I had been wanting to try this place out, but kept saying, “Eh, maybe next time.” Well not anymore. My husband and I finally took the plunge. We ordered a large pierogi pizza (which was the special) and garlic knots. Both were amazing! The seasoning blend was balanced. The marinara on the side was good, and I don’t even like marinara. The pizza was rich, but the kind sir getting my beer and warned that it would be and recommended some IPAs to refresh the palate. Service on the phone and with the brew thru staff was great. They didn’t make me feel like a d-bag for not knowing how to order the pizza or not knowing what beer I wanted to try. We will definitely be back and spreading the good word.
Jason Bellfy
I have one word for you foodies out there in the Newark, OH area...CALZONES!? Sliced Up makes beautiful pizzas that are on another level of taste. Sure, they have plain cheese, cheese and pepperoni, BLT, etc...but they up their game by serving gourmet style pizzas as well using fresh ingredients; trust me, you can TASTE the difference. They are not your everyday mom and pop pizza joint. I very much enjoy their pizzas, pasta meals, and definitely their calzones!!!So come on out, Newark! Give Sliced Up a try. You will be back!?⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
R/c S
I highly recommend them the pizza best in town hands down. If you haven't yet give them a try you will not be disappointed.I will definitely be back
Jen Burch
Sliced Up Pizza was the best tasting, well thought out slice of pizza I have ever had! The combination of flavors coupled with their signature, great tasting, chewy, oil-drizzled crust was to die for! Highly recommend checking out thier weekly flavor specials, as they come up with some super rad types of pizzas. (The Cubano, The Californian, The ‘Jamaican me crazy’, just to name a few!) Not your average run of the mill pizza shop! Unique and flavorful, never boring and always made from scratch from start to finish. I always visit their shop when I’m in town visiting from San Diego!
Ohio State B.
Probably give this a 1.1. Don't waist your money on this garbage. Papa John's or Pizza Hut is honestly probably better then this. They should change the name to Throw up pizza.
Tim A.
This is easily the best local pizza shop. It's a bit of a hidden gem inside the Kwik and Kold drive thru beer dock on 21st street. Huge New York style pieces of pep or cheese, that you can buy as a whole pie or by the slice. Great lunch specials with a slice of pizza, side salad (with house made dressing) and a 20 oz drink. "One bite. Everybody knows the rules. I give it a 9.1".
Amy Gartner
This pizza is AMAZING! You don’t think to get good pizza from a drive thru but this pizza is not good it is FANTASTIC! I tried their special of the evening and it was a thin crust with a garlic sauce, portobello and button mushrooms, caramel used onions, shaved Swiss cheese and a balsamic reduction. It is beyond phenomena! I also ordered a small salad which consisted of shaved iceberg mixed with spring mix and they make their own ranch and Italian so I got both to try. Both were so yummy! Thank you for great pizza and respectful and safe service!
Amy Lynn Twyman Smith
Had sliced up pizza for the first time today it was probably the best pizza I’ve had in Newark The customer service was amazing
Charlie M.
I was pleasantly surprised by how good this pizza is. Top quality ingredients and great taste. Glad to have NYC style pizza in Newark. I will be back
Alex Becerra
Seriously good pizza, top shelf ingredients the special Cali chicken pizza was great with fresh avacado!
excellent hand made pizza, the Hawaiian specialty was amazing!
Kristan Blackledge
The chicken bacon ranch pizza (that weeks special) was okay. I would give it a 6 out of 10 and would probably get it again. The pepperoni was like Chef boyardee from a box kit. The cheese was not good at all. Their crusty was way overworked which made it tough and chewy. I would give it a 3 out of 10. My husband and kids said they will not eat here again.
Shawn Gerboc
Incredible quality that cannot be found anywhere else in Newark. Their pepperoni pizza is fantastic and sets an incredibly high bar. However, don’t be afraid to step outside of your comfort zone and definitely try their margarita pizza and their chicken stir fry pizza. So delicious.
Jessica Barker
This place is AMAZING! If any of you are tired of the same boring chain pizzas this place is a great twist! You can tell the ingredients are of the highest calibre and the pizza is always as fresh as can be! Their dough is absolutely AMAZING! I will recommend this place to everyone I know, it's just fantastic! Simple as that! Oh and this drive thru has STRAWBERRY COWTAILS!!! Just saying that's worth a mention if you haven't tried one you should!
Michelle Liotta
Fresh ingredients, house made pizza sauce from fresh san marzano tomatoes, dough made in small batches using flour imported from Italy, all fresh herbs on a butter crusted New York style pizza.
I had been wanting to try this place out, but kept saying, “Eh, maybe next time.” Well not anymore. My husband and I finally took the plunge. We ordered a large pierogi pizza (which was the special) and garlic knots. Both were amazing! The seasoning blend was balanced. The marinara on the side was good, and I don’t even like marinara. The pizza was rich, but the kind sir getting my beer and warned that it would be and recommended some IPAs to refresh the palate. Service on the phone and with the brew thru staff was great. They didn’t make me feel like a d-bag for not knowing how to order the pizza or not knowing what beer I wanted to try. We will definitely be back and spreading the good word.
I have one word for you foodies out there in the Newark, OH area...CALZONES!? Sliced Up makes beautiful pizzas that are on another level of taste. Sure, they have plain cheese, cheese and pepperoni, BLT, etc...but they up their game by serving gourmet style pizzas as well using fresh ingredients; trust me, you can TASTE the difference. They are not your everyday mom and pop pizza joint. I very much enjoy their pizzas, pasta meals, and definitely their calzones!!!So come on out, Newark! Give Sliced Up a try. You will be back!?⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
I highly recommend them the pizza best in town hands down. If you haven't yet give them a try you will not be disappointed.I will definitely be back
Sliced Up Pizza was the best tasting, well thought out slice of pizza I have ever had! The combination of flavors coupled with their signature, great tasting, chewy, oil-drizzled crust was to die for! Highly recommend checking out thier weekly flavor specials, as they come up with some super rad types of pizzas. (The Cubano, The Californian, The ‘Jamaican me crazy’, just to name a few!) Not your average run of the mill pizza shop! Unique and flavorful, never boring and always made from scratch from start to finish. I always visit their shop when I’m in town visiting from San Diego!
Probably give this a 1.1. Don't waist your money on this garbage. Papa John's or Pizza Hut is honestly probably better then this. They should change the name to Throw up pizza.
This is easily the best local pizza shop. It's a bit of a hidden gem inside the Kwik and Kold drive thru beer dock on 21st street. Huge New York style pieces of pep or cheese, that you can buy as a whole pie or by the slice. Great lunch specials with a slice of pizza, side salad (with house made dressing) and a 20 oz drink. "One bite. Everybody knows the rules. I give it a 9.1".
This pizza is AMAZING! You don’t think to get good pizza from a drive thru but this pizza is not good it is FANTASTIC! I tried their special of the evening and it was a thin crust with a garlic sauce, portobello and button mushrooms, caramel used onions, shaved Swiss cheese and a balsamic reduction. It is beyond phenomena! I also ordered a small salad which consisted of shaved iceberg mixed with spring mix and they make their own ranch and Italian so I got both to try. Both were so yummy! Thank you for great pizza and respectful and safe service!
Had sliced up pizza for the first time today it was probably the best pizza I’ve had in Newark The customer service was amazing
I was pleasantly surprised by how good this pizza is. Top quality ingredients and great taste. Glad to have NYC style pizza in Newark. I will be back
Seriously good pizza, top shelf ingredients the special Cali chicken pizza was great with fresh avacado!
Restaurantji Recommends
excellent hand made pizza, the Hawaiian specialty was amazing!
The chicken bacon ranch pizza (that weeks special) was okay. I would give it a 6 out of 10 and would probably get it again. The pepperoni was like Chef boyardee from a box kit. The cheese was not good at all. Their crusty was way overworked which made it tough and chewy. I would give it a 3 out of 10. My husband and kids said they will not eat here again.
Incredible quality that cannot be found anywhere else in Newark. Their pepperoni pizza is fantastic and sets an incredibly high bar. However, don’t be afraid to step outside of your comfort zone and definitely try their margarita pizza and their chicken stir fry pizza. So delicious.
This place is AMAZING! If any of you are tired of the same boring chain pizzas this place is a great twist! You can tell the ingredients are of the highest calibre and the pizza is always as fresh as can be! Their dough is absolutely AMAZING! I will recommend this place to everyone I know, it's just fantastic! Simple as that! Oh and this drive thru has STRAWBERRY COWTAILS!!! Just saying that's worth a mention if you haven't tried one you should!
Fresh ingredients, house made pizza sauce from fresh san marzano tomatoes, dough made in small batches using flour imported from Italy, all fresh herbs on a butter crusted New York style pizza.