Usually have nothing but great things to say food is usually on point but last 2 times ive ordered had a bit of an issue first time pizza was a bit over cooked pepperoni was black along the edge of the pizza but i get it lots of orders s*** happens last time took 55 min for my order to arrive food was cold delivery guy dropping s*** on the ground. Im not one to usually b**** and complain but i spend 35 to 50 min everytime i order so i would like them to put just a little more effort in as well just saying
Carly Elizabeth
I can't overstate how great my family's experience with Carlucci's was. The pizza was delivered much earlier than estimated, it was LOADED with toppings, and cooked perfectly. The mozzarella sticks and dipping sauce were the perfectly complement to the meal, and the brownies were to die for-warm, even 20 minutes after delivery, moist, and delicious. The whole family was impressed, and we will definitely be ordering from here again!
Soff
Consistently high-quality. The Ezzo pepperoni is crispy and charred with a lot of flavor, medium spiciness. The sauce might be homemade, it's very tomato-y (as opposed to overly sweet or salty) and has a great flavor. The herbs on the pizza give it a great taste. Cheese is great. Never had a problem with the pizza or the delivery. Great stuff!
Chelsea D.
Very good pizza. Nice crisp and chew. Love the crumbled sausage it was amazing!! Good seasoning!
Maids Superior LLC
You must be born here, otherwise if you have a small accent they will not understand, even if you used A for apple C for Charlie, B for boy etc. They can't understand people with any accents. I have to spelled my street 5 times to an associate and was transferred to a manager..still couldn't order. Wow!
Mary Kate Cullen
WOW WOW WOW! I moved to Columbus from Chicago a few years ago and have been on the hunt for a good pizza place ever since then. Carlucci’s is it! The crust is deliciously thin and crispy, there is just the right amount of sauce and the herb/parm sprinkle on top adds a perfect pop of flavor. I will definitely be coming back for more!
Christopher Haritos
Simply very tasty pizza. Excited to go back!
Aleks Rapovski
The pizza and Stromboli we ordered was amazing. The ingredients are fresh and the pepperoni is to die for! Definitely will order again!
Jim
The salads here are excellent, well, maybe too many banana peppers. The pizza was very good, but had very little sauce on it. I definitely will be a frequent customer. Looking forward to trying the lasagna next time. The hours that they are open seem to vary, maybe a staffing problem.
CJ jackson
Great old school pizza near hotels and the columbus zoo reasonable prices and great tasting food ??highly recommended
Absolutely fantastic Pizza! They use Ezzo pepperoni (made in Columbus)! Well seasoned sauce, Light, crunchy, airy crust. Really something awesome, you can't go wrong here.
Darius D.
We moved to Hilliard from Grandview last December and tried here by chance. Best decision we could have made. It's the best pizza in Columbus and it's not even close. We have ordered it almost weekly since then. Fresh ingredients and the dough it's crispy as a cracker
Jmob Jmob
My favorite pizza in this area hands down. Their wings are great as well as the stromboli. You can’t beat their $9.99 one top special on Monday nights either!!!
Danielle M.
This spot has amazing pizza and specials. Their pizza is more New York style with a thinner crust that is cut into squares. The pizza we ordered was covered crust to crust with topping, they definitely don't skimp on the toppings. They also office a yummy GF/Cauliflower crust pizza as well, it is definitely on the small size. I could probably eat the whole pizza myself but usually share with my daughter. You can also preorder your pizza online and have it ordered to your place when you want it to. We have had the pizza arrive 20 minutes early several times we have ordered it. Overall a great place to order pizza!
Usually have nothing but great things to say food is usually on point but last 2 times ive ordered had a bit of an issue first time pizza was a bit over cooked pepperoni was black along the edge of the pizza but i get it lots of orders s*** happens last time took 55 min for my order to arrive food was cold delivery guy dropping s*** on the ground. Im not one to usually b**** and complain but i spend 35 to 50 min everytime i order so i would like them to put just a little more effort in as well just saying
I can't overstate how great my family's experience with Carlucci's was. The pizza was delivered much earlier than estimated, it was LOADED with toppings, and cooked perfectly. The mozzarella sticks and dipping sauce were the perfectly complement to the meal, and the brownies were to die for-warm, even 20 minutes after delivery, moist, and delicious. The whole family was impressed, and we will definitely be ordering from here again!
Consistently high-quality. The Ezzo pepperoni is crispy and charred with a lot of flavor, medium spiciness. The sauce might be homemade, it's very tomato-y (as opposed to overly sweet or salty) and has a great flavor. The herbs on the pizza give it a great taste. Cheese is great. Never had a problem with the pizza or the delivery. Great stuff!
Very good pizza. Nice crisp and chew. Love the crumbled sausage it was amazing!! Good seasoning!
You must be born here, otherwise if you have a small accent they will not understand, even if you used A for apple C for Charlie, B for boy etc. They can't understand people with any accents. I have to spelled my street 5 times to an associate and was transferred to a manager..still couldn't order. Wow!
WOW WOW WOW! I moved to Columbus from Chicago a few years ago and have been on the hunt for a good pizza place ever since then. Carlucci’s is it! The crust is deliciously thin and crispy, there is just the right amount of sauce and the herb/parm sprinkle on top adds a perfect pop of flavor. I will definitely be coming back for more!
Simply very tasty pizza. Excited to go back!
The pizza and Stromboli we ordered was amazing. The ingredients are fresh and the pepperoni is to die for! Definitely will order again!
The salads here are excellent, well, maybe too many banana peppers. The pizza was very good, but had very little sauce on it. I definitely will be a frequent customer. Looking forward to trying the lasagna next time. The hours that they are open seem to vary, maybe a staffing problem.
Great old school pizza near hotels and the columbus zoo reasonable prices and great tasting food ??highly recommended
Restaurantji Recommends
This pizza place is amazing...
Absolutely fantastic Pizza! They use Ezzo pepperoni (made in Columbus)! Well seasoned sauce, Light, crunchy, airy crust. Really something awesome, you can't go wrong here.
We moved to Hilliard from Grandview last December and tried here by chance. Best decision we could have made. It's the best pizza in Columbus and it's not even close. We have ordered it almost weekly since then. Fresh ingredients and the dough it's crispy as a cracker
My favorite pizza in this area hands down. Their wings are great as well as the stromboli. You can’t beat their $9.99 one top special on Monday nights either!!!
This spot has amazing pizza and specials. Their pizza is more New York style with a thinner crust that is cut into squares. The pizza we ordered was covered crust to crust with topping, they definitely don't skimp on the toppings. They also office a yummy GF/Cauliflower crust pizza as well, it is definitely on the small size. I could probably eat the whole pizza myself but usually share with my daughter. You can also preorder your pizza online and have it ordered to your place when you want it to. We have had the pizza arrive 20 minutes early several times we have ordered it. Overall a great place to order pizza!