I have read all the lukewarm reviews for this place. However, HANDS DOWN, their pizza was awesome. Buckeye Pizza's thin crust was PERFECT. It was NOT overly greasy, it was crunchy and just GREAT. The Pan was a DREAM. I ordered both. Their wings were pretty good.. OVERALL.. GREAT dinner. I ordered it over the phone, they said it'd be done in 25 mins. I got there 5 mins early, and my pan pizza was still in the oven. They had order in front of me and behind me, but my order was ready when they said it would be. I know that Plain City has ALOT of pizza places, but Buckeye is one of my go to for a while.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Sharon Sarver
Our pizza was burnt. The food didn't have flavor. The atmosphere was uninviting.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 3
James Bayes
I’ve ordered from this shop for years since he opened up the “BBQ” joint that never took off. Since he has tried his hand in the pizza world in a town that has more pizza shops than stop lights. So when I tell you take you business elsewhere. Do so. They are never correct on time when quoting over the phone. Most times JUST throwing your pizza in as you come in on the time they told you it would be done over the phone. Today set me off when an employee I’ve had more than a couple interactions with. I’ve come to find out he just does it on purpose now. I walked out with my pizza (was told 20 mins and waited 35 mins in which 5 mins was my pizza sitting on top of the oven on purpose because he wanted to make me wait again he thinks he is funny and all it’s doing is causing good paying customers to other businesses. I have more than a handful of friends who run businesses who order from here, never again.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 3
Service: 1
Carrie Martin
Great place to go and socialize and the food is excellent!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Meat Lovers
Lila Wilson
We love Liz’s crust made fresh daily! Excellent pizza, ample toppings
Tim Carroll
Ordered food, paid in advance. To be delivered upstairs. 45 minutes later find out the girl had not processed the order. Took forever to get a refund..
al zill
Dine in: Yes
slmaynard723
Recently moved to the area, decided to order to go. Pick up service was timely, and received when promised. Since moving we have ordered a few times from here! The food has always tasty! Maybe the others went at bad time, but overall, our experience has been great!! Would definitely return!
Hope
This place is disgusting. No one ever wears gloves, the floors are visibly covered in dirt, mud, and pizza/food products. Not to mention the horrible customer services and the way the owner acts! I have gotten nothing but attitude and disrespect the few (and only) times i have been in there. Definitely losing my money and hopefully other customers will see the truth as well.
Jake Williams
I just had the Kickin Bourbon traditional wings from Buckeye BBQ and Pizza… Absolutely amazing!!! Arguably the best wings and sauce I’ve ever had
Pizza is OKAY. Spicy pepperoni, tasty crust, great thickness for the pan pizza, but it really tasted like every other small pizzeria out there.
Rodney Kroninger
Best food on earth
Mike Conley
Well I have called the number they have listed online about eight times in the past 45 and no answer... so 1 star sadly. Heard such good things .... will update later
Ryan Lane
I wanted to try their pizza bad, came by at around 5:30pm on a Friday night and doors were locked shop was closed. How do you expect to make a good first impression for a prospective new customer when you aren’t even open on a Friday night? I’m sorry, poor customer service.. I won’t be back
Jose Marro
So delicious pizza.I recommend this place 100%So good and very friendly people!
I have read all the lukewarm reviews for this place. However, HANDS DOWN, their pizza was awesome. Buckeye Pizza's thin crust was PERFECT. It was NOT overly greasy, it was crunchy and just GREAT. The Pan was a DREAM. I ordered both. Their wings were pretty good.. OVERALL.. GREAT dinner. I ordered it over the phone, they said it'd be done in 25 mins. I got there 5 mins early, and my pan pizza was still in the oven. They had order in front of me and behind me, but my order was ready when they said it would be. I know that Plain City has ALOT of pizza places, but Buckeye is one of my go to for a while.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Our pizza was burnt. The food didn't have flavor. The atmosphere was uninviting.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 3
I’ve ordered from this shop for years since he opened up the “BBQ” joint that never took off. Since he has tried his hand in the pizza world in a town that has more pizza shops than stop lights. So when I tell you take you business elsewhere. Do so. They are never correct on time when quoting over the phone. Most times JUST throwing your pizza in as you come in on the time they told you it would be done over the phone. Today set me off when an employee I’ve had more than a couple interactions with. I’ve come to find out he just does it on purpose now. I walked out with my pizza (was told 20 mins and waited 35 mins in which 5 mins was my pizza sitting on top of the oven on purpose because he wanted to make me wait again he thinks he is funny and all it’s doing is causing good paying customers to other businesses. I have more than a handful of friends who run businesses who order from here, never again.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 3
Service: 1
Great place to go and socialize and the food is excellent!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Meat Lovers
We love Liz’s crust made fresh daily! Excellent pizza, ample toppings
Ordered food, paid in advance. To be delivered upstairs. 45 minutes later find out the girl had not processed the order. Took forever to get a refund..
Dine in: Yes
Recently moved to the area, decided to order to go. Pick up service was timely, and received when promised. Since moving we have ordered a few times from here! The food has always tasty! Maybe the others went at bad time, but overall, our experience has been great!! Would definitely return!
This place is disgusting. No one ever wears gloves, the floors are visibly covered in dirt, mud, and pizza/food products. Not to mention the horrible customer services and the way the owner acts! I have gotten nothing but attitude and disrespect the few (and only) times i have been in there. Definitely losing my money and hopefully other customers will see the truth as well.
I just had the Kickin Bourbon traditional wings from Buckeye BBQ and Pizza… Absolutely amazing!!! Arguably the best wings and sauce I’ve ever had
Restaurantji Recommends
Pizza is OKAY. Spicy pepperoni, tasty crust, great thickness for the pan pizza, but it really tasted like every other small pizzeria out there.
Best food on earth
Well I have called the number they have listed online about eight times in the past 45 and no answer... so 1 star sadly. Heard such good things .... will update later
I wanted to try their pizza bad, came by at around 5:30pm on a Friday night and doors were locked shop was closed. How do you expect to make a good first impression for a prospective new customer when you aren’t even open on a Friday night? I’m sorry, poor customer service.. I won’t be back
So delicious pizza.I recommend this place 100%So good and very friendly people!