Pizza Restaurants near Gibsonburg

Oogie's Country Pizza Pizza • $
143 W Madison St, Gibsonburg

Customers` Favorites

Pepperoni Mushroom Sausage Pizza

“Nice to see an old Gibsonburg Family run icon Still going strong They have stripped the old wooden floor, wow does it look fantastic And much brighter inside .They have added an outdoor dining area And new central air. The pizza was as expected Sauced and topped to the edges With a perfect crispy crust, Price was real reasonable, Service was exceptional“

3.7 Good22 Reviews
DeStazios LLC Pizza • $
351 Rice St, Elmore - 6.42 miles

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Alfredo Pizza
Dill Pickle Pizza
Potato Pizza
Meat Lovers
Pepperoni

“It's one of the best small family owned pizza joints that I have eaten in. Great attention to detail, the staff understands customer relations, and the front of the house is quaint and clean. Their dine in area is not large, so don't show up with a group of thirty to be seated for dinner.“

4.7 Superb21 Reviews
Portage Inn Bar & Grill • $
355 Rice St, Elmore - 6.43 miles

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Club Sub Sandwich
Meat Lovers Pizza
Fresh Cut Fries
SM Deluxe Pizza
Italian Sub
Cheeseburger
Garlic Bread

“Our cheese bites, were cold. The pizza was gross ?, it always was not even hot all the way through. The dough was gooey and uncooked. ?The sauce was all watering and dripping of the crust...?and the server never once came back ? to our table to ask us if everything was OK!! NOT, great service, coming from a server. She was nice, tho! We definitely, won't be going back!“

3.9 Good45 Reviews
Marco's Pizza Pizza • $$
6410 County Rd 165, Genoa

“Marcos pizza messed up our order. Did not replace what they messed up. Our pizza was cold. We had no ranch with our cheesy bread and when we received our cinnamon bread, it had no icing on it. We had to wait for an hour to get our order after the time that they had told us. Very disappointing.“

5 Superb1 Reviews
Scooterz Pizza Pizza • $
207 State St, Bettsville

Customers` Favorites

Pizza Brownie with Icing

“great pizza every time we've ever order!“

3.8 Good10 Reviews
Pisanello's Pizza Pizza • $
165 Bierley Ave, Pemberville

“Been a frequent flyer for years. Wholesome and fun staff! Food is always great and is exactly what we love to eat after a long week. Pizza is their staple but their subs are my favorite! Not having current seating inside but when it was available the staff were a hoot to be with and the seating was very home-like. Small town dining with a heart of gold.“

3.7 Good9 Reviews
Bharmacy Pizza • $$
621 Main St, Genoa
3 Average2 Reviews
Marco's Pizza Pizza • $
210 W Main St, Woodville

Customers` Favorites

Hawaiian Chicken
Pepperoni Pizza
Cheezybread

“Local favorite! Great for when we need a late night meal! Staff is always friendly and is accommodating to any allergen issues. Quick service and are always willing to make to order. Quite an experience! You're able watch the employees make the food, giving the restaurant a great vibe.“

2 Poor39 Reviews

Taste More In Gibsonburg