Old Familiar Ways

312 High St, Fairport Harbor
(440) 840-9899

Recent Reviews

Susan P.

Wonderful customer service. Unique store with great gift ideas! Great selection of teas!

Jamie Ferritto

Great little shop to visit. Very friendly. Definitely recommend ?

Caillie Meils

This place is an absolute gem. I go there often to buy teas and the owner, Patty, is very knowledgeable and helpful with herbal remedies. I recommend this place all of the time to family and friends. The teas are delicious and so helpful particularly the cold and flu tea is a staple in our household during the winter months. The herbs you can buy in bulk there are fantastic and many can't be found in other local stores. I hope it'll be around for many years to come as it's a truly unique store which is what the world needs more of.

Kimberly Wilson

Locally owned, owner always in. Great teas, and interesting blends! So many things to see! Bulk herbs, unusual herbs, some metaphysical things, rocks, candles, incense. Smells wonderful in there Go take a look!

Amy Seeds

Great local herb shop! Patty is knowledgeable and her shop is a great local resource to us for herbs and teas!

Nicole

If it’s an herb or herbal tea you need IT IS HERE! Nancy is an LPN and holistic healer I swear. Her hand poured candles are an obsession of mine and I can find my alternative medicine modalities here every time I go. The best part about this place is the conversation. The herbs are always potent and effective, her tea bags are non bleached organic material, she scours the earth for the highest quality ingredients for her signature skincare items and tinctures. Come flu season I swear by only her Elderberry syrup as does the entire town apparently bc she sells out so quickly. Crystals, literature, unique gifts can also be found here.

Andy Curtiss

I cannot say it strongly enough: I. LOVE. THIS. SHOP. The owner is a delight, the teas are nothing short of phenomenal, and you never know what you'll learn next by going in and just browsing and chatting. I miss living in Fairport just to be near! Metaphysical needs, herbal needs, tea needs, reading needs... she's got all of it. AND some kind words to boot!

David Krakauskas

Wonderful shop, large selection of teas and herbs. Candles, Incense, Hand Crafted products, Candles, Gemstones, New Age Products. Shop has so much to offer.

Nice Karen

The owner is friendly and knowledgeable. The teas and seasonings are fresh and delicious.

Erin Hogan

They sell expensive oils but there are no testers there. They have singular ones on the shelves that look like they are testers because there are only one of each scent. If you smell them, you have to buy them. The owner bragged about making a woman buy a whole bunch of different oils for smelling them. They made a lot of money in oil sales that day.She just made me buy a $13 oil because it looked like a tester oil. Then she made snide remarks that I bought my friend already opened merchandise. People are buying oils based off of the scent. If a company is charging $10+ for 5-10mL of scented oil, they should allow the customer to smell different ones so they can pick out which one they want. They should have a tester area apart from the merchandise like every other store that sells perfumes, cologne, or expensive oils.

Alondra Ramírez

Amazing experience! Love patty and all the goodies she has to offer and cultivates herself! ? thanks for this gem of a shoppe.

Kerri Ann

Discovered the Geneva location today and I am so happy I did! This place is AMAZING! I felt right at home when I walked in. They have everything and anything for cleansing, workings, and herbs for days! Beautiful place that I intend on frequenting often. ❤️

Samantha Rose

A wonderful little shop that has everything from gardening, to hand made crafts and attire.

Kimberly Ferris

This little metaphysical shop has tons of goodies, stones, crystals, books, oils! Herbs and teas you may never have heard of!! The owner is very knowledgeable and willing to lend an ear.

Sarah McNeil

First time going here but definitely wont be the last! I love the online ordering option! Its so close to my house and I love the vibe in the store its so peaceful. The woman behind the counter was super nice and gave me a tea bag to try that was absolutely delicious. This is definitely my herb place from now on

Load More