more but they are great! Chicken comes golden brown, it seems they change their oil more often then some of these other places here in town.. Thw parking isn't great.. but you can always park on the side of the building and the lady and gentlemen that work the pick up are so kind! Keep up the great service..“

“We've been in this area for 1 and a half years and this is, hands down, the best pizza we've found! We didn't care for the white pizza sauce but the red is perfect. Good prices, accurate orders, friendly workers, and the perfect pie. What more could you want? We'll be trying other meni items in the future.“

“Was in town for sons baseball game I was hungry got the pepperoni power house pizza ? and it honestly has to be in the top five pizzas I have ever had. It was very good I was very happy with it we'll definitely go back two thumbs up for sure ??????“

“First timer, excellent!! My husband is a pizza particular guy. Tavanello’s gets 5 stars from him!! ? This crust was crispy, flavorful and the ingredients very good! We will be back! Buy local! ❤️ I would add a photo but it is all gone! ?“

“Excellent pizza! Pricey but great. Take out only. No walk up orders. You MUST order by phone. Their large pizza is thick but about the same diameter as most pizza shops small or medium. They do put a good amount of excellent cheese on their pizza.“

“Employees are very nice, and make you feel you matter as a customer. Any time I experienced an "issue" they were quick to correct it and make it right. One of my pizza's came out burnt once and they put a new one in, they noticed it before giving it to me.“

“Picked up a pizza to take to Silver Creek and enjoy by the lake for dinner. Crust was crispy and not too thick with good flavor. Sauce was a little sweet and a little savory, with a great selection of toppings. Would definitely go again when in the area!Parking: Decent availability of street parking to quickly pick up orders“

“This buffet was fantastic. I usually order boscos in wooster. My girlfriend and I were out and about with our kids and we decided to look for a pizza buffet and we found this boscos pizza buffet and since I already knew boscos has fantastic pizza we decided to go here. This was a fantastic choice. The pizza was fresh and the same tasty quality on the buffet as if you just ordered a pizza. All the items on the salad bar were fresh and fantastic. They also have plenty of toppings for the salad bar. The price includes pizza and salad bar and your drink. I wish they would put a buffet at the boscos in wooster. The employees were super friendly and attentive. The fountain drinks tasted fresh and like they were supposed to. There is plenty of parking. I would definitely recommend stopping by if your in the area. Or take a trip to grab a bite. Either way its well worth it. You won't be disappointed. And you definitely won't leave hungry. Thank you boscos for such a fantastic dining experience my family and I definitely enjoyed our experience.Wheelchair accessibility: There is a wheel chair accessible ramp and a sitting area near the buffet.“

“A wonderful establishment. The customer service was next level. I had a very long day at work and came in to order pizza late at night and this store treated me like I was family. The guy behind the counter was new, but he did his job very well, and served me with a smile. Would recommend. 10/10“

“We had 2 bad delivery and service issues after Guys has been our go to for many years for pizza and wings. After the last one a few weeks back I decided to write a bad review.. After that review John the manager reached out to letting me know he addressed the issues and hoped that we would be back some day. He gave me a $50 credit for my troubles which we decided to use a few weeks later. Father order was perfect, the food was good and the order was correct. Thanks John for making this right. I removed the bad review.“

“I really like the hand made pan crust for a pizza. The rewards program isn't all that bad either. Employees there are polite. I have not had any incorrect orders made online, phone, or had any problems with pick up, curb, or delivery service.“

“Ordered pizza and cheesy garlic bread last night and it was so GOOD! We probably order from the Orrville location once every other month and have literally never had a bad experience. Our order is always correct, ready for pick-up at the time we are given and it is consistently hot. The employees are friendly and professional. Thanks Orrville East of Chicago!!“

“Wow, ordered for delivery to the truck stop. Talk about quick and friendly service. Great food, great prices and extremely fast. Omg the crust on the pan pizza is by far the best I've ever had. Wow. Look forward to returning and having it “