Always friendly service, excellent flavors. The sugar cookies are the best at Christmas time.
Apryl Y.
I would have been hesitant to visit if I'd have seen these reviews first. We went to the wooster location and the lady working there was so nice. The shop was so cute, simple, but inviting. There wasnt a huge selection, but just enough we had a hard time deciding lol. Always searching for a good bakery. We left with 6 different cupcakes to sample, two cookie bars and a box of small cookies. The cupcakes are all so pretty and I was blown away by the flavors and balance! Not too sweet, perfect! The Cherry blossom or whatever, cupcake blew me away! I did not expect to like it bc I'm not really into cherries. The blueberry lemon, I couldn't stop and I'm not big on sweets! I can't do anything too sweet and these were perfectly balanced and flavorful! And fluffy, btw. Not dense lol. Maybe they've upped their game due to the bad reviews, but so far, we are SO impressed! We have a favorite bakery! You will see more of us!
Kait M
Everything they offer is delicious! We went through them for our wedding cake and cupcakes! For every occasion we find ourselves ordering cupcakes from them! Recently purchased their holiday cookies and they were amazing! Highly recommend this place!
Denise S.
Since moving to the area, I frequent this great shop often. I was very happy to find out they had a location in Wooster. The woman behind the counter is simply refreshing. So kind and happy. I will admit, I don't buy a lot of cupcakes, BUT I do buy a lot of their buttercream cutout cookies. They are spectacular. I love they sugar coat the top so you can stack them easily.
Danielle Harubin
The BEST cake ever! We got a cake for our wedding and it was beautiful! Our guests said it was the best cake they have ever had. It is an hour drive from me but I will make the drive just for some cupcakes. Definitely recommend.
TinaLouise
I've had my daughter's b'day cakes done here for the last 4 years and they always do an amazing job, but this year they out did themselves. I was so impressed by the work done, so was my family, but especially my daughter! Thanks for making her day even more special.
Jamille S Hawkins
Absolutely the best bakery ever! The White Wedding Cake and Blueberry Crumble are my favorite
Paige Eberhardt
Hubbys job had some made and he brought me a sugar cookie so yummy. Great job
Brad Lancaster
PERFECT NAME! The Faithful Little Cupcake! EPIC!!!!
Kaitlyn Morel
Everything they offer is delicious! We went through them for our wedding cake and cupcakes! For every occasion we find ourselves ordering cupcakes from them! Recently purchased their holiday cookies and they were amazing! Highly recommend this place!
These are the best cupcakes I have ever had. Frosting is light and delicious and the cake is fresh and amazing. Will definitely be back for more!
Vincent/Michelle Todd (King and Queen)
Awesome peanut butter cookies, everything looked great! Definitely will be back!
Niki Maniaci
I can't even begin to express how happy we are with our whole wedding cake experience. They let us choose 6 cupcake flavors to take home and try, they talked us through sizes and styles, and delivered the most beautiful and delicious cake on our wedding day. We had soooo many people talk about how much they loved our cake. We live our of state and they made the whole process so easy. I highly recommend faithful little cupcake, and plan to stop in for desserts when we go back to Ohio to visit!
Danielle Offenberger
GirrllllllllllI have never set foot in this bakery but I went to a cupcake tour in Amish country on Saturday and a few of the cupcakes were from this bakery.The pancake and bacon....... woah. All the ones we received from this bakery were AMAZING (and also beautiful) the containers made their way back to Pittsburgh and were still beautiful and delicious.
Kristen W
What a sweet place...literally and figuratively! If you're looking for some sweet treats, give them a try.
Always friendly service, excellent flavors. The sugar cookies are the best at Christmas time.
I would have been hesitant to visit if I'd have seen these reviews first. We went to the wooster location and the lady working there was so nice. The shop was so cute, simple, but inviting. There wasnt a huge selection, but just enough we had a hard time deciding lol. Always searching for a good bakery. We left with 6 different cupcakes to sample, two cookie bars and a box of small cookies. The cupcakes are all so pretty and I was blown away by the flavors and balance! Not too sweet, perfect! The Cherry blossom or whatever, cupcake blew me away! I did not expect to like it bc I'm not really into cherries. The blueberry lemon, I couldn't stop and I'm not big on sweets! I can't do anything too sweet and these were perfectly balanced and flavorful! And fluffy, btw. Not dense lol. Maybe they've upped their game due to the bad reviews, but so far, we are SO impressed! We have a favorite bakery! You will see more of us!
Everything they offer is delicious! We went through them for our wedding cake and cupcakes! For every occasion we find ourselves ordering cupcakes from them! Recently purchased their holiday cookies and they were amazing! Highly recommend this place!
Since moving to the area, I frequent this great shop often. I was very happy to find out they had a location in Wooster. The woman behind the counter is simply refreshing. So kind and happy. I will admit, I don't buy a lot of cupcakes, BUT I do buy a lot of their buttercream cutout cookies. They are spectacular. I love they sugar coat the top so you can stack them easily.
The BEST cake ever! We got a cake for our wedding and it was beautiful! Our guests said it was the best cake they have ever had. It is an hour drive from me but I will make the drive just for some cupcakes. Definitely recommend.
I've had my daughter's b'day cakes done here for the last 4 years and they always do an amazing job, but this year they out did themselves. I was so impressed by the work done, so was my family, but especially my daughter! Thanks for making her day even more special.
Absolutely the best bakery ever! The White Wedding Cake and Blueberry Crumble are my favorite
Hubbys job had some made and he brought me a sugar cookie so yummy. Great job
PERFECT NAME! The Faithful Little Cupcake! EPIC!!!!
Everything they offer is delicious! We went through them for our wedding cake and cupcakes! For every occasion we find ourselves ordering cupcakes from them! Recently purchased their holiday cookies and they were amazing! Highly recommend this place!
Restaurantji Recommends
These are the best cupcakes I have ever had. Frosting is light and delicious and the cake is fresh and amazing. Will definitely be back for more!
Awesome peanut butter cookies, everything looked great! Definitely will be back!
I can't even begin to express how happy we are with our whole wedding cake experience. They let us choose 6 cupcake flavors to take home and try, they talked us through sizes and styles, and delivered the most beautiful and delicious cake on our wedding day. We had soooo many people talk about how much they loved our cake. We live our of state and they made the whole process so easy. I highly recommend faithful little cupcake, and plan to stop in for desserts when we go back to Ohio to visit!
GirrllllllllllI have never set foot in this bakery but I went to a cupcake tour in Amish country on Saturday and a few of the cupcakes were from this bakery.The pancake and bacon....... woah. All the ones we received from this bakery were AMAZING (and also beautiful) the containers made their way back to Pittsburgh and were still beautiful and delicious.
What a sweet place...literally and figuratively! If you're looking for some sweet treats, give them a try.