New to the area and it being Easter we kept finding places were closed. Pizza definitely wasn't what we were hoping for BUT I'm so happy we wound up here. Prices are on the higher side but the quality of the food made it 100% worth it. My husband got the wings and couldn't quite figure out what seasoning made them taste a little different than most buffalo wings but said they were delicious! We had 3 types of pizza and the cheese bread also and absolutely nothing disappointed. We did not realize that it's more of a take out place but they did have a small area for us to eat. Small selection of soda to choose from but again it's geared more towards take out. Customer service was excellent as well!
Jason McMahon
Horrible pie.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
DKL
Second time this happened so they are 2 for 4 on accuracy. ordered a couple chef salads and not once but twice they only put the pepperoni on it. Will probably not go back. Giving 2 stars because when its correct, its good.
Justin D.
I thought this pizza was very good! The crust and cheese were great and the sauce was also good. Personally I felt the sauce tasted a bit artificial and not as fresh, but I personally think that the sauce is the best part of the pizza. This was a good pizza to get consistently and the price was reasonable.
Daniel A.
This was my first time trying Brenz, I was more impressed by the service it self, I walked in to see if the sold by the slice because I wanted to try it but definitely did not want a whole pizza. The employee at the counter told me they did not, but they did offer a personal size, so I opted for that. I decided to get the BBQ Chicken version of that. I waited about 7bto 10 min, and he brought it right over to me he even asked if I needed a plate and napkins, and I did. It was really good the best way to describe the crust is a cross between hand tossed and thin crust. It's definitely not thick at all, which is more what I like, but it's also not paper thin like Donatos or Imos where I'm from, haha. So it's kinda right between it was good. The topping kind of piles up due to that. I didn't get a chance to ask, but the BBQ sauce seems unique. I do not know if that's their own or if it's something they buy, but it's yummy!!! So my first experience was great. I would definitely recommend it for my personal size it was $10. If this review helped you at all, please mark as helpful and follow me for more reviews around the world.
Olivia Carter
We've had Brenz several times from different locations and are never disappointed! One of the best pizza places in Columbus. The crust is so flavorful, and I love that they have a wide variety of unique specialty pizzas! The Heater is a family favorite. We tried their cookies for the first time, and they were fabulous! They're soft-baked, which I prefer.There's not much seating at this location - just counters and two small tables - so keep that in mind if you plan to eat in.The service was fantastic! The staff is super friendly, and our food came out very quickly, especially considering we hadn't ordered ahead.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Mel D
Delicious pizza for all at brenz everytime! They make their pizza ranging from Personal size 8" to 16" pizza in a variety of delicious bases and the crust choices are regular, gluten-free, or diary free. You can have your pizza the way you like it. Get a little cheese, lots of cheese, or no cheese. Oh my and for dessert, try a yummy chocolate chip cookie. I like mine warmed just until the chocolate starts to melt. It is soooo... good.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza with Extra Sauce
Heather Gortz
The bruschetta pizza was bland. No garlic and toppings were sparce. Kiss like the pepperoni ? but I don't know if I would try
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 5
kelli k
I ordered the small citrus salad through Relish delivery program at work.It had Romain, Mandarin oranges, almonds, croutons, feta cheese and a spicy citrus dressing.I'm didn't realize there were almonds in the salad until I read the list of ingredients again before writing this...so not sure if they weren't included or such a minimal amount they weren't reflected in the flavor.The croutons are more than I like in a salad, the flavors were nice together and the dressing is really good. So glad they allow you to put it on, as I only needed half of the container for my small salad.I would definitely try them again and if in the area - stop in for a nice meal.Vegetarian options: Pizza and salad options.Dietary restrictions: Several optionsParking: Lots of spots that I can seeKid-friendliness: Lots of pizza options
Food: 3
Recommended dishes: Side Salad
Joe Mamlin
Once again got my order wrong. I was looking forward to it and it was a big disappointment. That was the last chance. Check it carefully and ask questions before you leave.
I just picked up The Heater. Have to say I am impressed this is the best pizza I have found since moving to Columbus.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Premium Pizza
Randy S.
The pizza was delicious but expensive. When we picked it up, the place looked super clean. We will definitely be going back from time to time when we can get some coupons.
Caroline Smith
I come to this location often, the people are so incredibly friendly. Every time, the pizza is always the best, and recently I stopped to get some pizza for a work party, and they let us take a mistake pizza home, which really made the day for some of my back of the house workers. This is the best location to order from, the guys at the register are so nice!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Premium Pizza
Monica Benavides
The best pizza in
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Heritage Honey Pizza
Tom B.
We ordered pizza delivery. The pizza was pretty good. Not great but solid. We'll be back.
New to the area and it being Easter we kept finding places were closed. Pizza definitely wasn't what we were hoping for BUT I'm so happy we wound up here. Prices are on the higher side but the quality of the food made it 100% worth it. My husband got the wings and couldn't quite figure out what seasoning made them taste a little different than most buffalo wings but said they were delicious! We had 3 types of pizza and the cheese bread also and absolutely nothing disappointed. We did not realize that it's more of a take out place but they did have a small area for us to eat. Small selection of soda to choose from but again it's geared more towards take out. Customer service was excellent as well!
Horrible pie.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Second time this happened so they are 2 for 4 on accuracy. ordered a couple chef salads and not once but twice they only put the pepperoni on it. Will probably not go back. Giving 2 stars because when its correct, its good.
I thought this pizza was very good! The crust and cheese were great and the sauce was also good. Personally I felt the sauce tasted a bit artificial and not as fresh, but I personally think that the sauce is the best part of the pizza. This was a good pizza to get consistently and the price was reasonable.
This was my first time trying Brenz, I was more impressed by the service it self, I walked in to see if the sold by the slice because I wanted to try it but definitely did not want a whole pizza. The employee at the counter told me they did not, but they did offer a personal size, so I opted for that. I decided to get the BBQ Chicken version of that. I waited about 7bto 10 min, and he brought it right over to me he even asked if I needed a plate and napkins, and I did. It was really good the best way to describe the crust is a cross between hand tossed and thin crust. It's definitely not thick at all, which is more what I like, but it's also not paper thin like Donatos or Imos where I'm from, haha. So it's kinda right between it was good. The topping kind of piles up due to that. I didn't get a chance to ask, but the BBQ sauce seems unique. I do not know if that's their own or if it's something they buy, but it's yummy!!! So my first experience was great. I would definitely recommend it for my personal size it was $10. If this review helped you at all, please mark as helpful and follow me for more reviews around the world.
We've had Brenz several times from different locations and are never disappointed! One of the best pizza places in Columbus. The crust is so flavorful, and I love that they have a wide variety of unique specialty pizzas! The Heater is a family favorite. We tried their cookies for the first time, and they were fabulous! They're soft-baked, which I prefer.There's not much seating at this location - just counters and two small tables - so keep that in mind if you plan to eat in.The service was fantastic! The staff is super friendly, and our food came out very quickly, especially considering we hadn't ordered ahead.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Delicious pizza for all at brenz everytime! They make their pizza ranging from Personal size 8" to 16" pizza in a variety of delicious bases and the crust choices are regular, gluten-free, or diary free. You can have your pizza the way you like it. Get a little cheese, lots of cheese, or no cheese. Oh my and for dessert, try a yummy chocolate chip cookie. I like mine warmed just until the chocolate starts to melt. It is soooo... good.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza with Extra Sauce
The bruschetta pizza was bland. No garlic and toppings were sparce. Kiss like the pepperoni ? but I don't know if I would try
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 5
I ordered the small citrus salad through Relish delivery program at work.It had Romain, Mandarin oranges, almonds, croutons, feta cheese and a spicy citrus dressing.I'm didn't realize there were almonds in the salad until I read the list of ingredients again before writing this...so not sure if they weren't included or such a minimal amount they weren't reflected in the flavor.The croutons are more than I like in a salad, the flavors were nice together and the dressing is really good. So glad they allow you to put it on, as I only needed half of the container for my small salad.I would definitely try them again and if in the area - stop in for a nice meal.Vegetarian options: Pizza and salad options.Dietary restrictions: Several optionsParking: Lots of spots that I can seeKid-friendliness: Lots of pizza options
Food: 3
Recommended dishes: Side Salad
Once again got my order wrong. I was looking forward to it and it was a big disappointment. That was the last chance. Check it carefully and ask questions before you leave.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Restaurantji Recommends
I just picked up The Heater. Have to say I am impressed this is the best pizza I have found since moving to Columbus.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Premium Pizza
The pizza was delicious but expensive. When we picked it up, the place looked super clean. We will definitely be going back from time to time when we can get some coupons.
I come to this location often, the people are so incredibly friendly. Every time, the pizza is always the best, and recently I stopped to get some pizza for a work party, and they let us take a mistake pizza home, which really made the day for some of my back of the house workers. This is the best location to order from, the guys at the register are so nice!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Premium Pizza
The best pizza in
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Heritage Honey Pizza
We ordered pizza delivery. The pizza was pretty good. Not great but solid. We'll be back.