The Cheesecake Girl - Hilliard

5354 Center St, Hilliard
(614) 787-1753

Recent Reviews

fusion31003

Expensive but the best tasting cheesecake I've ever

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 4

Stacy Busch

We are from out of town and saw this biz online. Looked great. We went to the Center Market location. When we approached the display/storefront the young lady was busy on the register doing something. She did not greet us or even look at us as we were discussing what looked good in the showcase. After several minutes of us standing there, ibapproached her and she asked how she could help. Unfortunately, kind of expect that type of service from retail nowadays. We purchased a slice of "tagalongs" cheesecake for $9.50. I told my wife this better be the best cheesecake I have ever eaten for that price. Well, I had three bites and I was done. The cheesecake had literally no flavor. I am a pb freak and love tagalongs, so I was pumped, but then totally disappointed after trying it. My wife was let down as well. She said it was very bitter to her and needed sugar.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 1

Service: 1

N Shu

We got all our deserts from the Cheesecake Girl for our wedding. The cheesecake tasted amazing and were a hit! Thank you so much for doing such an amazing job!! I would recommend The Cheesecake Girl anytime!! Very professional and timely! Easy to work with! Thank You SO MUCH!

J S (KidKwik)

These are average and overpriced. Service was slow as well stood there waiting for someone to come out of back for a good 3-5 minutes. With a name like that you would expect much better.The sugar cookie one is just a Pillsbury sugar cookie with cheesecake on it. Seriously? Can’t even make your own mini sugar cookies? At least if you had the price would be justified even if it was still just average. If you need a sugar cookie recipe I’m happy to help3/4 cup lard1 2/3 cup sugar3T milk3T vanilla3 eggs3 1/2 cup flour1T baking powder1/2t saltMix, roll and cutPlace on greased cookie sheet bake 400 until golden.You’re welcome, and it’s funny reading the comment that says you make everything from scratch. I know a Pillsbury Halloween sugar cookie when I see one.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 1

Service: 3

Alice Everage

I just had several fkavors if cheese cake fir myself and family while dining at Bubbly foid center. My family members were in love with the different fkavors but my four feet family members rank their dog donuts very, very highly. After eating their donuts they were looking for any crums leftovers. Well done and rhank you for dedication to sweet perfected taste.

Kenton Bohenko

The cheesecake slices are amazing. It's a little pricey, but you get what you pay for.

E B

One word... perfection! I've been here 3 times and it's delicious. pineapple, original, and cookie dough were all just wonderful.

ty autry

Wasn't impressed. Would've gave a 3 star based on taste..but bumped it to a 2 because of the pricing. The cheescake wasn't very good..the birthday cookie sandwich was decent, but not worth the price. The private selection cheesecakes at kroger/walmart are way better than this place.

Jessica F.

LOVE The Cheesecake Girl. This one is inside of Crooked Can! Different options everytime, limited selection though so make sure you stop by earlier rather than later if you want a bigger selection of choices. The fruit pizza cheesecake and the black raspberry chip cheesecake are my favs!!!

Lauren Coleman

I love this place and I can’t wait for the pumpkin cheesecake to come back!

Carla F.

I kept hearing good things about this place so I decided to check it out while we were at the Crooked Can. I tried their cheesecake trifle jar, a mini original cheesecake, and a birthday cheesecake cookie sandwich. The red velvet cookie crunch cheesecake trifle jar was delicious. Layers of cake with cheesecake, can't go wrong with that. There were also mini chocolate chips in it which added a perfect crunch to it. The birthday cookie sandwich was good too but I was not a fan of their mini original cheesecake. I was expecting a soft and smooth cheesecake but it was on the harder side.

Aquiala M.

I cannot say enough about how much I enjoy The Cheesecake Girl! I have always experienced excellent customer service in this and other locations. The quality of the cheesecake is incredible, and I love the flavor combinations. There is always something for everyone, including cute treats made for dogs. My go-to is the golden Oreo funfetti cheesecake.

MA W

Visited “The cheesecake girl” in Budd Dairy Hall.We had a red velvet cookie crunch cheesecake jar.So rich and creamy, it was a jar of heaven…well worth the $10 price tag, I shared it with my sister and we both had a good size serving.Highly recommended!

Dan H.

We are usual customers and we always buy oatmeal cream cookies at your Dublin Store. we have purchased quite a few of these since your store opening in Dublin. We really enjoy these until today 10/28/22 when to our surprise we noticed hardly any cream at all in the cookies and along with that the cookies were dry tasting. We are really disappointed with the cookies and have never had a problem before. I never thought I would have to look in the box to see what we purchased but I guess we will have to. Hopefully next time they will be back to what they use to be like, thanks.....Dan

Aubrie H.

Yummy sweet treats. Love that they always have different mini cheesecakes to try. The coconut is ourfavorite! Every time we stop in we have to head home with a doggy donut as well!

Load More

The Cheesecake Girl - Hilliard

5354 Center St, Hilliard, OH 43026
(614) 787-1753