This was THE BEST Italian restaurant in the area. Service was always great and the food was delicious. Super disappointed that it's closing!! The Austintown location doesn't compare.
Brittany Williams
The food is always hot and fresh I always get the chicken and greens it’s such a large portion for (Lunch) the taste is amazing and that special dressing for the salad is amazing I absolutely love it here!!! Great food great people quality service
Melissa Cornwell
We found Nicolinni's Ristorante through a Google search while planning a trip to visit family in the area. Many times places found this way end up being a disappointment but not this one. Our experience was exceptional from making a reservation through messenger on FB, to the delicious food and the accommodating and welcoming staff, especially our server Brian. It was very refreshing talking to a fellow Youngstonian and learning more about the area since it has been several years since being here. Brian clearly loves life, loves people and takes a great deal of pride in providing excellent service to his customers. He is a true asset. We highly recommend Nicolinni's and will definitely return the next time we are in the area. The entire experience truly exceeded our expectations.
Ross Smith
This restaurant is the most well run restaurant in the valley. The service is outstanding. The food is exceptional, and the ribeye is the best you will find anywhere. Thank you for such a great dining experience!
Roberta Tringhese
Service was good. Didn't like the table, there were 5 of us the table made reaching food difficult. Also did not have lemons for iced tea or water. Server said the bar didn't have any fruit, I can understand not having unusual fruit, but lemons? There are grocery stores so close send someone out to buy some lemons, a couple of bags would be maybe 6 dollars, to please customers. On the positive my dinner cavetelli & meatballs were good, greens were good, like the oil & spices just couldn't reach it. My.husband had chicken marsala and was pleased with it.
Shawn Power
Awesome food! Hungarian peppers stuffed with sausage are so good. Wait staff friendly and courteous.
Susan Penwell
great dinners....and wonderful server-Brian. The bread....mmmm....the salad with great house dressing.....veal parm....chicken marsala...and shrimp and sausage in Cajun sauce over cheesy grits!
Rachael Seltzer
The food was incredible, but the serving staff could be more attentive.
Shane Chaine
Definitely a place id eat at everyday! The best quality food around
Best Italian food I have had in a looooooong time! Whitefich Francese was AMAZING! Calamari...beat ever!
Jeffrey Brown (Marrak)
Holey moley. This was the best Italian food I've ever had. I got the marsala and it was to die for. The Alfredo was killer too. The desserts were just average tho.
Jennifer C.
It was ok, I had the seafood melody, it was good. My son had the veal parm, he didn't care for it. The bread and oil is o.k. I didn't care for the wedding soup, I have had better. The Pepper soup was good. Maybe I will go back, but not in a hurry.
Matt Gates
Really enjoy this place. Food is really good, service is excellent, and atmosphere was nice.
Phil Cannatti
Great food, reasonable prices, very good service. I could make a meal out of the bread, oil & salad.
It is now closed and auctioned off
This was THE BEST Italian restaurant in the area. Service was always great and the food was delicious. Super disappointed that it's closing!! The Austintown location doesn't compare.
The food is always hot and fresh I always get the chicken and greens it’s such a large portion for (Lunch) the taste is amazing and that special dressing for the salad is amazing I absolutely love it here!!! Great food great people quality service
We found Nicolinni's Ristorante through a Google search while planning a trip to visit family in the area. Many times places found this way end up being a disappointment but not this one. Our experience was exceptional from making a reservation through messenger on FB, to the delicious food and the accommodating and welcoming staff, especially our server Brian. It was very refreshing talking to a fellow Youngstonian and learning more about the area since it has been several years since being here. Brian clearly loves life, loves people and takes a great deal of pride in providing excellent service to his customers. He is a true asset. We highly recommend Nicolinni's and will definitely return the next time we are in the area. The entire experience truly exceeded our expectations.
This restaurant is the most well run restaurant in the valley. The service is outstanding. The food is exceptional, and the ribeye is the best you will find anywhere. Thank you for such a great dining experience!
Service was good. Didn't like the table, there were 5 of us the table made reaching food difficult. Also did not have lemons for iced tea or water. Server said the bar didn't have any fruit, I can understand not having unusual fruit, but lemons? There are grocery stores so close send someone out to buy some lemons, a couple of bags would be maybe 6 dollars, to please customers. On the positive my dinner cavetelli & meatballs were good, greens were good, like the oil & spices just couldn't reach it. My.husband had chicken marsala and was pleased with it.
Awesome food! Hungarian peppers stuffed with sausage are so good. Wait staff friendly and courteous.
great dinners....and wonderful server-Brian. The bread....mmmm....the salad with great house dressing.....veal parm....chicken marsala...and shrimp and sausage in Cajun sauce over cheesy grits!
The food was incredible, but the serving staff could be more attentive.
Definitely a place id eat at everyday! The best quality food around
Restaurantji Recommends
Best Italian food I have had in a looooooong time! Whitefich Francese was AMAZING! Calamari...beat ever!
Holey moley. This was the best Italian food I've ever had. I got the marsala and it was to die for. The Alfredo was killer too. The desserts were just average tho.
It was ok, I had the seafood melody, it was good. My son had the veal parm, he didn't care for it. The bread and oil is o.k. I didn't care for the wedding soup, I have had better. The Pepper soup was good. Maybe I will go back, but not in a hurry.
Really enjoy this place. Food is really good, service is excellent, and atmosphere was nice.
Great food, reasonable prices, very good service. I could make a meal out of the bread, oil & salad.