Neumeister's Candy Shoppe

2447 W Market St, Tiffin
(419) 379-9088

Recent Reviews

Emily Fouts

Delicious ice cream and really friendly service! Also got some chocolates while we were there and those were great too. The ice cream I got was the mermaid sundae and it was amazing!!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Eric Peacock

I saw someone complaining about the price in another review but what they didn't mention is that the portions are a very good size. I'll definitely be coming back here

Justin Reiter

The service was amazing and the product was worth every penny!

Bryler Beamer

Great place and even better ice cream

M. Duschl

The place was very clean, the people were very nice. The portions were huge, many choices of sprinkles and things. It was nice to have a place that was calm and not rush rush like a typical ice cream place.

Memoo

If you love chocolate and ice cream this is the place! Very helpful staff. So many choices!

Michael Estep

There chocolate coveted pretzels ate stale.

Anthony Chwalek

Awesome service outstanding products

Dawn N.

If you love chocolate and ice cream this is the place! Very helpful staff. So many choices!

Viper Driver

Awesome banana split!

jkrslkay

My sister and I ate dinner there last night and it was delicious. The ice cream was very tasty and creamy. The manager was extremely nice and helpful. Would definitely recommend

Chris Chase

Lovely people with a great product!

stephanie Vanbuskirk

I wasn't impressed by this shop at all and I even tried it twice with my kids.Decor is extremely minimal, not a whole lot in the way of eye candy.None of the candies in the cases really stand out as something special that you can only get at this shop.The ice cream is very much just regular ice cream.I watched the lady make my kids monster sundaes and it was very much something you could do on you own after a trip to Walmart for the ingredients, none if it was homemade ingredients. My son ordered a buckeye sundae, and the only peanut butter in it was from the two buckeyes she placed on top, take those off its just plain chocolate ice cream under a mountain of redi whip. My daughters was similar, however the canned frosting used to decorate the rim had an overwhelming old taste to it. Spoiler alert, the 'unicorn' is all plain vanilla, under again too much rediwhip. It was extremely over priced for something so unoriginal and plain.As for service, I was a bit upset that the woman who 'helped us' pushed us into ordering the sundaes after I had said we wanted milkshakes. By 'push' I mean wouldn't stop suggesting it would be a better option until I finally gave in and ordered them.Both experiences at this shop were unsatisfactory and the chances of my return are highly doubtful, I will not be recommending this shop unless it is to avoid it.

Jaselinn Torez

Absolutely AMAZING!! This is a hidden gem and the service was ASTOUNDING and you could feel the love from the owner and her employee. Everything was just delicious we will definitely be back for some new treats to try

Sharon Moloney

The best candy around, and the ice cream is excellent!!

Load More