The Goat Hilliard

4265 Brooklands Dr, Hilliard
(614) 470-5550

Recent Reviews

BigD M

Drinks are horrible, even the bartender said so. I was charged for blue cheese dressing even though I ordered a salad. Bartender never asked how was food or drinks. Very disappointed.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 2

Service: 2

Recommended dishes: Fries, Hamburger

Jeremy Smith

Great place. The food is awesome and the drinks amazing. The staff are friendly.Vegetarian options: Not sure if there is an actual menu section for vegetarians, yet I know they can substitute a meat for cauliflower or tofu.Dietary restrictions: Just let the server know. Most items made from scratch so this is an easy fix.Parking: There is one row of parking right in front of the townhomes...don't be rude and take one of those places. People live thereKid-friendliness: Awesome place for kids to come as wellWheelchair accessibility: Plenty of wheelchair accessible entrances

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Alex Feyh

Good food, slow service. Only had bartender staffed to run bar and take care of tables. Food came out very slowly and half of the stuff we asked for we never got. All of this when they weren’t even close to busy. Upstaff!!!!

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 1

Recommended dishes: Hot Chicken

Nikole Behrens

I just moved in not too long ago, and having the Goat on the property was a big drawing point for my husband and I! I'm a fulltime writer and sometimes I just need a break to get out of the house and work somewhere else. Taking a nice stroll down to the Goat and enjoying a plate of nachos or wings is a great highlight of my week. The food is pretty tasty -- anything I've had with pulled pork on it is fantastic. I also appreciate the relaxed friendly vibes. If you're considering moving here, the Goat is a major win!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Jordan R.

The atmosphere was nice, but the food was mediocre. Fries came out cold and limp and both of our entrees (chicken sandwich and cauliflower wrap) were meh. We aren't going back.

Henry Matthews

Ordered the American smash burger, and a normal cheeseburger came out in its place . Buns were cold. Mango habanero wings lacked both mango and habanero flavor. Overall the food experience was not a good one. The beers were fine. TBF management did try to fix the wings, but the second batch was the same as the first. Service was stellar, food was meh.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 1

Service: 5

Brie Oragbade

Ordered for take out and got the smallest amount of food I've ever received in a take out. I guess I assumed the mac and cheese dishes were entrees as they were similar in price to the salads right above but it was so tiny I would assume it was a side. I also ordered a blueberry crumble which was basically just blueberries in sauce with the lack of crumble. And astonishingly was the same size as the Mac and cheese very disappointing.

Food: 4

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Blueberry Crumble

Alex

This review is in regards to the brunch menu. My wife and I tried it for the first time, and wow, it was at the very best subpar, and the prices for what little we received was a joke. We ordered the mixed berry french toast (had a thin slice of one strawberry and about 4 blueberries) and the Mile High scramble, which was honestly a joke. So disappointing. Also, really on top of letting you know when your order is ready to pick up

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 2

Service: 5

Seth Held

This is a favorite stop after work. Try the Old Fashioned and the tater tots!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Adrean Jones

My husband and I met up for a week night dinner date. We absolutely loved this place and will be back. The atmosphere is very open and there is an elegant historical feel inside. We had cocktails a black walnut old fashioned and an elderberry with our crispy cauliflower appetizer. For our meals I had the mahi mahi tacos and my husband got the chicken sandwich. Both were delicious, the fish was cooked perfectly and the chicken was juicy. For dessert we had the chocolate custard which was almost like a Carmel but it was just the right amount of sweet to top off our meal.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Brian Lee

The service was a little rocky at first but once we got a server it was better. Server was great. Food was delicious. Atmosphere is very comfortable and laid back. The Euchre tournament was taking place in another area!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Hamburger

Jessica P.

My husband & I absolutely love The Goat - it has become one of our go-to spots. The atmosphere, the service, the food - all great and all make for a amazing overall dining experience! When you do visit, the farmhouse tots are a MUST!

Madison M.

The atmosphere is beautiful. The drinks were mid. The fries were really good and the birria tacos were good. Our waitress kinda sucked I think it would've been a whole different experience if we would've had a better one. Fair warning water is trash.

Douglas G.

We had reservations for 4 which grew to 12 in a short time and we were seated at a very tall long table as everyone arrived. They had no issue with the change of reservation numbers. We had the perfect server, Blade, as he was extremely pleasant and accommodating throughout the evening. The orders came out perfectly to each seated customer and many raved about the food and of course the drinks! Of course the Black Walnut Old Fashioned is always a hit! With the table coming from the state of Washington, California, and Nebraska, the conversation was light and lively, the Queens Table was the perfect location for us to converse with each other and have an outstanding evening with the perfect server, Blade and the outstanding food!

Janice Anderson

Really good food. The ice was terrible with the snow place there tho. They did not clean the walls off where you walk into. Scary with our sister who uses walkers to get in and out. But the food was good and the waitress was very nice and friendly.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Buffalo Chicken Wrap, Double Pepperoni Pizza, Tenders, Traditional Wings 10, Fries, Hamburger

Load More