My favorite standard pizza ever. Jalapeno combination is delicious with how the jalapeno juices mix in with their top tier sauce can't recommend mama enough!
Jason Caruso
Hands down, best pizza in town. Get jalapeños on whatever pizza you get. The spice blends in with the red sauce for a taste you can't find anywhere else. One of the only places left that can fill you and your colleagues up for less than $10 per person. Cannot recommend Dear Mama's intensely enough!
Sandy Davis
They always treat me like family when I order. Always smiling when one of us walk thru the door. Definitely in the top tiers of pizza in ohio. 100% recommended.
Patrick Zychowski
This is the best pie I’ve ever had in my life, already sliced, didn’t even need a knife. Fat Bobs needs a diet, Ohio pie ain’t even from Ohio so don’t even try it, Angelo’s is too far away for a local man like myself, so I always keep a slice of dear mamas, up on the shelf. If I can’t get pizza here, Id rather not. Why would I get pizza somewhere else, that compares to snot. Family owned, everyone is polite, they have consistency, and absolutely amazing service. Top notch pizza spot as ffff
Travis Horvath
Tried a classic pepperoni and a chicken bacon ranch and they were both delicious. The charred edges were great. The pepperoni was the favorite of the night. Excellent pizza, we will order again!
Victor Santana Jr.
Dear Mam's Pizza overall was ok/average to us. Food was good but nothing amazing in our option. We got a couple different Pies. Felt like it could of been cook a little longer, was a little too doughy still. Hope to try again and it be a little bette next time
Müs Chip
Edit: after discussing the situation with the owner, she offered a discount due to the inconvenience, and deeply apologized. Changing the rating to 5 star for outstanding service. The pizza we ordered was delicious. Reminded me of a blend of Detroit style and authentic Italian. Sauce is a bit on the sweeter side, if you like savory, request light sauce. The chicken had a great texture and breading flavor was great. Proud to have this establishment in my home city!Went to their website to put an order in and the site showed as open on labor day, I put the order in, they charged my card. I arrived to find out they were closed. Will be calling for a refund next day. The site should have been updated for holiday hours.
kayla p
If you’re vegan, YOU MUST GO. Holy amazing. The cheesy bread, the BBQ vegan chicken (add pineapple), the white sauce with vegan pepperoni. All AMAZING. the shop itself has separate stations as well for all the vegan pizzas which just about made me cry. My mom got a reg pizza and said she could have eaten the whole 6 cut pie in one sitting it was so good. I will for sure be back here soon for more vegan pizza :)
Joe
Great pizza. Detroit style, with the square cuts and sauce on top. Very good dough, loved the charred edges. Sauce was a sweeter sauce but it didn’t over power the rest of the pizza. A large/10 slices was a pretty decent size and the prices were comparable. The inside pickup area was super clean and not cluttered. I look forward to coming back.
Leanne Zuzich
Have you tried Dear Mama's yet?? If not, what are you waiting for lol...the cheesy bacon jalapeño bread & the cinnamon dough bites are ???I love talking to the owner (I think) when I go in, she's so sweet. Everything has been good that we've ordered but the cheese bacon jalapeño bread & cinnamon things will always hold a special place in my heart.Go support a great small business
I ordered for the 1st time , it was delicious! The toppings were fresh and the pizza not greasy. The boneless wings were meaty and tasty, the side sauces(garlic/parm and Louisiana heat) were awesome too! I will be back!
Marlena Marcella
This place is AMAZING! 2nd time ordering from here and it is once again, delicious! My new favorite place. ??
Rebecca Cooper
We just tried it tonight for the first time and it is SO good. We placed the order online, and within a couple minutes, they called to confirm a substitution to ensure they got it right. We got the philly cheesesteak pizza and a wings and jojo meal. Everything was SO GOOD, and the order was exactly right. We found our go-to pizza place!
Kara Schuster
Great pizza and great service! Super nice people. Pizza never disappoints! Their cheesy bread is also fantastic.
C Y
We wanted to try something new, and based on a recommendation from a friend, we tried That's Amore. It definitely didn't disappoint. We had cheesy bread, the large salad, a cheese pizza and the Philly cheese steak pizza. Everything was delicious. The portions were perfect, prices are great, and customer service was above and beyond, everyone was happy. My entire family said this should be our new "go to."
My favorite standard pizza ever. Jalapeno combination is delicious with how the jalapeno juices mix in with their top tier sauce can't recommend mama enough!
Hands down, best pizza in town. Get jalapeños on whatever pizza you get. The spice blends in with the red sauce for a taste you can't find anywhere else. One of the only places left that can fill you and your colleagues up for less than $10 per person. Cannot recommend Dear Mama's intensely enough!
They always treat me like family when I order. Always smiling when one of us walk thru the door. Definitely in the top tiers of pizza in ohio. 100% recommended.
This is the best pie I’ve ever had in my life, already sliced, didn’t even need a knife. Fat Bobs needs a diet, Ohio pie ain’t even from Ohio so don’t even try it, Angelo’s is too far away for a local man like myself, so I always keep a slice of dear mamas, up on the shelf. If I can’t get pizza here, Id rather not. Why would I get pizza somewhere else, that compares to snot. Family owned, everyone is polite, they have consistency, and absolutely amazing service. Top notch pizza spot as ffff
Tried a classic pepperoni and a chicken bacon ranch and they were both delicious. The charred edges were great. The pepperoni was the favorite of the night. Excellent pizza, we will order again!
Dear Mam's Pizza overall was ok/average to us. Food was good but nothing amazing in our option. We got a couple different Pies. Felt like it could of been cook a little longer, was a little too doughy still. Hope to try again and it be a little bette next time
Edit: after discussing the situation with the owner, she offered a discount due to the inconvenience, and deeply apologized. Changing the rating to 5 star for outstanding service. The pizza we ordered was delicious. Reminded me of a blend of Detroit style and authentic Italian. Sauce is a bit on the sweeter side, if you like savory, request light sauce. The chicken had a great texture and breading flavor was great. Proud to have this establishment in my home city!Went to their website to put an order in and the site showed as open on labor day, I put the order in, they charged my card. I arrived to find out they were closed. Will be calling for a refund next day. The site should have been updated for holiday hours.
If you’re vegan, YOU MUST GO. Holy amazing. The cheesy bread, the BBQ vegan chicken (add pineapple), the white sauce with vegan pepperoni. All AMAZING. the shop itself has separate stations as well for all the vegan pizzas which just about made me cry. My mom got a reg pizza and said she could have eaten the whole 6 cut pie in one sitting it was so good. I will for sure be back here soon for more vegan pizza :)
Great pizza. Detroit style, with the square cuts and sauce on top. Very good dough, loved the charred edges. Sauce was a sweeter sauce but it didn’t over power the rest of the pizza. A large/10 slices was a pretty decent size and the prices were comparable. The inside pickup area was super clean and not cluttered. I look forward to coming back.
Have you tried Dear Mama's yet?? If not, what are you waiting for lol...the cheesy bacon jalapeño bread & the cinnamon dough bites are ???I love talking to the owner (I think) when I go in, she's so sweet. Everything has been good that we've ordered but the cheese bacon jalapeño bread & cinnamon things will always hold a special place in my heart.Go support a great small business
Restaurantji Recommends
I ordered for the 1st time , it was delicious! The toppings were fresh and the pizza not greasy. The boneless wings were meaty and tasty, the side sauces(garlic/parm and Louisiana heat) were awesome too! I will be back!
This place is AMAZING! 2nd time ordering from here and it is once again, delicious! My new favorite place. ??
We just tried it tonight for the first time and it is SO good. We placed the order online, and within a couple minutes, they called to confirm a substitution to ensure they got it right. We got the philly cheesesteak pizza and a wings and jojo meal. Everything was SO GOOD, and the order was exactly right. We found our go-to pizza place!
Great pizza and great service! Super nice people. Pizza never disappoints! Their cheesy bread is also fantastic.
We wanted to try something new, and based on a recommendation from a friend, we tried That's Amore. It definitely didn't disappoint. We had cheesy bread, the large salad, a cheese pizza and the Philly cheese steak pizza. Everything was delicious. The portions were perfect, prices are great, and customer service was above and beyond, everyone was happy. My entire family said this should be our new "go to."