Pizza Restaurants near Wellsville

“I got half a sheet of pizza today while I was in town, right after they opened. It was some of the best Nick's I've had since I was a kid. We didn't eat it for about an hour after I got it, due to driving back to the Youngstown area, and the crust was still crunchy like it's supposed to be and just so good. thank you!“

“The Italian pizza is the best thing I’ve ever experienced! I’ve yet to have a pizza I didn’t like from here. It’s 30 mins from my house and I have to pass several other pizza places to get there, and I continue to do just that. 10/10.“

“We really like this, but yesterday they were short of help n very busy. Felt sorry for them. We didn't have to wait long n she did the best she could. Pick up n man delivering was extremely busy. It's terrible on a Memorial weekend that they didn't have more employees there.“

“We walked in and was going to get pizza the owner was making pepperoni rolls was full of pepperoni and cheese. The batch he was making was the second batch for the day there were only there are only two left of the first batch and they were still warm. They were as good as they look when he was making them.“

“The pizza is really top notch with the over fire and very flavorful. I usually don't eat the crust but it was garnished with flavor and not a crumb was left. Mixed drinks were also pretty good and mixed just right. We also enjoyed having so much room in a large former bank building and got to see the vault.“

“Absolutely, love ice dogs, everything they have. The Pulice's that own it are the greatest people in the world. The girls that work there are funny and smart And always happy to see me. they take great care of me and my Dave. Highly Recommended.“

“First time ordering from Romeo's and was extremely happy. Had to make couple phone calls with questions and Natasha was kind and so helpful with the questions my wife and I had. We ordered a stromboli, calzone and THE GODFATHER SUB. Let me tell you the cheese combo is out of this world and yes sauce is sweet but it did grow on me. The stromboli and calzone were greasy on inside but they were packed with meat and cheese and that soft scrumptious dough is making my mouth water just writing this. Lastly, The Godfather Sub let me just say OLHELLYEAH. Looking forward to trying the pizza next. Thank you for a wonderful experience Romeo's ??.“

“I’ve been searching for a restaurant in the surrounding area, stupid Ville, Ohio, and Toronto, Ohio. I found this restaurant, and let me tell you, their hoagie is the best I’ve ever had in Ohio. I had to drive to Pittsburgh, as I’m from South Park Suburbs of Pittsburgh, and that’s the only area that I can have found good Italian hoagies. Now Paul’s Pizza is my go to place from now on. Friendly and great food. I highly recommend this Pizza joint for your enjoyment! Five Stars.“

“When I call in my order I'm always greeted by friendly staff. The food tastes amazing every time and sooo filling! I order several nights a week. It's a great choice for dinner whatever you're craving. They have really good pizza and wings too!“

“Romas Pizza in Chester, WV is hands down the best pizza on the East Coast. Most places go with square slices and try to imitate DiCarlos style of pizza. Their classic round pizza is just how I like it and there's something about their pizza sauce and pizza dough that separates them from everyone else . Their wings are amazing as well.. if you haven't checked them out I definitely suggest doing so. You won't be disappointed.“

“Wow! This place is phenomenal! Fast service, delicious food and milkshakes! We will definitely be back. Our waitress Lauren was great too. I was hoping they had everything to make my favorite drink, a tiramisu martini. They didn't, but the bartender went over and above, and made me something really close. It was great! No idea what she put in it, but I commend her for going out of the way to try to make something I liked!Kid-friendliness: Restaurant side and a bar side. Great for people with kids, like myself“

“Not sure what's wrong with these people that don't give this place all five stars. I grew up in this town and on Bruno's and Bosco's Pizza. This stuff tastes the same as it did when I was a kid and that is absolutely wonderful. I just had my girlfriend drive me a half a tray all the way back to Indiana and it was the first time I have tasted that deliciousness since the 90s. You guys do a great job. You did that and you still do now keep it up.“

“I went here back in January, and I still love the memory to this day. The food was great, especially the calzone. The woman at the front desk was extremely kind and generous; it’s a nice family-driven atmosphere. We came from almost an hour out and didn’t regret it, I hope to go back soon!“

“Me and my husband tried this place out for the first time last night. We ordered the deluxe pizza and 12 wings. I would honestly have to say it was the best pizza I had in a long time. I would recommend that you order ahead of time because we waited a while for the food. We will be ordering again....WORTH THE WAIT.“

“I'm from Buffalo so I know good pizza. It's not buffalo pizza but it decentIt's a flat crust. Sauce is unique and tasty. Bit crispy crust. They sizing is odd. A large pizza is actual a sheet pizza which is about 24 slicesThey aren't badly priced.Would eat here again“

“Didn’t take a pic of the pizza but we ❤️ Bruno’s pizza! Omg I’ve been coming here anytime I’m in the area since I was a child. I have since hooked my husband on it and now both of our kids! We recently had to go to East Liverpool and first thing my 20 yr old says is his Bruno’s order. It’s a must try if you haven’t had it!“

“Great place ran by great people! Very friendly and reasonably priced! The only complaint I have is the quality of the pizza is inconsistent its never terrible but will be amazing one time and ok the next like today for instance the crust was just way too hard it was a bit difficult to chew it and the sauce was too heavy running off the pizza with every bite still tasty just not up to par with what they're capable of producing!Wheelchair accessibility: Easily accessible“

“Honestly, I have moved back from Florida after 11 years and my mouth. Actually my teeth watered for Dicarlo’s Pizza, but now Ohio Valley Pizza, which is part of that fantastic wonderful pizza, you made me happy. I will never ever order any pizza but yours because it’s perfect. Damn I’m so excited I’ve hated pizza for 11 years now I’m home. “

“I work with adults with intellectual disabilities. Today, me and my coworker brought four of our clients in to eat lunch. Our waitress (Sophia I believe) was probably the kindest waitress I’ve ever had. She didn’t bat an eye at us needing six separate checks, she was patient and sweet to our clients, she was attentive… Just overall fantastic. The food was also delicious. I got the meatball calzone (without the peppers) and the pepperoni logs. So freaking good! My coworker got the chicken Alfredo pasta, which she let me try. Really good! Our clients got pizza, a burger, chicken tenders, and the white cheddar Mac and cheese. Their food all looked really good and they all were happy. The only thing I’m disappointed about is that I live far away and I’m rarely in the area, so my opportunities to come back will be few and far between.“