First time visitor to this bakery. Will be back. !!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Donuts
Anonymous
Lived in Painesville since 2011. Never been to Gartman Bakery. Me and my daughter decided to finally go and get some donuts about 10am. As we're looking at the display of donuts. I couldn't help but think they look dry. We decided to get a variety of donuts to try anyway. And sure enough they were dry with minimal flavor. Did not taste fresh and seem as though they've been on display for awhile. Definitely wont be back. Not Good!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 4
Cheryl Basich
We've been customers for nearly fifty years! Birthday cakes, donuts, balish, cinnamon rolls and breads are all WONDERFUL! This Christmas check out their beautiful window displays. They have been in business since 1898!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Donuts, Boston Cream, Tarts, Wedding Cake
Leslie Marks
All of their baked goods are always delicious and beautiful! Their gingerbread display is so neat at Christmas too!
Travis Yocum
There aren't too many bakeries like this left.You can feel the history. We are lucky to have Gartmans in our area. It hasn't changed much since it was founded in the late 1800
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Donuts
Laura Sadler
I have nothing but great things to say! I sent in a picture of an idea for the cake and it turned out beautifully, not to mention delicious!
Beverly Maio
Bought a nut roll yesterday. Can't figure out what the dough is. Bread or cake. Really disappointing.
Bernadette Pelletier
This is a little hidden treasure in downtown Painesville off the square. It is very reminiscent of old time bakeries. I ordered and purchased a birthday cake and everyone enjoyed it. They are very accommodating to your requests here. The staff is knowledgeable and friendly. Hard to leave there without purchasing a treat to eat on the way home .Highly recommend.
Katie Goodhue
Delicious cake and pops! Our theme was “ONE in a melon” for our daughters birthday party! Cake and smash cake came out beautiful and full of flavor (almond)! The cake pops were a hit as well and perfect for little ones! Family owned business we love supporting!
Kristin Freidinger
Gartman’s did it again! Amazing cake and beautiful! Thank you for making another birthday memorable for our family. This candy bar cake was a crowd pleaser!
We had a Christmas in July party and ordered from another bakery a week in advance. They called us the day before to let us know they could not do the cookies. I called Gartman's and spoke with Brittany to ask if there was any chance they would be able to do 60 Christmas cookies in such a short notice. Without hesitation she took care of us! The cookies were delicious and the staff amazing, from ordering to pick-up! I highly recommend Gartman's as they are my families go-to place for cakes and now cookies too!! Thank you all for your exceptional customer service and delicious treats!
Jenna Rymer Guzmán
They made a cupcake cake for my daughter's birthday, and it turned out perfectly!
Stacey Mac
Hands down, this bakery has the best Balish in town (otherwise known as Kolaczki) call at least 24 hours in advance to order your favorite flavors or buy a mixture by the dozen when you walk into the store. Delicious!!
Ellen Brown
The bakery has changed. The things you used to get were fresh and moist and had a good taste. The cake was dry, like it was 3-4 days old. The donuts were bland. Very disappointed.
Jillian Siegel
They always go above and beyond my expectations! They made a cake for my daughter's birthday and it was the talk of the party.
First time visitor to this bakery. Will be back. !!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Donuts
Lived in Painesville since 2011. Never been to Gartman Bakery. Me and my daughter decided to finally go and get some donuts about 10am. As we're looking at the display of donuts. I couldn't help but think they look dry. We decided to get a variety of donuts to try anyway. And sure enough they were dry with minimal flavor. Did not taste fresh and seem as though they've been on display for awhile. Definitely wont be back. Not Good!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 4
We've been customers for nearly fifty years! Birthday cakes, donuts, balish, cinnamon rolls and breads are all WONDERFUL! This Christmas check out their beautiful window displays. They have been in business since 1898!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Donuts, Boston Cream, Tarts, Wedding Cake
All of their baked goods are always delicious and beautiful! Their gingerbread display is so neat at Christmas too!
There aren't too many bakeries like this left.You can feel the history. We are lucky to have Gartmans in our area. It hasn't changed much since it was founded in the late 1800
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Donuts
I have nothing but great things to say! I sent in a picture of an idea for the cake and it turned out beautifully, not to mention delicious!
Bought a nut roll yesterday. Can't figure out what the dough is. Bread or cake. Really disappointing.
This is a little hidden treasure in downtown Painesville off the square. It is very reminiscent of old time bakeries. I ordered and purchased a birthday cake and everyone enjoyed it. They are very accommodating to your requests here. The staff is knowledgeable and friendly. Hard to leave there without purchasing a treat to eat on the way home .Highly recommend.
Delicious cake and pops! Our theme was “ONE in a melon” for our daughters birthday party! Cake and smash cake came out beautiful and full of flavor (almond)! The cake pops were a hit as well and perfect for little ones! Family owned business we love supporting!
Gartman’s did it again! Amazing cake and beautiful! Thank you for making another birthday memorable for our family. This candy bar cake was a crowd pleaser!
Restaurantji Recommends
We had a Christmas in July party and ordered from another bakery a week in advance. They called us the day before to let us know they could not do the cookies. I called Gartman's and spoke with Brittany to ask if there was any chance they would be able to do 60 Christmas cookies in such a short notice. Without hesitation she took care of us! The cookies were delicious and the staff amazing, from ordering to pick-up! I highly recommend Gartman's as they are my families go-to place for cakes and now cookies too!! Thank you all for your exceptional customer service and delicious treats!
They made a cupcake cake for my daughter's birthday, and it turned out perfectly!
Hands down, this bakery has the best Balish in town (otherwise known as Kolaczki) call at least 24 hours in advance to order your favorite flavors or buy a mixture by the dozen when you walk into the store. Delicious!!
The bakery has changed. The things you used to get were fresh and moist and had a good taste. The cake was dry, like it was 3-4 days old. The donuts were bland. Very disappointed.
They always go above and beyond my expectations! They made a cake for my daughter's birthday and it was the talk of the party.