Papa Johns Pizza

1203 N Barron St, Eaton
(937) 472-7272

Recent Reviews

Darcie Walker

AJ is amazing and does such a great job! He is genuinely kind and can problem solve when comments come in such as mine. No need to elaborate on it because it was fixed asap, and he is an asset you want to keep in this world! Thanks AJ!!

Matthew Oldham

Get our food 95% of the time correct and even when they do make a mistake they make up for it with fresh

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Extras

Mark Howard

Waited 2 hours for the pizza. App said 45 minutes. I understand things get busy. But they could’ve picked up the phone when I called. And pretty overpriced. Terrible

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Brenda Miller

We always get great pizza & friendly service at this location, but tonight Marcus went out of his way to be kind & helpful. Highly recommended!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Lisa Greathouse

We love the Eaton Papa Johns. It is always clean and Kristen is just the sweetest. They always welcome us when we go in. All the staff are so nice and friendly. Just a very happy friendly atmosphere.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

i Like Pigs

ABYSMAL SERVICEOrdered 3 pizzas all original crust; all the crusts were flat with no delicious defined ridge around the edge (like the yeast didn’t rise). This is the second time in two weeks this has happened; let it pass the first time. When I called and spoke with the manager he seemed1)shocked that I wanted to return them2) made no effort to apologise3) made no effort to compensate4) looks like he charged me again insteadof refunding the chargeWell done

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 1

DP125

Great food! Great People! Food is always fresh and I never have a complaint!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Beth P

We have always loved Papa John's pizza and still do! But it's irritating when you order 4 dipping sauces and only get 1 !!! Plus, I'm pretty sure you pay $0.75 for each sauce! We are very annoyed at the lack of sauces!

Doyce Rich

Tried 2 of the new Papa Bowls, basically a crustless pizza. Very tasty and made for a nice lunch.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Papadias, Chicken Poppers

JD Zumbrun

It what you expect from Pappa John. There is no dine in. Really enjoyed the chicken parm bites. The pizza is ok. Better than Domino's. The Pappa Tracker doesn't seem to work at this location tho. Just before I picked up my already done order the Tracker still said it was in the making stage.Wheelchair accessibility: Wide door but not automatic.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: BBQ Wings

Hunter Delk

Food is always pretty good here for what it is also on the app being able to save up points for real money is awesome definitely would

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Julia Staggs

Carry out on time fresh and nice people work inside

715courtneyv

Ordered pizza and breadsticks tonight, and it was awesome! Very fresh, and time spent making the order. There was a bad snowstorm today, and I appreciate that this store went above and beyond on a day like this. Merry Christmas!!

Denise Grant

Great service, pizza was just like it?? ? ? ?

Liz Hogbin

Cory was my driver and he was extremely polite!The pizza was amazing especially the Buffalo chicken ? ? ? ?

Load More