Bake Me Treats

16 S Main St, Poland
(234) 254-4005

Recent Reviews

Brandon Maceyko

Highly recommend! A must stop bakery for any sweet tooth looking for custom cakes, pastries, or macaroons

Erin Moeller

I love BMT I bring treats to every holiday ! There menu is always so cute and everyone that works at the shop is so fun. Not to mention excellent at their jobs! Such a great addition to the area!!!

chris moffo

My first time visiting this place. Has some of the best desserts.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Assorted Macarons, Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip Cookie, Funfetti Cutout Cookie, Cake Blah Blahs, Assorted Cupcakes

Anthony V.

Cute, adorable designs made by a woman who you can tell loves what she does! You can taste the dedication to detail in every bite!

Julie Foster Petrilla

We ordered just a 48 macaron order for our graduation party and I had wished we ordered more. They were outstanding! I had ordered ahead and they were ready and fresh when I picked them up. Thank you so much!

Brittani Drake

Staff was so nice! We went to the North Market today for my first time and we stumbled, almost literally, upon these sweet ladies selling their macarons. I've never really tired them before and they were so helpful answering my questions. Would definitely recommend!

Brittany Cuba

Went to the Watermelon Sugar High fest today. It was really fun. I had never been to Bake Me Treats before and was excited to try their baked goods. We did the coloring sheet, and we were able to get a free cupcake! It was absolutely delicious, and im excited to go back and try other things as well! Thank you for such a fun day.

Kelly Wolford

We love all of the baked goods they offer and it's a treasure to have this unique bakery in our area. They have shipping available which is very expedited and they will be glad to help if you have trouble placing your order. Thank you Bake Me Treats!!

Trish L

Second time visiting, second time disappointed. They make very good macaroons, but the consistency of their other goods seems to be hit or miss.My first visit, I purchased three items as a taste test for me and my friend. Two macaroons, one oatmeal, cream pie, and a very small cake (they’d sold out of white cupcakes by the time we’d arrived). The macaroons were very good as was the oatmeal cream pie, but the cake was very dry/stale and most of it ended up getting thrown away.I had told a couple people how good the oatmeal cream pies were, and decided to surprise them with some this week. I was there first thing on Tuesday morning (they are closed Sunday and Monday) and nothing was out except a couple trays of cupcakes and the macaroons. Figuring they had been baking early that morning and just didn’t have time to put things out, I asked if they had any oatmeal cream pies. They went in the back and brought out a plastic container from the refrigerator. I was charged $15 for four cookies that were so stale two of them ended up in the trash. I even tried letting them get to room temp, but it didn’t help. Very disappointing as I had talked them up so much.Unfortunately, I won’t be returning to this bakery. For the price they are charging, consistency should be a priority.

Susan Ellsworth

Thank you Bake Me Treats for the most beautiful and spectacular tasting cake for my daughter’s wedding. The macaroon tower was delicious as well.

Karen Cooksey

First visit & won't be my last!!!OMG. Try the macarons! They are THE BEST I've ever had!!! The cupcakes are luscious with some of the best tasting & textured buttercream I've had. I still have items to try but I'm hooked!!

L

Over the last few years I always come here to buy macaroons and they were always so delicious. This year I decided to buy my mom a birthday cake from them and it was so delicious and not overpowered with sugar it was the perfect amount of sugar. I highly recommend getting a cake from here. And now that I am engaged I will be looking into having my wedding cake made by them.

Shelby Goldman

Absolutely delicious!! I ordered a bunch of different macarons and every single one was as good as the next. Also had their peanut butter chocolate chip cookie and oatmeal sandwich cookies, perfection.

Samantha M.

I am a self-certified bakery snob, and the treats here live up to my high standards. They are one of the few walk-in bakeries in the area that uses Swiss meringue buttercream for their cupcakes, and it is that difference that puts them on a different level than others. All of their treats are both delicious and beautiful to look at. The macarons are some of the best I've had. I normally make my own birthday cake, but have requested one from here this year!

Ashley Malone

Stopped by this morning to try some macarons and got some blah blahs (cake pops without the stick). They were so good! Everyone was super friendly and helpful! Can’t wIt to try more flavors!

Load More