The Best Italian food around. Feel free to surf on the menu. I hadn't got anything that wasn't amazing.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Marta Hill
Read the fine print on items you may have ordered in the past, menu changes were a surprise.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 5
Michael Tomko
Great atmosphere. Had their pretzel it was really good. Pizza was Ok. Would have like to have a little sweeter sauce and more of it. I would come back again.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Craft Beer
Amy Nedolast
Enjoyed the live music, the service was great, and the food was great. Loved their own Italian dressing recipe, even took a pint home. Very creative menu, my only complaint would be, the menu needs word definition key! But the place is great if you love Italian!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Thea Zimmerman
Picked up carry out, order was ready exactly on time. Pizza was very good - got the Padrona and a pepperoni. Good crust and tasty toppings. The house salad was exceptional. One of the best salads we’ve gotten at a pizza place. Very fresh veggies and delicious house dressing.
Food: 5
Service: 5
German
This place will not disappoint! We MUST come here every year when we are in for the NCSAA Basketball Tournament in Mt. Vernon. The flavors and the portions are just right to satisfy your pizza craving. We got the Maui Wowie pizza. The crust was perfect and the flavors were excellent - left us wanting more! The appetizer, Carne de Papa is a must - such a healthy option that serves enough to serve as your meal instead of an appetizerThe place looks cool, and the service was great.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Debra Smith
Loved the pizza. Have not tried other menu items but will next time we go as it looked and smelled good??❣
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jeremy Wolfe
Not sure why you are not at this establishment yet. They were very accommodating and the waitresses handled are large party with-out incident. Pizzas, Salads and Wings were excellent, nothing to complain about.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Angry Pig, Chicken Wings
H. V
Food - it was ok. Pizza didn’t blow my mind but it wasn’t horrible. I was concerned when almost half the specialty options have some sort of spice (almost like the spice is masking lack of flavor). Sauce wasn’t sweet, but also wasn’t savory. Just a very mid, maybe add some option toppings to balance out acidity.Service- no issues at all. She was quick with our drinks and food l, got the check and a to go box promptly. Watching the other servers, they seemed just as quick and polite.Atmosphere- ehhh this is where it falls short. Parking is not ideal. Granted, I don’t know how you can properly fix that issue. Parking lot was full but there were multiple empty tables. That probably doesn’t help profits. Internal decor was confusing. Is it a pizza restaurant, shotgun bar, old school diner, etc? Music was depressing for a Friday night at 7pm. I’m in my upbeat happy mode, why is Zombies by The Cranberries playing?!? Seating needs to be fixed. 4-tops and smaller are packed around the perimeter while bigger groups ride the middle of the floor. If you could disperse the smaller tables evenly throughout your space while still dedicating some space to your larger tables, the vibe on the floor would be more appealing to your customers.
Pizza was decent but could use a little more flavor and was a little under cooked in the muffle. We'll come back and give it another try.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 4
Roy Blankenship
Service and atmosphere was very good.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: 4 Cheese Ravioli Marinara
S C
I want to first start by saying that the taste of the food is amazing! I mean it is absolutely outstanding but, my complaint is with the amount of food that they give you when you do carry out and most definitely with the amount of meat that you get when you do carry out. Because it's been my experience that it's differs from, eating at the restaurant, versus, carry out... And what I mean by that is that it seems like their portion is smaller and you definitely don't get as much meat and like I said that is Ben my personal experience. Also, if I'm going to pay $11 for a salad, I would like to think that maybe I could be given more than three tomatoes and more onion and olives I mean there was like next to nothing in my salad, not to mention that when I place to my order there was an issue with the online ordering so, I called in and I asked for fresh mozzarella on the salad and was told that I could not get that but online, not only can you get it but, it's actually an option that is offered to you. So with all of that being said, my last thing is tha,t the pricing was more when, the girl took my order than, what it is online or, in the restaurant. Very confusing! But, once again I want to say that, the food tastes amazing, it really does, it's just those couple of things that would make this experience out of this world if they were remedied!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 4
Tonya D'Amato
Really good special drinks! The pizza is delicious and the atmosphere is open and bright. We enjoyed our server and everything went great. We will recommend and be back!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Varvara Bondarenko
I liked Burrata. I never visited Amatos before so I only know the rebranded place. We did havw to wait a bit before we got seated (or acknowledged) but our server Savannah was very sweet and nice. I liked the food, especially the pretzel bites. The desserts were gigantic and I would prefer smaller ones.We later ordered a pizza for pickup and it was definitely a win for us. Loved their margarita.
The Best Italian food around. Feel free to surf on the menu. I hadn't got anything that wasn't amazing.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Read the fine print on items you may have ordered in the past, menu changes were a surprise.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 5
Great atmosphere. Had their pretzel it was really good. Pizza was Ok. Would have like to have a little sweeter sauce and more of it. I would come back again.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Craft Beer
Enjoyed the live music, the service was great, and the food was great. Loved their own Italian dressing recipe, even took a pint home. Very creative menu, my only complaint would be, the menu needs word definition key! But the place is great if you love Italian!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Picked up carry out, order was ready exactly on time. Pizza was very good - got the Padrona and a pepperoni. Good crust and tasty toppings. The house salad was exceptional. One of the best salads we’ve gotten at a pizza place. Very fresh veggies and delicious house dressing.
Food: 5
Service: 5
This place will not disappoint! We MUST come here every year when we are in for the NCSAA Basketball Tournament in Mt. Vernon. The flavors and the portions are just right to satisfy your pizza craving. We got the Maui Wowie pizza. The crust was perfect and the flavors were excellent - left us wanting more! The appetizer, Carne de Papa is a must - such a healthy option that serves enough to serve as your meal instead of an appetizerThe place looks cool, and the service was great.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Loved the pizza. Have not tried other menu items but will next time we go as it looked and smelled good??❣
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Not sure why you are not at this establishment yet. They were very accommodating and the waitresses handled are large party with-out incident. Pizzas, Salads and Wings were excellent, nothing to complain about.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Angry Pig, Chicken Wings
Food - it was ok. Pizza didn’t blow my mind but it wasn’t horrible. I was concerned when almost half the specialty options have some sort of spice (almost like the spice is masking lack of flavor). Sauce wasn’t sweet, but also wasn’t savory. Just a very mid, maybe add some option toppings to balance out acidity.Service- no issues at all. She was quick with our drinks and food l, got the check and a to go box promptly. Watching the other servers, they seemed just as quick and polite.Atmosphere- ehhh this is where it falls short. Parking is not ideal. Granted, I don’t know how you can properly fix that issue. Parking lot was full but there were multiple empty tables. That probably doesn’t help profits. Internal decor was confusing. Is it a pizza restaurant, shotgun bar, old school diner, etc? Music was depressing for a Friday night at 7pm. I’m in my upbeat happy mode, why is Zombies by The Cranberries playing?!? Seating needs to be fixed. 4-tops and smaller are packed around the perimeter while bigger groups ride the middle of the floor. If you could disperse the smaller tables evenly throughout your space while still dedicating some space to your larger tables, the vibe on the floor would be more appealing to your customers.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 3
Service: 4
love this place, fresh delicious
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Pizza was decent but could use a little more flavor and was a little under cooked in the muffle. We'll come back and give it another try.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 4
Service and atmosphere was very good.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: 4 Cheese Ravioli Marinara
I want to first start by saying that the taste of the food is amazing! I mean it is absolutely outstanding but, my complaint is with the amount of food that they give you when you do carry out and most definitely with the amount of meat that you get when you do carry out. Because it's been my experience that it's differs from, eating at the restaurant, versus, carry out... And what I mean by that is that it seems like their portion is smaller and you definitely don't get as much meat and like I said that is Ben my personal experience. Also, if I'm going to pay $11 for a salad, I would like to think that maybe I could be given more than three tomatoes and more onion and olives I mean there was like next to nothing in my salad, not to mention that when I place to my order there was an issue with the online ordering so, I called in and I asked for fresh mozzarella on the salad and was told that I could not get that but online, not only can you get it but, it's actually an option that is offered to you. So with all of that being said, my last thing is tha,t the pricing was more when, the girl took my order than, what it is online or, in the restaurant. Very confusing! But, once again I want to say that, the food tastes amazing, it really does, it's just those couple of things that would make this experience out of this world if they were remedied!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 4
Really good special drinks! The pizza is delicious and the atmosphere is open and bright. We enjoyed our server and everything went great. We will recommend and be back!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
I liked Burrata. I never visited Amatos before so I only know the rebranded place. We did havw to wait a bit before we got seated (or acknowledged) but our server Savannah was very sweet and nice. I liked the food, especially the pretzel bites. The desserts were gigantic and I would prefer smaller ones.We later ordered a pizza for pickup and it was definitely a win for us. Loved their margarita.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Margherita Pizza