Papa Johns Pizza

6289 Reynolds Rd, Mentor
(440) 209-1901

Recent Reviews

Gabriella Latino-Reyanud

Food was make quick, delivery driver was awesome nice guy, he got here fast, had no issue finding my apartment. Food was still really hot & wasnt missing anything from my order.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Joe McGinnis

Unfortunately, the pizza is inconsistent. One pizza will be edible, and the next time only partially covered with cheese or very salty.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 2

Service: 5

Veronica Habat

Staff is really nice and pizza is always ready when I get here and really yummy! Best Papa Johns around!

Brian Sandberg

Get in and out with minimal

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 4

_ Kujo

these two older guys kinda look alike just one short, one tall, every time we order they are rude and have an attitude towards me and i’ve even heard them talk disrespectfully. it seems to me that they could care less about the food or the customer. We have had our order messed up a couple times, only while they are working. we try to avoid ordering when they work. it’s a shame too because we enjoy the pizza, usually, don’t know what else to do besides go somewhere else.

alex jackson

The pizza made me sick Threw up all night No good ..

Kelly Mordini

I go to Papa John's, my girls like the pizza very much so! We tend to get the Epic pepperoni which the crust is stuffed. I'm not much of a pizza eater but I have tried this one and it is really good! The service is really good too! We tend to go to the Papa John's over near Lakeshore and 305 across the street from Speedway on Lakeshore in Mentor this location the staff is really nice:-)

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Jeffery

I work here, so it automatically gets 5 stars

Hillary H.

I do love the pizza here and the dipping sauce is a sin. Only one I order it reheats real well in a frying pan so I get more then one meal out of it

Rhiannon Ricci

A JOKE OF A RESTAURANT. THEY WILL PURPOSELY KEEP THEIR PHONE LINES ON "BUSY" SO THAT THEY DONT HAVE TO TAKE CALLS. I've been a customer for YEARS but quality control is non-existent. Company's will hire literally any stupid person to make pizza with ZERO experience I'm customer service. DO BETTER PAPA JOHNS!!!

Christy Thayer

Can't even call and order a pizza. Line is constantly busy. Tried to order through website, accidentally had it sent to a wrong address, GOD FORBID, and can't even call to rectify the situation. Terrible service!!!

Christy Thayer

absolutely TERRIBLE service!! order food online. realized we had the wrong address and tried to call them to change it. No way to get a hold of anyone. phone was a constant busy. 67 times we called. Arrived at the location and no one was even on the phone. They just stared at us. Absolutely horrible service. Will never order pizza from there ever again!!

Rhiannon Ricci

AWFUL PISS POOR EMPLOYEE AND TERRIBLE CUSTOMER SERVICE

TriHard7

They hooked it up in the extra cheese + toppings. Whoever worked 4pm 6/4/22 ty so much. I will definitely be back because of you.

kelly ryman

While the food is good and the delivery is prompt the reason I’m giving 3 stars is because every single time I order I tell them no pepperoncinis in the pizza box because I’m extremely allergic. To vegetable peppers. And each time its in there ??

Load More