We have been here twice and we are addicted! Were new to Strongsville and needed a spot. We've tried a few places so far. But the pizza here is soo amazing! The owner is amazing as well! He is there to show you the pizza and his moto is, If it's not picture perfect then its not a pizza he can sell. The even have a dine in spot which is my favorite! Most pizza shops don't have dine in and I think it takes away from the experience. Our new pizza spot for sure! 100%% recommend!
Adrianna Burden
Came looking for really good pizza and really good wings , and we got it ! They were actually made crispy and pizza was cooked perfect . No complaints ! Bartender Adrienne was super nice and attentive!
Lynds Rose
The pickle pizza. Just do it. I would never ever have thought to put tomato slices, red onion (which I normally avoid, ugh too bitey), pickles, an amazing white sauce and ranch together. It’s my 3 year old nephews favorite. And mine.It IS a bit expensive for pizza, but daaang is it good.
Dave V
The BEST PIZZA to go to in Pennsylvania!! By far the best, they set the standard for what pizza should taste like. I'll continue to keep going to Dom's Tavern and Pizzeria to get pizza, pasta and subs. Thank you for the AMAZING tasting food and amazing service. Have a wonderful and blessed New years!!
Lisa
Homemade spaghetti was a nice surprise! Cheesy breadsticks. Fresh pizza bread. Tito and tonic. Quiet comfortable atmosphere and friendly front staff. Was not expecting that based on location. Quick thoughtful service and a good meal. A+ for the vino. Much needed and appreciated. Give them a try. Based on the bread... I'm betting their pizza will be good too. Congratulations on your opening!
John Z.
I drove by and this is closed in 2022 and appears to be a new business. Tarp over the name.
Norma Hill
Tonight we tried Dom's,Let me start by saying the owner is very pleasant, As someone who's family owned a pizza shop for many years and Im Italian at that I have to say this pizza was definitely the best Ive had in a very long time an the best in the Middleburg hts area,the pizza was perfectly prepared an cooked an portioned ,you can tell it isn't a can of typical pizza brand sauce or dough. Very Well blended cheeses. Also the canolis where amazing,as a baker myself i can say without a doubt these are amazing..look forward to furture meals. Highly Recommend !
Allen Jeffery
Food was very good I ordered a spaghetti and meatball dinner my wife got a chicken Alfredo dinner and two cannolis food was very good scale from 1 to 10 I give it an 8 1/2
Michael N.
I have to say, this was horrible. One small, one medium pizza, and a disgusting salad full of brown lettuce was $40. I almost got back in my car to go return this slop. First time and last time eating anything from this place.
Lynne Ucic
Went to 3 Brother's for Dinner. We ordered spaghetti with meatballs, chicken parmigian, a nd a pizza to go. The dinners were Great and the pizza was addicting. The waitress was friendly and efficient. We will definately be returning!
Food is great quality. Great service and cute atmosphere. Owners are super nice!
Stephanie Phillips
Got a sausage pizza and Thai Chili boneless wings and it was all delicious! The more crispy, crunchy, wings with the most tender juicy meat. They were so saucy and the wings didn’t get soggy at all! 11/10 would go back for wings tomorrow!
Dan
B̶e̶s̶t̶ ̶p̶i̶z̶z̶a̶ ̶a̶r̶o̶u̶n̶d̶.̶.̶.̶.̶ ̶L̶i̶t̶t̶l̶e̶ ̶p̶r̶i̶c̶e̶y̶ ̶b̶u̶t̶ ̶w̶o̶r̶t̶h̶ ̶i̶t̶.̶UPDATE SINCE NEW MANAGEMENT: 5 to 0 stars...We have been ordering here for over 7 years. When we first moved into our house, my wife ordered subs for everyone helping us paint. We were instantly hooked and couldn't believe how good they were. Also, my wife has Celiac disease and must eat gluten free food. She absolutely fell in love with how good the gluten free pizza and cheesy bread was. We raved about this place, even with the higher than normal prices. Now, I would never recommend this place to anyone.... Since day one under new management we noticed a difference in the quality of food and ingredients. Unfortunately, it has only gotten worse and worse since. I have called and complained when it's been terrible and never once offered any type of compensation. Even when we had insanely bad FOOD POISONING only a few orders after new management. Sadly, they barely cared at all.... The food itself has been EXTREMELY inconsistent. Every single order is different. Zero exaggeration! We order the same thing 99% of the time so it's not hard to notice the changes. One order the thin crust will pita thin and burnt, the next full crust, the next the edge will be three inches wide and make the pizza tiny. The sauce is way sweeter and acidic, sometimes there is a spice on the bottom of the crust, sometimes not. Sometimes things are insanely burnt or sometimes it is so doughy you can't believe it was cooked. For some strange reason when we order a Pepsi 2 liter, we'll randomly get a cherry Pepsi. The cheesey bread sticks were only gluten free before, now it's $4 extra. The cheesey bacon fries are maybe 2/3 the size they were before and somehow extra cheese is what the normal cheese was before..... I wish I would have taken more pictures of past orders but have attached tonight's order. The incredibly burnt and uncut thing is "cheesey" bread, the brown soggy but somehow burnt fries have "extra cheese", the burnt through cup was the bacon for the fries (plastic added for flavor and 1/3 the size of before).... There are many more examples but this is long enough..... Guess we will have to find a new place that has good gluten free pizza... So sad to see somewhere so damn good bought and changed so much. Probably to try and squeeze out just a little more profit at the cost of losing customers.
Margaret Dodson
we dine in great friendly server had a deep fry crust pizza one of the best pizza i had and the wings were fantastic
Abbey Bates
Oh man! Our pizza was freaking delicious! It's a good thing we don't live local, otherwise we'd be here a few times a week. If you order extra cheese, expect a commercial-like stretchy cheese moment complete with the steam. We'll definitely be returning.
We have been here twice and we are addicted! Were new to Strongsville and needed a spot. We've tried a few places so far. But the pizza here is soo amazing! The owner is amazing as well! He is there to show you the pizza and his moto is, If it's not picture perfect then its not a pizza he can sell. The even have a dine in spot which is my favorite! Most pizza shops don't have dine in and I think it takes away from the experience. Our new pizza spot for sure! 100%% recommend!
Came looking for really good pizza and really good wings , and we got it ! They were actually made crispy and pizza was cooked perfect . No complaints ! Bartender Adrienne was super nice and attentive!
The pickle pizza. Just do it. I would never ever have thought to put tomato slices, red onion (which I normally avoid, ugh too bitey), pickles, an amazing white sauce and ranch together. It’s my 3 year old nephews favorite. And mine.It IS a bit expensive for pizza, but daaang is it good.
The BEST PIZZA to go to in Pennsylvania!! By far the best, they set the standard for what pizza should taste like. I'll continue to keep going to Dom's Tavern and Pizzeria to get pizza, pasta and subs. Thank you for the AMAZING tasting food and amazing service. Have a wonderful and blessed New years!!
Homemade spaghetti was a nice surprise! Cheesy breadsticks. Fresh pizza bread. Tito and tonic. Quiet comfortable atmosphere and friendly front staff. Was not expecting that based on location. Quick thoughtful service and a good meal. A+ for the vino. Much needed and appreciated. Give them a try. Based on the bread... I'm betting their pizza will be good too. Congratulations on your opening!
I drove by and this is closed in 2022 and appears to be a new business. Tarp over the name.
Tonight we tried Dom's,Let me start by saying the owner is very pleasant, As someone who's family owned a pizza shop for many years and Im Italian at that I have to say this pizza was definitely the best Ive had in a very long time an the best in the Middleburg hts area,the pizza was perfectly prepared an cooked an portioned ,you can tell it isn't a can of typical pizza brand sauce or dough. Very Well blended cheeses. Also the canolis where amazing,as a baker myself i can say without a doubt these are amazing..look forward to furture meals. Highly Recommend !
Food was very good I ordered a spaghetti and meatball dinner my wife got a chicken Alfredo dinner and two cannolis food was very good scale from 1 to 10 I give it an 8 1/2
I have to say, this was horrible. One small, one medium pizza, and a disgusting salad full of brown lettuce was $40. I almost got back in my car to go return this slop. First time and last time eating anything from this place.
Went to 3 Brother's for Dinner. We ordered spaghetti with meatballs, chicken parmigian, a nd a pizza to go. The dinners were Great and the pizza was addicting. The waitress was friendly and efficient. We will definately be returning!
Restaurantji Recommends
Food is great quality. Great service and cute atmosphere. Owners are super nice!
Got a sausage pizza and Thai Chili boneless wings and it was all delicious! The more crispy, crunchy, wings with the most tender juicy meat. They were so saucy and the wings didn’t get soggy at all! 11/10 would go back for wings tomorrow!
B̶e̶s̶t̶ ̶p̶i̶z̶z̶a̶ ̶a̶r̶o̶u̶n̶d̶.̶.̶.̶.̶ ̶L̶i̶t̶t̶l̶e̶ ̶p̶r̶i̶c̶e̶y̶ ̶b̶u̶t̶ ̶w̶o̶r̶t̶h̶ ̶i̶t̶.̶UPDATE SINCE NEW MANAGEMENT: 5 to 0 stars...We have been ordering here for over 7 years. When we first moved into our house, my wife ordered subs for everyone helping us paint. We were instantly hooked and couldn't believe how good they were. Also, my wife has Celiac disease and must eat gluten free food. She absolutely fell in love with how good the gluten free pizza and cheesy bread was. We raved about this place, even with the higher than normal prices. Now, I would never recommend this place to anyone.... Since day one under new management we noticed a difference in the quality of food and ingredients. Unfortunately, it has only gotten worse and worse since. I have called and complained when it's been terrible and never once offered any type of compensation. Even when we had insanely bad FOOD POISONING only a few orders after new management. Sadly, they barely cared at all.... The food itself has been EXTREMELY inconsistent. Every single order is different. Zero exaggeration! We order the same thing 99% of the time so it's not hard to notice the changes. One order the thin crust will pita thin and burnt, the next full crust, the next the edge will be three inches wide and make the pizza tiny. The sauce is way sweeter and acidic, sometimes there is a spice on the bottom of the crust, sometimes not. Sometimes things are insanely burnt or sometimes it is so doughy you can't believe it was cooked. For some strange reason when we order a Pepsi 2 liter, we'll randomly get a cherry Pepsi. The cheesey bread sticks were only gluten free before, now it's $4 extra. The cheesey bacon fries are maybe 2/3 the size they were before and somehow extra cheese is what the normal cheese was before..... I wish I would have taken more pictures of past orders but have attached tonight's order. The incredibly burnt and uncut thing is "cheesey" bread, the brown soggy but somehow burnt fries have "extra cheese", the burnt through cup was the bacon for the fries (plastic added for flavor and 1/3 the size of before).... There are many more examples but this is long enough..... Guess we will have to find a new place that has good gluten free pizza... So sad to see somewhere so damn good bought and changed so much. Probably to try and squeeze out just a little more profit at the cost of losing customers.
we dine in great friendly server had a deep fry crust pizza one of the best pizza i had and the wings were fantastic
Oh man! Our pizza was freaking delicious! It's a good thing we don't live local, otherwise we'd be here a few times a week. If you order extra cheese, expect a commercial-like stretchy cheese moment complete with the steam. We'll definitely be returning.