12 Best Pizza Restaurants near New Riegel

“Great small pizza joint! Absolutely amazing service, a must stop!“

“A new Crêpe Champion has risen!!She has declared that this is the best crêperie she’s ever been to, beating out EPCOT. Today’s lunch was a Loaded Tater (potatoes, cheese, bacon, sour cream) crêpe, washed down with a Nutella, marshmallow, chocolate sauce, whipped cream, and sprinkles crêpe for dessert! 10/10!!“

“I was visiting family and they said I should try this place. I am thrilled that it was delicious. Best Cannelloni I have ever had. Service was top notch and it's a wonderful place to just be. So glad there are still restaurants like this. This is a destination that will be included whenever I am in Ohio.“

“Visited on Saturday while traveling the Slice of Seneca County Pizza Trail. We couldn't eat at EVERY place in one day, so we also loaded up the truck with some carryout. Today I'm the envy of the office, because I'm having manicotti for lunch. I got the individual size, but it's a hefty tray of pasta and included salad and garlic bread, so it looks like I'll be having it again for lunch tomorrow. Love it!“

“Today was our 1st time ordering from heavenly pizza… it was fantastic! The lady who took my order was very patient when I had no idea what we should get for our party of 6. We fed the family for $30 and had plenty left over! It was delicious! We are from out of town, but will definitely stop on our way through next time!“

“Honestly hate the last rating on atmosphere so will explain...this is basically a take out restaurant in an old building...not a fancy sit down restaurant so trying to be honest. That stated it's a pizza joint with honestly the best pizza I've ever had with some amazing unusual pizzas as well! Trust me if you go won't be disappointed!“

“I hate not being able to give it 5 stars but over the weekend things were sloppy. 1 waitress for dine in and register. The place was packed. Our food was still hot and They have the best tasting pizza in Tiffin. Nice little place. They have thin crust and thick crust. Fresh toppings every time.“

“Carey Pizza Palace makes the best Foldovers. He doesn't put butter on it like some people do. I like the way he does it. And the Chef Salad was so good. Your place is always clean and your so nice. I'm glad you opened back up. I wish I would take pictures but I'm so hungry, by the time I get it I forgot. Sorry :)“

“I ordered a pizza for delivery… it came.. I literally JUST realized the driver filled out her OWN tip and wrote the total. She told me I just needed to sign and I glanced the in the process of my toddler throwing a fit and just seen it was filled out and didn’t think any of it. She left and I sat down and realized what happened. I mean cool she did sell herself short on a tip because I was going to tip a little more than she wrote but I still think the customer should be able to dictate the tip and not the driver.“

“I could only give four stars because it was my first time ordering from this place, BUT with that being said My husband and I are very very pleasantly pleased with this establishment, We ordered delivery and it arrived at a good time, the food was still hot and fresh and excellent! The Pizza was well made and toppings distributed well, I myself ordered a Veggie basket and im in love with it! I will be ordering more at a later date!“

“This Marcos does have some terrific and efficient folks working there! Very kind! At my last pick-up I watched a transaction between a well aged woman and the nice lady that was working the counter. The elderly woman didn't realize that the worker was going out of her way to help and get ve great customer service, but you could tell the worker WANTED to help and be extra kind to this elderly person! This spoke highly of the character of the employee and it also gained a loyal customer right here!“

“I have been ordering food after work; I would say they are extremely friendly! And a great place to get food from. The food is amazing and always prepped as it comes to order and taste fresh every time. Their pricing is extremely well priced. It is a very nice pizza parlor I strongly recommend on visiting this location and trying there amazing food. They have an amazing customer service.“