Excellent cauliflower crust for me and regular crust for my hubs. Not burnt (like so many others). Always excellent.
Jimmy Wilson
Actually the best pizza I have ever had. Family run great service
T.taylor
Ive been going here for 30 plus years, just picked up pizza and Italian delight sandwich. The milillo family must of sold the business, pizza was ok not like it used to be sandwich was cold inside , no chips or drinks . You can sure tell its different owners ill give them another try but it a be hard to compete to the milillo family standards
rlwyattcali
Ah, the passage of time... Childhood when the phone number we dialed was only 38956. Then in my late teens there was the time my future father in law said he'd buy me a 16 inch if I could eat the whole thing by myself (ha! Child's play for any teen boy). Moving back into Liberty in the mid 90s meant Milillo would put aluminum foil on top to keep in the warmth. And now, in my early (I hope) twilight I can no longer handle that sixteen size.... But I sure put away that delicious 10 inch all by myself tonight. I will have to bike a few extra miles when I get back to my current state in the southwest but it sure was satisfying to enjoy the very same taste, just as it has always been. DELICIOUS!!
M Langland
This is my first time having their food. It was very good. I'll definitely be returning for more.Vegetarian options: The cheese lasagna is amazing. It's really difficult to find lasagna without meat.
Richard Eldridge
Best pizza in Hamilton, OH! I strongly recommend their pizza. I've been getting pizza from here for almost 20 years and hope to make it another 20 years. My wife loves their lasagna. They also have great garlic bread.
MelloTraveler
Excellent pizza, very good crust with fantastic sauce. Quick easy phone order. Ready when they said. It was just as good as it was when I grew up in Hamilton many years ago. The staff was friendly and helpful.
Bill Mcswain
I've been enjoying their pizza for over 40 years and I can honestly say the quality is taking a nose dive . The last couple large pizzas I got were really bad. Way too much cheese. Poorly cut and soggy crust. Hopefully they improve and get back on track
tom stroup
My favorite pizza since I was very young.
Joseph Gabbard
Paid for extra sauce and cheese on pizza, cheese didn’t even cover pizza. Steak sandwich pattie looked like it was boiled in pan of water. It was pale, no flavor or seasoning at all. Sandwich itself was soaking wet. Bottom of bun fell apart so wet. Worst steak sandwich I’ve ever had from anywhere. Dogs enjoyed it. I think the pasta sauce has changed also. Just kind of bland lately. The pizza bar has dropped in Hamilton. Counting days for Vitales to open. So sad. Cannot recommend anymore unless quality and service improves.Since I can’t reply I had to edit. I didn’t call because I didn’t want to bother with it. My experience as displayed by your response is just to claim I’m wrong and just bad mouthing you. Why after all these years as a customer would I just make something up out of the blue? I couldn’t even pick it up. The bottom just fell apart. I’m not trying to get a refund or anything. Glad that you basically just call your customers liars when they complain. Proving my point why phone calls are a waste of time. And in response to your smart Alec comment. I’ll be glad when Raymond’s opens. Have a great day ?
I got a personal size pepperoni and bacon pizza, breadsticks. The sauce on pizza was great and flavor all together good. I like a little bit more crispy crust, but love they still use the old ovens and not a conveyor belt. Breadsticks were a little hard...
Barbara Almaraz
I’m disappointed in my pizza. Looks like they started using canned mushrooms and biting into them feels slimy. I love mushrooms on my pizza, but these turned my stomach. Sad times…
Travis Torres
IVE BEEN TOLD THE FOOD IS EXPENSIVE AND I SAY TO EVERYONE YEAH IT MAY COST A LITTLE MORE THAN YOUR AVERAGE PIZZA PLACE BUT FOR THE QUALITY AND TASTE OF THE FOOD IT'S GREAT. WHAT PIZZA DO YOU KNOW TASTE AS GOOD AS MILILLO'S? THEY TREAT YOU LIKE FAMILY AND OFFERS GREAT FOOD. THX MILILLOS...
Bryan Kinkaid
I ordered a large pie. The toppings were scarce on the outside of the pizza where the crust was actually good. The middle of the pizza was extremely thin and loaded with toppings making for a greasy, inedible pie. The steak hoagie was undercooked to medium. The hoagie roll was outstanding without the meat.This was my first time here. I was craving Richard’s or Chester’s but figured I’d finally try another local spot with history. I feel like a 3 star revue is generous for my experience but I would hope that their pizzas are usually made better than this. If you’re in town looking for some good Hamilton pizza, get Richard’s, Chester’s or All8Up.
Henry Flower
Great pizza, great everything!!! I've been told the employees make bare minimum wage. Normally I would never support a restaurant who can't treat their employees decently: if a place can't pay a respectable wage they shouldn't be in business period... So I always leave a 5ver in the tip tub... Such kind nice hard working employees
Excellent cauliflower crust for me and regular crust for my hubs. Not burnt (like so many others). Always excellent.
Actually the best pizza I have ever had. Family run great service
Ive been going here for 30 plus years, just picked up pizza and Italian delight sandwich. The milillo family must of sold the business, pizza was ok not like it used to be sandwich was cold inside , no chips or drinks . You can sure tell its different owners ill give them another try but it a be hard to compete to the milillo family standards
Ah, the passage of time... Childhood when the phone number we dialed was only 38956. Then in my late teens there was the time my future father in law said he'd buy me a 16 inch if I could eat the whole thing by myself (ha! Child's play for any teen boy). Moving back into Liberty in the mid 90s meant Milillo would put aluminum foil on top to keep in the warmth. And now, in my early (I hope) twilight I can no longer handle that sixteen size.... But I sure put away that delicious 10 inch all by myself tonight. I will have to bike a few extra miles when I get back to my current state in the southwest but it sure was satisfying to enjoy the very same taste, just as it has always been. DELICIOUS!!
This is my first time having their food. It was very good. I'll definitely be returning for more.Vegetarian options: The cheese lasagna is amazing. It's really difficult to find lasagna without meat.
Best pizza in Hamilton, OH! I strongly recommend their pizza. I've been getting pizza from here for almost 20 years and hope to make it another 20 years. My wife loves their lasagna. They also have great garlic bread.
Excellent pizza, very good crust with fantastic sauce. Quick easy phone order. Ready when they said. It was just as good as it was when I grew up in Hamilton many years ago. The staff was friendly and helpful.
I've been enjoying their pizza for over 40 years and I can honestly say the quality is taking a nose dive . The last couple large pizzas I got were really bad. Way too much cheese. Poorly cut and soggy crust. Hopefully they improve and get back on track
My favorite pizza since I was very young.
Paid for extra sauce and cheese on pizza, cheese didn’t even cover pizza. Steak sandwich pattie looked like it was boiled in pan of water. It was pale, no flavor or seasoning at all. Sandwich itself was soaking wet. Bottom of bun fell apart so wet. Worst steak sandwich I’ve ever had from anywhere. Dogs enjoyed it. I think the pasta sauce has changed also. Just kind of bland lately. The pizza bar has dropped in Hamilton. Counting days for Vitales to open. So sad. Cannot recommend anymore unless quality and service improves.Since I can’t reply I had to edit. I didn’t call because I didn’t want to bother with it. My experience as displayed by your response is just to claim I’m wrong and just bad mouthing you. Why after all these years as a customer would I just make something up out of the blue? I couldn’t even pick it up. The bottom just fell apart. I’m not trying to get a refund or anything. Glad that you basically just call your customers liars when they complain. Proving my point why phone calls are a waste of time. And in response to your smart Alec comment. I’ll be glad when Raymond’s opens. Have a great day ?
Restaurantji Recommends
I got a personal size pepperoni and bacon pizza, breadsticks. The sauce on pizza was great and flavor all together good. I like a little bit more crispy crust, but love they still use the old ovens and not a conveyor belt. Breadsticks were a little hard...
I’m disappointed in my pizza. Looks like they started using canned mushrooms and biting into them feels slimy. I love mushrooms on my pizza, but these turned my stomach. Sad times…
IVE BEEN TOLD THE FOOD IS EXPENSIVE AND I SAY TO EVERYONE YEAH IT MAY COST A LITTLE MORE THAN YOUR AVERAGE PIZZA PLACE BUT FOR THE QUALITY AND TASTE OF THE FOOD IT'S GREAT. WHAT PIZZA DO YOU KNOW TASTE AS GOOD AS MILILLO'S? THEY TREAT YOU LIKE FAMILY AND OFFERS GREAT FOOD. THX MILILLOS...
I ordered a large pie. The toppings were scarce on the outside of the pizza where the crust was actually good. The middle of the pizza was extremely thin and loaded with toppings making for a greasy, inedible pie. The steak hoagie was undercooked to medium. The hoagie roll was outstanding without the meat.This was my first time here. I was craving Richard’s or Chester’s but figured I’d finally try another local spot with history. I feel like a 3 star revue is generous for my experience but I would hope that their pizzas are usually made better than this. If you’re in town looking for some good Hamilton pizza, get Richard’s, Chester’s or All8Up.
Great pizza, great everything!!! I've been told the employees make bare minimum wage. Normally I would never support a restaurant who can't treat their employees decently: if a place can't pay a respectable wage they shouldn't be in business period... So I always leave a 5ver in the tip tub... Such kind nice hard working employees