The Rutherford Café

Name: The Rutherford Café
Address: 9 E William St, Delaware, Ohio, 43015, US
Telephone: (740) 990-0085
Price range: $$
Rating: 4.6

$$ • Sandwich Shops, Salad

Hours:
9 E William St, Delaware
(740) 990-0085

Menu Order Online

Take-Out/Delivery Options

delivery

take-out

Customers' Favorites

Smoked Sausage

Sunshine Salad

The Rutherford Café Reviews

4.6 (54)

Write a review

December 2023

Located on Williams St just east of Sandusky St, next to the BP. There is paid public parking on the other side of the BP. Good food, made to order. A half of a sandwich with a fountain drink came to $11 after the tip.

August 2023

All you're missing in life is the Smokey Sandusky sandwich! My daughter enjoyed her grilled cheese while the adults put away three Smokey Sandusky sandwiches! Enjoyed every bite. If you haven't had Lebanon bologna before this would be a whole new experience. We love to buy it in Amish country to use on charcuterie boards at home. The horseradish pickles don't taste much like horseradish, they are just so good. The cafe is small so you might have to wait for a seat, but it's Order-at-the-counter...read full review

July 2023

I will miss this beautiful little spot more than most now that I'm no longer working in the area. The sandwiches and salads are wonderful and wonderfully priced. Everything I've ordered from here has been packed full and tasty. The owners are superb and work the line along with their staff. Super friendly and informative when asking about menu items. Everything is customizable, and yet your food comes quickly. I'll always try to stop back next time I'm in Delaware!

More Reviews(57)