Best ice cream from local spot. Super nice service and amazing atmosphere. Must go place
Maryn E.
They have some of the best ice cream around! They flavors are always on point, and for it being made there, it's really well priced. This is a family favorite after soccer games or the fair. It has flavors and options for everyone. They also have a nice playground outside for when it's warm.
YahYah
Love it!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chocolate Ice Cream
Lisa T.
Always the best everything! We can't wait to get milk when we visit from California! We love this milk the chocolate milk too soo good! Ice cream is a must! So many options! Rootbeer floats! Cheese and butter so yummy!
Heather Ramsier
I use to love this place, but recently it seems their ice cream just doesn’t have the flavor it once did. I love the atmosphere and the play area outside for the kids.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 4
Stan DeSalsa
Best dairy family around. Try the chocolate milk first time & it was absolutely delicious ?Can't wait to try more of your favorite products ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chocolate Ice Cream, Small Flavored Milk, Banana Split, Chocolate Milk, Half and Half
Jen Comito
Super yummy PB sundae ?! We could even get a mini version for half price.
We had gotten your eggnog from our daughter because she didnt use it at Christmas. It sat in the fridge and I finally opened it the other day. I’ve had it before from other places and it seemed too thin and not that flavorful. Yours was the best I have ever tasted! It was smooth, seasoned just right and mixed well with rum! I definitely will be buying it again and telling everyone I know about it!
Wicho Barron
Worst strawberry ice cream I've ever had.I'm all about family owned places, I'm leaving this review because we discretely told the staff the ice cream was bad and they kept it on the shelf as nothing bad ever happened to it.They did offer a replacement but I didn't accept it cause I wasn't in the mood for more.Heck I even bought merchandise while waiting for the ice cream.Again, if they would've put the ice cream away, I wouldn't leave this review.The butter pecan ice cream was also sub standard.I even thought it was me but all my family tried it and said the same thing.Bland, watery, artificially flavored ice cream
All I can say is I purchased your eggnog from a local farm and it is the best I ever had.
Food: 5
Brian Reading
Driving by figuring we stopped pickup some chocolate milk. Oh so good couple pints of ice cream, big old bottle of eggnog for the holidays.
Service: 5
Jeff Taylor
Amazing ice cream and friendly staff!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chocolate Ice Cream
Melissa Reading
On our trip to Wooster it was a pleasant surprise to find a Hartzler store while driving by. I just love their milk.... chocolate, all the flavors, ice cream and their egg nog! I was lucky to find their eggnog so I can Make my tasty pie for Thanksgiving!! Can't wait to stop by again to try more ice cream flavors.
Rich W.
Great ice cream very clean Store with lots of friendly staff Don't forget to grab some fresh milk still in the glass bottles
Best ice cream from local spot. Super nice service and amazing atmosphere. Must go place
They have some of the best ice cream around! They flavors are always on point, and for it being made there, it's really well priced. This is a family favorite after soccer games or the fair. It has flavors and options for everyone. They also have a nice playground outside for when it's warm.
Love it!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chocolate Ice Cream
Always the best everything! We can't wait to get milk when we visit from California! We love this milk the chocolate milk too soo good! Ice cream is a must! So many options! Rootbeer floats! Cheese and butter so yummy!
I use to love this place, but recently it seems their ice cream just doesn’t have the flavor it once did. I love the atmosphere and the play area outside for the kids.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 4
Best dairy family around. Try the chocolate milk first time & it was absolutely delicious ?Can't wait to try more of your favorite products ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chocolate Ice Cream, Small Flavored Milk, Banana Split, Chocolate Milk, Half and Half
Super yummy PB sundae ?! We could even get a mini version for half price.
Ice cream was good. Quality of Milk was so
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chocolate Ice Cream, Chocolate Milk
We had gotten your eggnog from our daughter because she didnt use it at Christmas. It sat in the fridge and I finally opened it the other day. I’ve had it before from other places and it seemed too thin and not that flavorful. Yours was the best I have ever tasted! It was smooth, seasoned just right and mixed well with rum! I definitely will be buying it again and telling everyone I know about it!
Worst strawberry ice cream I've ever had.I'm all about family owned places, I'm leaving this review because we discretely told the staff the ice cream was bad and they kept it on the shelf as nothing bad ever happened to it.They did offer a replacement but I didn't accept it cause I wasn't in the mood for more.Heck I even bought merchandise while waiting for the ice cream.Again, if they would've put the ice cream away, I wouldn't leave this review.The butter pecan ice cream was also sub standard.I even thought it was me but all my family tried it and said the same thing.Bland, watery, artificially flavored ice cream
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 2
Restaurantji Recommends
All I can say is I purchased your eggnog from a local farm and it is the best I ever had.
Food: 5
Driving by figuring we stopped pickup some chocolate milk. Oh so good couple pints of ice cream, big old bottle of eggnog for the holidays.
Service: 5
Amazing ice cream and friendly staff!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chocolate Ice Cream
On our trip to Wooster it was a pleasant surprise to find a Hartzler store while driving by. I just love their milk.... chocolate, all the flavors, ice cream and their egg nog! I was lucky to find their eggnog so I can Make my tasty pie for Thanksgiving!! Can't wait to stop by again to try more ice cream flavors.
Great ice cream very clean Store with lots of friendly staff Don't forget to grab some fresh milk still in the glass bottles