Penn Station East Coast Subs

2025 Tiffin Ave Suite 2, Findlay
(567) 525-4506

Recent Reviews

Mike L.

My large spicy Italian had too little meat on one half of the sub, the avocado I ordered was nowhere to be found, as were the tomatoes. Overall a big disappoitment.

Kay Marie

Its a good quick sub shop, a great choice if you want a warm fresh sub.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Rueben Sub

Terri O.

Ordered salad from grubhub 2 hours ago, was told it had just been completed 10 minutes ago, no apology just asked I wanted to cancel my order

Meg Moore

Woman working in front always nice.Had a pickup order once. The two employees working were utterly clueless and very obviously high. Not a little bit either

Jamie Hilt

Good place for subs especially the Italian and very meaty. Oh the fries are excellent!!??

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Nicole Ducat

Only complaint is I ordered and paid for a large fry and got a small. N they wanted to argue with me about it so I just dealt with it n walked

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 2

Sheryl Manges

Worst sub ever... it’s actually disgusting... suppose to be chicken cordon bleu... $10 for a medium and waited long enough that I thought they had to finish raising the chicken!!! Never again

Tammy Burger

Well been to this location twice and both times the fries that I received were the scraps from the many orders they had made and it was only 530. Thought they would be cooking some fresh ones cause ANY time I went to the Tiffin location the fries were amazing. Also the employees seem stoned out of their minds and like they are disinterested in being there. I probably won't go back to this location which is a shame cause when prepared right the food is amazing.

Chelsea Kelly

Yes I understand going into the establishment around 7:30 was a bad idea if they close at 8. But the cashier gave us attitude issue from the start. Rolled his eyes when I stated it was for here. I loved Penn Station but now I’m wondering if I should even keep going here if I get treated like that by someone taking our order

Thomas Snyder

I loved this place they make the best lemonade and the workers where very respectful to me and my family there fries and BLTs are amazing I highly suggest going there and ordering a BLT with fries and a lemonade and thank you penn station for being so nice to me and my family

Jamie Thompson

In the time it took us to eat, they messed up 2 Door Dash orders, 3 dine-in orders, and my order. They're too stoned to listen or function. They're rude.

David Parker

The best corned beef sub I've ever had. It was cooked perfectly.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Philly Cheesesteak, Rueben Sub

Lisa Stovall

The sandwich leaked through the paper and the bag. Tasted good, but made a mess in my car.

Joseph Hallstrom

Standard Penn Station. Food is good, the place could use more attention to cleanliness.

Jaclyn Mack

Seemed like everyone who was working was to high to understand the words coming out of my mouth, they messed up both my subs, I asked for sauteed onions and no mushrooms instead they gave me extra mushrooms no sauteed onions I also asked for my chicken cordon bleu to have no honey mustard or tomatoes and they kept the honey mustard and tomatoes on. Their hours are changed at the moment but they have not post it anywhere the change hours they have out a olive oil but their food is actually made in a peanut butter is soy mix and they do it don't have it posted anywhere so it is not peanut allergy friendly

Load More