They are always on time and they are super friendly.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Any Sub, Pepperoni Pizza
Beth Staton
Best pizza
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Mike Stewart
Stopped by here on my way home a few days back and got a small pepperoni and cheese pizza. It was absolutely delicious. The sauce, cheese, crust, and pep were all top notch! Can't wait for next time!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza
Jeff Ward
The service sucked, the girl that waited on us, correction the girl that asked us what we wanted was rude, and very unsocial. Literally wanted pep, cheese, half olives, and got half cheese no olives and very little pepperoni. The first and last time ever getting the pizza.
Darrick Drakulich
West Jefferson doesn't take pizza lightly but i think Mike's Pizza tops the list. Easily the best pizza place in town. My daughters new favorite pizza place
Brooke Wetzel
The only pizza place we order from! Great prices and even better food. Everyone who works there is nice! The only thing that I don't like is their hours but definitely worth waiting for them to open.Parking: There's a few spots right in front of the shop. A few on the side, but you can park in the back of Shell's Parking lot if you can't find a spot out front
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Bites
Susan Kanode
Hands down, usually the best thin crust pizzas in Central Ohio! Must have been really busy, my thin crust was a thick crust and my extra cheese was light cheese. Really disappointed in my pie this time!
Geanita Smith (Nita)
Always very polite worked very helpful if you need. Great food shirts nice and hot
Geanita Smith
Always very polite worked very helpful if you need. Great food shirts nice and hot
Nicole M.
Good pizza, try their wings too! They are pretty good and won't break the bank. They also have gluten free for those who want/need it.
Ordered a sub and cheese bites tonight and it was absolutely amazing. I moved to Cincinnati two years ago and just moved back into town and I knew the exact pizza spot I was going to once we moved back in! Mikes pizza is the best!
Susan Justus
We ordered subs and pizza tonight. I'd highly recommend it. Definitely hit the spot.was here when they said was hot and the driver very nice.i love there subs and pizza. Ty Mikes
Gage Kimbler
Very bad customer service and very bad pizza. Cheap on the cheese and very bad dough. Wouldn’t recommend anyone to eat anything from here seemed like dough wasn’t even fully cooked.
Noah Slade
Rude and disgusting. Do not go here. After waiting over 10 minutes for someone to address me I was greeted with nothing short of anger and rudeness. The kicker ... when I finally received my order it was the worst pizza I have ever had in my life and I am 80 years old and eat pizza at least once a week.
Derek J
Great value for the money! You really cant beat it.
They are always on time and they are super friendly.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Any Sub, Pepperoni Pizza
Best pizza
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Stopped by here on my way home a few days back and got a small pepperoni and cheese pizza. It was absolutely delicious. The sauce, cheese, crust, and pep were all top notch! Can't wait for next time!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza
The service sucked, the girl that waited on us, correction the girl that asked us what we wanted was rude, and very unsocial. Literally wanted pep, cheese, half olives, and got half cheese no olives and very little pepperoni. The first and last time ever getting the pizza.
West Jefferson doesn't take pizza lightly but i think Mike's Pizza tops the list. Easily the best pizza place in town. My daughters new favorite pizza place
The only pizza place we order from! Great prices and even better food. Everyone who works there is nice! The only thing that I don't like is their hours but definitely worth waiting for them to open.Parking: There's a few spots right in front of the shop. A few on the side, but you can park in the back of Shell's Parking lot if you can't find a spot out front
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Bites
Hands down, usually the best thin crust pizzas in Central Ohio! Must have been really busy, my thin crust was a thick crust and my extra cheese was light cheese. Really disappointed in my pie this time!
Always very polite worked very helpful if you need. Great food shirts nice and hot
Always very polite worked very helpful if you need. Great food shirts nice and hot
Good pizza, try their wings too! They are pretty good and won't break the bank. They also have gluten free for those who want/need it.
Restaurantji Recommends
Ordered a sub and cheese bites tonight and it was absolutely amazing. I moved to Cincinnati two years ago and just moved back into town and I knew the exact pizza spot I was going to once we moved back in! Mikes pizza is the best!
We ordered subs and pizza tonight. I'd highly recommend it. Definitely hit the spot.was here when they said was hot and the driver very nice.i love there subs and pizza. Ty Mikes
Very bad customer service and very bad pizza. Cheap on the cheese and very bad dough. Wouldn’t recommend anyone to eat anything from here seemed like dough wasn’t even fully cooked.
Rude and disgusting. Do not go here. After waiting over 10 minutes for someone to address me I was greeted with nothing short of anger and rudeness. The kicker ... when I finally received my order it was the worst pizza I have ever had in my life and I am 80 years old and eat pizza at least once a week.
Great value for the money! You really cant beat it.