Italian Restaurants near New Philadelphia

Uncle Primo's Italian • $$
435 Minnich Ave NW, New Philadelphia

Customers` Favorites

Chicken or Veal Parmesan
Chicken Broccoli Pasta
Blackened Walleye
Turtle Cheesecake
Eggplant Parmesan
Lasagna Classico
Chicken Alfredo
Stuffed Peppers
Heif's Salad
Baked Potato

“My wife and I went here for Valentines Day dinner (weekend after) we had a reservation for 7 and was seated around 715. Strongly recommend making one. I ordered the chicken parmasean with Alfredo and my wife ordered the eggplant parmasean with Alfredo. Both were amazing and great portions as well! Our waitress was super nice and checked in with us throughout dinner. Pricing was reasonable and food was great!“

4.4 Superb54 Reviews
Maggoo's Pizza, Pasta & More Pizza • $
1816 E High Ave, New Philadelphia

Customers` Favorites

Spaghetti and Meatballs
Small Pepperoni Pizza
House Made Pizza
Chicken Parmesan
Mozzarella Stix
Baked Spaghetti
Red Velvet Cake
Caprese Pasta
Garlic Bread
Almost Larry

“Good, not great, and there's nothing wrong with that either. I'm not going to rave about it but I'll definitely be back as I know they're consistent, and my favourite menu items are going to be exactly the same. Neat location and atmosphere that comes with it. Prices are reasonable, service can be hit or miss but I've never had truly bad service there either. All in all, Magoo's earns pretty much the most solid 4 I can give. Not a 5 star restaurant where you'll hear the word "Michelin" be used to describe anything other than a tyre, and that's all right. If you want some good old Americana Italian food or a decent pie, look no further.Kid-friendliness: Of course.Parking: Plenty of it.“

4 Good33 Reviews

3
Sbarro

Sbarro Pizza • $
400 Mill Ave SE #557, New Philadelphia

“I tried my first Stromboli here. It was so delicious!!! Comes with free marinara sauce. I can't wait to eat another one. The people who work here are hard working and always smiling. Amber, Taylor, McKenna are amazing people who represent Sbarro well!“

1 Poor2 Reviews
Olde Towne Tavern Pizza • $$
108 N Main St Box 287, Tuscarawas - 6.73 miles

Customers` Favorites

Bavarian Pretzel with Beer Cheese
Cheesy Garlic Bread Pizza
Italian Sausage Sandwich
Smothered Chicken Breast
Brick Oven Baked Pasta
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Homemade Cherry Crisp
Macaroni and Cheese
Build Your Own Pizza
Meat Lovers Pizza

“Exceptional experience!! We walked in expecting a lot after all we’ve heard and they over delivered in every area. The owners took the time to walk around and make sure everyone was enjoying themselves, the wait staff was outstanding, and the food was over the top! Get the ribeye, and the crème Brûlée !!! It couldn’t have been better!“

4.6 Superb40 Reviews
El Hefe Italian • $
232 N Tuscarawas Ave, Dover - 2.73 miles

Customers` Favorites

Crab Cakes Calamari Clams Shrimp
Strawberry Banana Cake
Panko Chicken Parmesan
El Hefe Dinner Salad
Crab Cake Appetizer
Penne Mediterranean
Meatball Sliders
Chicken Alfredo
El Hefe Burger
Chicken Marsala

“Steak, it's what's for breakfast, when you have to work and didn't have time to make anything else. Leftover Marsala Steak from EL Hefe. I admit, I'm a steak snob. I usually only like filet....and I usually make it at home....from steaks that I buy from a locally owned small business/market back in Indiana. I stock up on them anytime I'm back in Indiana. I have to tell you that this is the first steak that I have had out at a restaurant, in literally years, that I have actually liked and enjoyed. This steak was phenomenal, even reheated the next day, and it wasn't even a filet! I totally recommend! Run....don't walk to EL Hefe!“

4.4 Superb79 Reviews
Massa Mia Italiano Ristorante Italian • $$
1041 Arrowhead Rd, Bolivar - 9.85 miles

Customers` Favorites

Spaghetti Bolognese
Caprese Salad

“Spectacular place to dine! Atmosphere was entertaining with boys practicing hitting just behind the glass. My wings were huge compared to the tiny ones I’m disappointed with at other places. Drinks were made to perfection. Service was prompt and friendly!!“

4.4 Superb44 Reviews
Pangrazio's Pizza & Spaghetti Pizza • $
219 Grant St, Dennison - 8.87 miles

Customers` Favorites

Regular Noodles with Two Meatballs
Southwestern Chicken Pizza
Small Homemade Spaghetti
Personal Pizza & Salad
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Buffalo Baconsticks
Jim's Pork Delight
Gluten Free Penne
Pepperoni Pizza
Side Pepperoni

“Pizza & Cheesesticks were great!!! This was the busiest I have ever seen this place. The only problem was service was very slow. We didn't receive napkins until we were halfway done eating. Waited 15 minutes to get the pizza after eating for takeout.If you're this busy your waitresses should not be standing around talking to customers they know. We shouldn't have had to ask for napkins.“

4.4 Superb30 Reviews
The Kitchen by Pangrazio's Pizza • $
217 Grant St, Dennison - 8.86 miles

“What a great little gathering place! We needed a place, on short notice, for a celebration of life for our Grandmother and Pangrazio's came through in a big way! The staff were all amazing and the food was absolutely wonderful! Eating buffet style straight out of the kitchen was such a fitting meal to honor our Italian Grandmother. Great food, great atmosphere, and wonderful staff! Thank you Pangrazio's for everything!“

4.2 Good12 Reviews
Dennison Yard Italian • $
313 Center St, Dennison - 8.95 miles

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Parmesan Sandwich
Spaghetti and Meatballs
Homemade Spaghetti
Sausage & Peppers
Hungarian Peppers
Italian Nachos
House Salad
Greek Pizza
Garlic Toast
Side Salad

“A late afternoon lunch for 6. Between us, we had a GF pizza, Robson salad, subs, and meatloaf sandwiche. The service was good and we didn't wait long for our food. The portions were good, and everyone was pleased with what they ordered.Vegetarian options: We need more labels in the section. There are adequate options for vegetarians between salads, pizza and I think the soup of the day was also vegetarian.Dietary restrictions: There are many options for vegans, and those that eat GF. Soup, salads and pizza including a decent GF crust.Parking: There are a decent amount of parking spaces in their lot but it may get harder to find spots during peak hours.Kid-friendliness: I didn't notice if there was a kids menu, but certainly, they can accommodate families.Wheelchair accessibility: First floor entry, maybe one step outside but not sure.“

3.8 Good64 Reviews
Loading...

Discover More Cuisines In New Philadelphia

map Map