23 Best Italian Restaurants near Hartville

“Carlo's has become one of our very favorite places to visit & take family to. The food is delicious, the staff is so kind & the atmosphere is so warm, welcoming & cozy! It definitely exudes the most authentic Italian, family owned, tasty, small town charm feel & I highly recommend to those who've not tried it before!“

“First time coming to The Bistro for anniversary and everything was amazing! I highly recommend coming here. The food was great and the service was also amazing. It being our first time we had some questions and what the server recommended. She was very knowledgeable and was very helpful for what we asked. We started out with the Bianca Pizza for appetizer, then for our main dishes my husband got the pistachio pesto, pork chop and I got the chicken piccata. Both very delicious and to end the night we got a cheesecake Togo.“

“Carrabba’s was accommodating with allowing our family to celebrate the birthdays of our grandkids allowing us bringing cake and gifts. Our waitress was very attentive and pleasant. Everyone enjoyed their food. Good selection on menu. Our experience was very good.“

“I went in to fill out an applicationThe people there were extremely helpful and friendly they treated me like family and they even saw to it that I got an interview that day they really are a place that I would tell people to visit ?Kid-friendliness: They are kind to everyone“

“We had a lovely dinner for our 12th anniversary. Fabulous food, drinks, desserts, and atmosphere. Chandler was a phenomenal server, very personable, friendly, good with the banter.It's the second time we've celebrated here and it never fails to make us gustatorially and emotionally happy!“

“First time coming to The Bistro for anniversary and everything was amazing! I highly recommend coming here. The food was great and the service was also amazing. It being our first time we had some questions and what the server recommended. She was very knowledgeable and was very helpful for what we asked. We started out with the Bianca Pizza for appetizer, then for our main dishes my husband got the pistachio pesto, pork chop and I got the chicken piccata. Both very delicious and to end the night we got a cheesecake Togo.“

“Excellent food and service! The food is always fresh and made from scratch. They have very good prices a good variety of options on their menu. They also provide a great catering options for bigger parties. Consentinos is a gem in our area.“

“Visited Cool Cat Counter for the first time and was thoroughly impressed! The food was fantastic, served quickly, and at great prices. The staff were incredibly friendly and attentive, adding to the wonderful 50s diner atmosphere. Overall, a top-notch experience - highly recommend!“

“today we ordered the Jan special. the guy working the oven called me over and said our philly steak stomboli did not look good and he did not feel right sending it home with me. He offered to make something in its place. I had to wait a few minutes but he also made me a fresh pizza! I just want to say thank you for sending quality food that looks good out! it's always delish! Thank you so much!“

“A local favorite for many years! Patio is very nice when weather permits it, and service is on the ball pretty much all the time. Mid range to high end Italian style menu, with some basic options for kids or whatever you want if not Italian. HANDS DOWN THE BEST FRIED CHICKEN TENDERS I've ever had period! Sounds silly but I am telling all here and now to be ready to become a fellow 'Best Chicken Tenders cult member'! It is but a single taste and munch of the almighty Tenders. That's all it takes to turn one into a fanatic convert of Palombos chicken fingers! Oh and everything else is pretty bomb as well lol. ✌?“

“What can I say? Roma's is one of my favorite places. The staff is amazing. Jason and Linda are the best. I highly recommend their chicken tenders and their Jalapeño crunch pizza...believe me, you will be glad you did. The food is amazing.“

“Dined there for the first time this evening. While everyone arriving had reservations, unfortunately at least one group seated earlier stayed 3 hours, putting the restaurant a bit behind. This was no fault of the restaurant. Despite being quite full, everyone working was friendly, working diligently to wait on people and very kind.The food was definitely worth the wait! Delicious stromboli, garlic bread, spaghetti and pizza. I will absolutely be back! They also offer curbside if you don't wish to wait. Wonderful hidden gem to discover.“

“Five stars all across the board five stars all across the board! This was the first time my mother and I tried this location, after hearing great things about it. As soon as I entered to place my order, I was greeted immediately with a smile. I ordered the fish and fries with an extra tartar sauce for the road. The employee who took my order was very informative and patient with me. She smiled the whole time and gave great conversation. The atmosphere was very clean and to my liking. She informed me that my food would not have a long wait and I proceeded to sit in the car as it cooked shortly after, she came out and handed me the food herself. I was very surprised because I am not used to this kind of courtesy but it warmed our heart. This shown proper and excellent customer service. We will return and tell our friends and family about this location and its employees! Thank you again :)“

“Overall, this place is a local treasure! The food was really good and much better than national chains. It may be the exact same food suppliers but overall the food tastes better. The staff and atmosphere here were great! It had a home town feel that was inclusive of newbies. Our waitress made great recommendations for out of towners. Will definitely come back here when in town.“

“Pricey. Kept us from also ordering drinks. But otherwise award winning food making it a special treat for us! Just the same scenario as everywhere with higher prices than we will pay on any kind of regular basis. They must have a great cook!“

“We tried Angellos for the first time last night the the Vintage Ohio Vine Festival and hands down this is the best sandwich I have ever had!! I believe it was the owner she was walking around giving samples out of the Pasquale's Italian Sub Sandwich and when she told me what was on it was I was hesitant to try it at first because I am a very picky eater but I am so glad I did! Before we left and went and order 2 sandwiches to go. It just has the perfect combination of flavors and the bread is so fresh. I could honestly eat this everyday!“

“We have been to La Pizzaria for various events: rehearsal dinners, showers, funeral dinners, and often for regular dinners. We have always had great meals and service. Most recently, my husband found the meat raviolis (homemade) to be his favorite! Next time, I will take a picture of it! I love the baked ziti and regular spaghetti/meatballs, and the dinner salads are the best.“

“My friend and I order pizza separately, the pizza was so good. That is the first time eat there and it was fabulous place. Love the old pictures of the famous Stars like Frank Sinatra, all different stars pictures on the wall. Place was clean and environmental was pleasure. Definitely will be back again some day. And also I live close by not far. It was great.“

“This place is a hidden GEM!! the food was amazing. I got the Turkey Panini with the spicy coleslaw and it was to die for. My husband got the Italiano burger and it had so much flavor. I highly recommend giving this place a try. Service was awesome too!“

“Always delicious. I have a favorite - shrimp scampi with gluten free rotini. I love the salad, mi us croutons. My husband loves the cheese ravioli with crispy chicken on top.Dietary restrictions: Gluten free pasta . Very thankful for that. My son in law gets chicken Parm w gluten free pasta with the chicken grilled instead of breaded.“

“Best pizza in Northeast Ohio. It's cooked exactly as requested and it's always right. Excellent staff, and when picking my pizza up I noticed how clean the place is. I drive 20 minutes and it's worth it every time! Their chicken is amazing too! Highly recommend!“

“Very tasty food especially with the pasta inside the "burrito". Unfortunately the unique texture of the piada breaks down and juices from the ingredients leak all over, and MAN is it expensive...over $20 for 1 person's lunch!“

“Great food and service and prices to match. Drinks don't break the bank, and the food has always been fantastic! Always remember, reservations don't hurt plan ahead on for weekends.Vegetarian options: Not a ton, but enough great options for vegetarians“