Papa Johns Pizza

3644 Main St, Hilliard
(614) 777-4545

Recent Reviews

John Downs (Jack)

I ordered a pizza but I was charged for 2. Clerk verified I only ordered one but there was nothing he could do. I had to pay for both. Said issue with their system. I said ok just give me a refund or the 2nd pizza. He said he was unable to do that. Said I needed to go to my bank for a refund. None of this made any sense to me. I didn't stop to argue it as I had my small grandkids in the car. Beware of ordering on line.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 2

Service: 3

Sheri Lyn

I have been craving pizza for sometime now, and finally gave in. So Papa Johns was the answer.We use the APP which tells us accurately every step in preparation- and when it was ready to pick up (they offer delivery too, but we were going to be nearby).

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pizza

Ashley Bell

i ordered boneless wings, pizza, and bacon jalapeno cheese bread and received bone IN wings, pizza, and regular cheese bread.who knew ordering simple items could be so hard for some people. don’t recommend this location.

Food: 1

Service: 1

adam simpkins

Don’t order delivery from this location. It’s always at least 30 minutes past the time they say online. And you food will be cold when it gets to you. And don’t try to call because nobody answers. Rare chance they do answer, all they say is it’s out for delivery. Not to mention the your order will probably not be right. Get your location together.

Food: 1

Service: 1

Recommended dishes: Pizza

Mohammed Fateh

Paid 5 dollars for ranch sauce and didn’t get any so I called them and the lady was very disrespectful saying you only paid for 2 when my receipt clearly shows 4. Never going

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Rolando Alvarez Gonzalez

Ordered a pizza, and they delivered the wrong pizza. I called backto see if they could send me the right one, but they hanged up on me,very disappointed

Dhifaf Shafeea

Best. Pizza. In. The. WORLD. No joke!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Garlic Parmesan Breadsticks, Extra Sauce, Pizza, Create Your Own Pizza Medium

Thomas Strong

Over an hour and ten minutes to get cold pizza, that's four minutes down the road from where I live. ?

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

M Marmalade

This location is amazing! An online order for my son's first grade class accidentally went to the wrong Papa John's, but Main Street filled the order in 10 minutes flat, and we arrived for lunch on time! Thank you so much!!!!

Alyssa B.

The food was delicious. Everything was fresh. My fav was the Parmesan chicken papa bites. You've gotta try them!

Donald Mayfield

First time ordering from there. Food was great wings was hot everything was great. Thank you guys keep up the good work

Chris W.

I usually don't go to large chains for pizza, but I would go to Papa Johns every now and then, because their pizza always had a unique taste. Now the pizza really has no taste. I do like their garlic parmesan bread sticks, but even those aren't as good as they used to be. The positive is that carry out is usually always ready within 15 minutes.

Richelle Grooms

My son loves Poppa John's pizza, and so do I. I have no complaints.

Katie McBride

No delivery, hours different than online. Only a mile away but sent me calling a different store 5 miles away that didn’t deliver at all!!!

James Smith

VERY NICE PEOPLE. LET US ORDER THE PIZZA BOWL AND WAS VERY VERY GOOD. WILL ORDER FROM THIS STORE AGAIN. VERY NICE STAFF J&P

Load More