Stopped in for donuts this morning. They are delicious! Nice and fluffy, and the cream filled eclairs are my favorite. Definitely recommend everyone getting some donuts here.
Oh my what can I say! Best of the best. Staff, Service. They totally is one of the best Bakery in the area. Hidden Gem!
Sherral Bowers
I have bought things from there for years and have never been disappointed in any of their items. We are very lucky to have them.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Mike Novak
Remembering my younger years, 40+ years ago, I used to walk up to buckeye bakery on route 42 and Indiana ave to buy coffee cake every Saturday morning.Recently I found that that store was permanently closed so I called the main bakery to see if they still produced my favorite breakfast treat.They have since changed it from coffee cake to a maple roll. It is good but nothing like the original! I can’t give them a bad report, I still shared it with my family and they loved it! Ty
Deanna R.
Thank you for your beautiful decorating!
jillian carrick
This bakery is amazing! They will do custom cakes upon request. I had to change my pick up time a day earlier and they were so helpful and sweet!
Sean Burns
Grocery store quality. Some of the items you see in the case have been there a few days.
Darlene Curry
They make the best sugar cookies in Mansfield,oh
Kyle Justice
I love this place. Everyone is always very nice and upbeat, excellent service, great pricing, and by far the best pastries, cookies, and donuts I’ve had around Mansfield. I am in love with their cream cheese pastries. They have pineapple and all kinds of other delicious flavors.
This place was great and I stopped there often but about a year ago this place went on a down-hill slide. They never have any thing left when I stop by 11am! I haven't bought anything in a long time because their product cases are always empty when I go out of my way to stop there. Never again will I waste my time on the buckeye bakery, and that's something I never thought I'd say!Employees I interacted with were rude and didn't display any concern for me as a customer. Many other reviews in past year saying exact same thing. Too bad. This place had a great following until apparent very poor leadership flushed it down the toilet.
Jean
The young man behind the counter was very helpful and shared some of the history of this long-standing family business with us. The layered date bar and the toffee bar with maple icing were so delicious. Worth the stop!
Todd Newberry
Been a fan for 40 years. Until today. My daughter called a month ago to order for her wedding. They said call back a week from the wedding. She calls today, 9 days out. They told her they wouldn't take her order and were rude.
Jody Pressley
They got my order wrong, made substitutions without asking me and didn't even give me the correct amount of items I ordered. Which didn't make for a good first impression.
Judy Mack
I ordered a quarter sheet cake for a friends birthday and paid 40.00 for it, the cake was delicious (not 40.00 delicious) but she was happy with the cake until we found 2 hairs bake right inside the cake. I’ll stick with Miller Hawkins 18.99 and just as delicious. And no hair
Stopped in for donuts this morning. They are delicious! Nice and fluffy, and the cream filled eclairs are my favorite. Definitely recommend everyone getting some donuts here.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Creme Sticks
Thumbs
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cupcakes, Egg Cookies, Sundaes, Wedding Cake, Frozen Cookies, Sheet Cake
Oh my what can I say! Best of the best. Staff, Service. They totally is one of the best Bakery in the area. Hidden Gem!
I have bought things from there for years and have never been disappointed in any of their items. We are very lucky to have them.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Remembering my younger years, 40+ years ago, I used to walk up to buckeye bakery on route 42 and Indiana ave to buy coffee cake every Saturday morning.Recently I found that that store was permanently closed so I called the main bakery to see if they still produced my favorite breakfast treat.They have since changed it from coffee cake to a maple roll. It is good but nothing like the original! I can’t give them a bad report, I still shared it with my family and they loved it! Ty
Thank you for your beautiful decorating!
This bakery is amazing! They will do custom cakes upon request. I had to change my pick up time a day earlier and they were so helpful and sweet!
Grocery store quality. Some of the items you see in the case have been there a few days.
They make the best sugar cookies in Mansfield,oh
I love this place. Everyone is always very nice and upbeat, excellent service, great pricing, and by far the best pastries, cookies, and donuts I’ve had around Mansfield. I am in love with their cream cheese pastries. They have pineapple and all kinds of other delicious flavors.
Restaurantji Recommends
This place was great and I stopped there often but about a year ago this place went on a down-hill slide. They never have any thing left when I stop by 11am! I haven't bought anything in a long time because their product cases are always empty when I go out of my way to stop there. Never again will I waste my time on the buckeye bakery, and that's something I never thought I'd say!Employees I interacted with were rude and didn't display any concern for me as a customer. Many other reviews in past year saying exact same thing. Too bad. This place had a great following until apparent very poor leadership flushed it down the toilet.
The young man behind the counter was very helpful and shared some of the history of this long-standing family business with us. The layered date bar and the toffee bar with maple icing were so delicious. Worth the stop!
Been a fan for 40 years. Until today. My daughter called a month ago to order for her wedding. They said call back a week from the wedding. She calls today, 9 days out. They told her they wouldn't take her order and were rude.
They got my order wrong, made substitutions without asking me and didn't even give me the correct amount of items I ordered. Which didn't make for a good first impression.
I ordered a quarter sheet cake for a friends birthday and paid 40.00 for it, the cake was delicious (not 40.00 delicious) but she was happy with the cake until we found 2 hairs bake right inside the cake. I’ll stick with Miller Hawkins 18.99 and just as delicious. And no hair