Best brick oven pizza! Half cheese, half extra extra cheese is a favorite in our house!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Stuffed Shells
John mcneely
Last night was the first night I have ordered from here. I've lived in canal winchester for 6 years and will have to say this was by far the best cheese pizza I have ever had. Definitely found my new pizza place.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Breadsticks, Cheese Pizza
Kaitlin Smart
Just came to say the customer service here is wonderful. I had a small issue with a charge on my credit card and the owner of the business gave me her personal cell phone number, told me to message her the details, and even replied to my texts when she was on vacation out of the country!!
Service: 5
Larry Marks
Don’t eat in! Dining area was unbearably cold. Ended up taking our pizza to the bar next door. Pizza was good.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 4
Service: 4
Kevin Davis
Usually great, but lately we've been getting burnt pizza!
Rafael Rodriguez
Couldn't add a photo sorry pizza was on my mind ? I'm from New York City, so the pizza here is spot on will drive 28 minutes to get me a pie very good and crispy there is a shop in Pickerington and in Reynoldsburg two brothers run the shop's.
Staff member who answered the phone and manager were both extremely disrespectful toward me when I called to inquire about my dietary restriction. I was hung up on by the guy who first answered the phone after telling me “it doesn’t matter what brand we use”, and when I called back to talk to the manager about the ingredients I needed to know about he told me my question was “very bizarre” and he refused to answer it??? He then proceeded to tell me I should eat somewhere else. Can’t believe how rude and unaccommodating they were. Called the other location who was kind and immediately answered my question. They ended up just giving me $10 off my order. ?Vegetarian options: Refused to tell me about ingredients
Service: 1
Charlie White
The food was not worth the money spent. The food was supposed to be delivered at 5:00 p.m. did not arrive until 5:30.
Food: 3
Service: 3
Brandi Wiatrak
Coming from Chicago, we set high standards for our pizza. We visited a few other local pizza spots and were disappointed, but we’re so happy we finally found some LEGIT pizza! Awesome sauce, crust, and sausage. Loved the ham and pineapple pizza too. Best pizza in Pickerington! Try it, you won’t be disappointed.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Meat Pizza, Zucchini Sticks
Dave King
Just ordered wings, white pizza and pepperoni pizza. Awesome!
I just wish I would’ve known sooner! My wife and I had the pepperoni rolls and the pin wheels! They were so good I didn’t even get a chance to take picture! Don’t sleep on these two menu items! I’m telling ya! Go try it for yourself! The cheese was melting over. The sauce, kinda of a marinara but a slight spice with a hint of sweet! Dough was finely tuned to a nice slight burnt texture with a crunchy final bite. To top it off, the butter poured over was the glistening touch! Dig in!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pinwheels
Betty Rubble
Marinara sauce is a little spicy for me. Try the chicken bbq pizza. Yum!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Liz D.
It was our first time trying this place. We ordered a supreme pizza and loaded fries. I really wish we spent our $54 elsewhere honestly. The pizza looked amazing but it was such a disappointment. It was extremely bland, no flavor with any ingredient on that thing. I tried to give it a little boost with the garlic butter but even that was flavorless. The loaded fries were super hot, yayyy!! But when it's topped with a cheese sauce and very little bacon, that's a cheap loaded fry to me. I would've loved to see actual shredded cheddar cheese melted on it with a good amount of bacon pieces, but sadly that wasn't the case It looked like I'm going to be sticking with Grapevine pizza from now on because it's not worth going elsewhere anymore.
Dominic Edwards
Our favorite pizza in the Columbus area. I gave it a few tries before reviewing to be sure they’re consistent, and they are consistently great. Not “Columbus style” pizza with the garbage cracker crust and square cut. It’s authentic NY style pizza. Only downside is I live slightly too far for delivery and they’re not on the delivery apps (to my knowledge). But the pizza is too good to knock the rating for a short drive. Great pizza!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jim Lim
I reviewed 3 thin crust pizzas: Here (New York Pizzeria), Romeos, and Mod pizza. I had high expectations because it was "New York" style but was sadly disappointed! You can hardly taste the sauce and the bread was kind of hard, thick, and slightly burnt. The main flavoring were the mushrooms and less on the cheese. I would not order from here again. Romeos and Mod pizza were much better in terms of taste and flavor.
Best brick oven pizza! Half cheese, half extra extra cheese is a favorite in our house!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Stuffed Shells
Last night was the first night I have ordered from here. I've lived in canal winchester for 6 years and will have to say this was by far the best cheese pizza I have ever had. Definitely found my new pizza place.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Breadsticks, Cheese Pizza
Just came to say the customer service here is wonderful. I had a small issue with a charge on my credit card and the owner of the business gave me her personal cell phone number, told me to message her the details, and even replied to my texts when she was on vacation out of the country!!
Service: 5
Don’t eat in! Dining area was unbearably cold. Ended up taking our pizza to the bar next door. Pizza was good.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 4
Service: 4
Usually great, but lately we've been getting burnt pizza!
Couldn't add a photo sorry pizza was on my mind ? I'm from New York City, so the pizza here is spot on will drive 28 minutes to get me a pie very good and crispy there is a shop in Pickerington and in Reynoldsburg two brothers run the shop's.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Garlic Knots, Pepperoni Pizza, Cheese Pizza
Staff member who answered the phone and manager were both extremely disrespectful toward me when I called to inquire about my dietary restriction. I was hung up on by the guy who first answered the phone after telling me “it doesn’t matter what brand we use”, and when I called back to talk to the manager about the ingredients I needed to know about he told me my question was “very bizarre” and he refused to answer it??? He then proceeded to tell me I should eat somewhere else. Can’t believe how rude and unaccommodating they were. Called the other location who was kind and immediately answered my question. They ended up just giving me $10 off my order. ?Vegetarian options: Refused to tell me about ingredients
Service: 1
The food was not worth the money spent. The food was supposed to be delivered at 5:00 p.m. did not arrive until 5:30.
Food: 3
Service: 3
Coming from Chicago, we set high standards for our pizza. We visited a few other local pizza spots and were disappointed, but we’re so happy we finally found some LEGIT pizza! Awesome sauce, crust, and sausage. Loved the ham and pineapple pizza too. Best pizza in Pickerington! Try it, you won’t be disappointed.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Meat Pizza, Zucchini Sticks
Just ordered wings, white pizza and pepperoni pizza. Awesome!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
I just wish I would’ve known sooner! My wife and I had the pepperoni rolls and the pin wheels! They were so good I didn’t even get a chance to take picture! Don’t sleep on these two menu items! I’m telling ya! Go try it for yourself! The cheese was melting over. The sauce, kinda of a marinara but a slight spice with a hint of sweet! Dough was finely tuned to a nice slight burnt texture with a crunchy final bite. To top it off, the butter poured over was the glistening touch! Dig in!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pinwheels
Marinara sauce is a little spicy for me. Try the chicken bbq pizza. Yum!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
It was our first time trying this place. We ordered a supreme pizza and loaded fries. I really wish we spent our $54 elsewhere honestly. The pizza looked amazing but it was such a disappointment. It was extremely bland, no flavor with any ingredient on that thing. I tried to give it a little boost with the garlic butter but even that was flavorless. The loaded fries were super hot, yayyy!! But when it's topped with a cheese sauce and very little bacon, that's a cheap loaded fry to me. I would've loved to see actual shredded cheddar cheese melted on it with a good amount of bacon pieces, but sadly that wasn't the case It looked like I'm going to be sticking with Grapevine pizza from now on because it's not worth going elsewhere anymore.
Our favorite pizza in the Columbus area. I gave it a few tries before reviewing to be sure they’re consistent, and they are consistently great. Not “Columbus style” pizza with the garbage cracker crust and square cut. It’s authentic NY style pizza. Only downside is I live slightly too far for delivery and they’re not on the delivery apps (to my knowledge). But the pizza is too good to knock the rating for a short drive. Great pizza!
Food: 5
Service: 5
I reviewed 3 thin crust pizzas: Here (New York Pizzeria), Romeos, and Mod pizza. I had high expectations because it was "New York" style but was sadly disappointed! You can hardly taste the sauce and the bread was kind of hard, thick, and slightly burnt. The main flavoring were the mushrooms and less on the cheese. I would not order from here again. Romeos and Mod pizza were much better in terms of taste and flavor.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 4