Pizza crust was not cooked through. It was doughy. We ordered the best medium pizza they make. It was disappointing.
Ashlee G.
I had heard by people that seem to know about food, that this was the place for pizza in Bethany. When we first walked in it was pretty early and the dine in was not busy at all, but the phones were ringing constantly. That made me think my peeps were right about this place. That all changes once the food came out. First off we got some meatballs. These are just balls of meat with no seasoning and are super dense. The sauce was decent, but didn't really stand out. Then the pizza came. We had half Pepperoni and Supreme. Not sure why they just used canned mushrooms for this, but they looked and tasted horrible. The cheese is thick and lacked flavor. The crust was the only good part of this pizza. The only reason this isn't a worse review, the young man who was working the phones and taking dine in orders was a very pleasant and helpful person. He also brought out our food and checked on us later on. Didn't get his name, but he deserved all the credit for at least a nice experience. This place is pricey for a hole in the wall local pizza joint that uses canned veggies on their supreme pizza. Maybe it was a bad night, but it was not great at all.
Jason Mitchell
The pizza is not bad, but I would have preferred it be cooked a little longer, middle was doughy and droopy to the point I needed a fork and knife to eat. Plus $27 for a medium pizza, garlic knots (marinara sold seperately) and 2 drinks was overpriced. But this is just my opinion.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 4
Bianca G.
Not sure what happened tonight but the employees were lost and unsure of what to do in every moment. Slow to take our order, 5 min of us standing there. Slow to serve us and they didn't even know where to put the pizza on the table, and somehow I could have become their direct supervisor because they simply needed guidance in every step. It wasn't a pleasant experience by any means and the food wasn't good either. The "$8 Large" salad was joke. It's more of a $1.99 head of lettuce. Not sure if we'll be back and my husband grew up here with parents living down the street. Help wanted sign in the front window and it couldn't be more true!
Scarlet Adames
Went right before closing , wanted a slice but ended up getting Garlic Knots. Got them with I'm not kidding - bathing in half an inch of oil in the container.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 1
Allyssa B.
Everything about this place was amazing. Food was great and everyone was very kind except for one lady who I felt like was just absolutely disgustingly hateful towards her other coworkers. Yelling at them and seemingly throwing a tantrum.
John Warren
Feels like an old pizzaria walking in (additional parking in the rear with a backdoor entrance), been family run for many decades now and if you're lucky enough the owners will be in and you can chat with them and their deep NY accent. From what I can tell, there are no "pre-determined" pizzas, you just order your size and choose your toppings (not unlimited toppings unless you want to pay extra). They do have a pretty good two slice and a drink lunch special, however be warned, if you want extra toppings it's not only an extra charge per topping, but also PER SLICE - adds up real quick. Pizza came out fresh and piping hot, flavor was fine, but the crust didn't do anything for me.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 3
Heather
We ordered our pizza for a specific time and it was about 30-40 minutes later, which was fine for us since we were estimating but if we would have needed a specific time for sure this would have been a problem. The pizza was very good still but of course was just "warm".
Food: 4
Service: 4
H S.
Always delicious!! Love the easy lunch. It's one of my favorites. I wish they had a better website to order but I don't care that much. It's still one of my favorites
One of the best or in my opinion the best pizza in the metro.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Garlic Knots 6
Brian Williams
I've been in Oklahoma for 4 years and I've yet to find a good New York style pizza until tonight. It's absolutely delicious. Perfect all the way to the crust. Found my new pizza joint!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Supreme Pizza the Empire Size, New Yorker Supreme
Angelo Julian
Nice family owned restaurant great people great service great atmosphere and great food.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Slices of Pizza
Teerawat Phlaochan
At present, the food that American people accept to eat all over the kingdom and throughout the country is probably pizza. that has always been ranked and the shop that I would like to recommend People with a lot of experience and expertise due to the age of the store and the age of the owner. The produce that is released to those who love this style of food is appropriate with our sincere intention and presenting delicious food every time we come to visit. Thank you for making my body and mind feel full.Parking: Every time I get something from this store Will use the parking lot behind the store. It's a wide gathering area and it's easy to walk into the store. or use a wheelchair
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Berto Bennett
I had heard by people that seem to know about food, that this was the place for pizza in Bethany. When we first walked in it was pretty early and the dine in was not busy at all, but the phones were ringing constantly. That made me think my peeps were right about this place. That all changes once the food came out. First off we got some meatballs. These are just balls of meat with no seasoning and are super dense. The sauce was decent, but didn’t really stand out. Then the pizza came. We had half Pepperoni and Supreme. Not sure why they just used canned mushrooms for this, but they looked and tasted horrible. The cheese is thick and lacked flavor. The crust was the only good part of this pizza. The only reason this isn’t a worse review, the young man who was working the phones and taking dine in orders was a very pleasant and helpful person. He also brought out our food and checked on us later on. Didn’t get his name, but he deserved all the credit for at least a nice experience. This place is pricey for a hole in the wall local pizza joint that uses canned veggies on their supreme pizza. Maybe it was a bad night, but it was not great at all.
Pizza crust was not cooked through. It was doughy. We ordered the best medium pizza they make. It was disappointing.
I had heard by people that seem to know about food, that this was the place for pizza in Bethany. When we first walked in it was pretty early and the dine in was not busy at all, but the phones were ringing constantly. That made me think my peeps were right about this place. That all changes once the food came out. First off we got some meatballs. These are just balls of meat with no seasoning and are super dense. The sauce was decent, but didn't really stand out. Then the pizza came. We had half Pepperoni and Supreme. Not sure why they just used canned mushrooms for this, but they looked and tasted horrible. The cheese is thick and lacked flavor. The crust was the only good part of this pizza. The only reason this isn't a worse review, the young man who was working the phones and taking dine in orders was a very pleasant and helpful person. He also brought out our food and checked on us later on. Didn't get his name, but he deserved all the credit for at least a nice experience. This place is pricey for a hole in the wall local pizza joint that uses canned veggies on their supreme pizza. Maybe it was a bad night, but it was not great at all.
The pizza is not bad, but I would have preferred it be cooked a little longer, middle was doughy and droopy to the point I needed a fork and knife to eat. Plus $27 for a medium pizza, garlic knots (marinara sold seperately) and 2 drinks was overpriced. But this is just my opinion.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 4
Not sure what happened tonight but the employees were lost and unsure of what to do in every moment. Slow to take our order, 5 min of us standing there. Slow to serve us and they didn't even know where to put the pizza on the table, and somehow I could have become their direct supervisor because they simply needed guidance in every step. It wasn't a pleasant experience by any means and the food wasn't good either. The "$8 Large" salad was joke. It's more of a $1.99 head of lettuce. Not sure if we'll be back and my husband grew up here with parents living down the street. Help wanted sign in the front window and it couldn't be more true!
Went right before closing , wanted a slice but ended up getting Garlic Knots. Got them with I'm not kidding - bathing in half an inch of oil in the container.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 1
Everything about this place was amazing. Food was great and everyone was very kind except for one lady who I felt like was just absolutely disgustingly hateful towards her other coworkers. Yelling at them and seemingly throwing a tantrum.
Feels like an old pizzaria walking in (additional parking in the rear with a backdoor entrance), been family run for many decades now and if you're lucky enough the owners will be in and you can chat with them and their deep NY accent. From what I can tell, there are no "pre-determined" pizzas, you just order your size and choose your toppings (not unlimited toppings unless you want to pay extra). They do have a pretty good two slice and a drink lunch special, however be warned, if you want extra toppings it's not only an extra charge per topping, but also PER SLICE - adds up real quick. Pizza came out fresh and piping hot, flavor was fine, but the crust didn't do anything for me.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 3
We ordered our pizza for a specific time and it was about 30-40 minutes later, which was fine for us since we were estimating but if we would have needed a specific time for sure this would have been a problem. The pizza was very good still but of course was just "warm".
Food: 4
Service: 4
Always delicious!! Love the easy lunch. It's one of my favorites. I wish they had a better website to order but I don't care that much. It's still one of my favorites
Best pizza in okc hands down.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
One of the best or in my opinion the best pizza in the metro.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Garlic Knots 6
I've been in Oklahoma for 4 years and I've yet to find a good New York style pizza until tonight. It's absolutely delicious. Perfect all the way to the crust. Found my new pizza joint!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Supreme Pizza the Empire Size, New Yorker Supreme
Nice family owned restaurant great people great service great atmosphere and great food.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Slices of Pizza
At present, the food that American people accept to eat all over the kingdom and throughout the country is probably pizza. that has always been ranked and the shop that I would like to recommend People with a lot of experience and expertise due to the age of the store and the age of the owner. The produce that is released to those who love this style of food is appropriate with our sincere intention and presenting delicious food every time we come to visit. Thank you for making my body and mind feel full.Parking: Every time I get something from this store Will use the parking lot behind the store. It's a wide gathering area and it's easy to walk into the store. or use a wheelchair
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
I had heard by people that seem to know about food, that this was the place for pizza in Bethany. When we first walked in it was pretty early and the dine in was not busy at all, but the phones were ringing constantly. That made me think my peeps were right about this place. That all changes once the food came out. First off we got some meatballs. These are just balls of meat with no seasoning and are super dense. The sauce was decent, but didn’t really stand out. Then the pizza came. We had half Pepperoni and Supreme. Not sure why they just used canned mushrooms for this, but they looked and tasted horrible. The cheese is thick and lacked flavor. The crust was the only good part of this pizza. The only reason this isn’t a worse review, the young man who was working the phones and taking dine in orders was a very pleasant and helpful person. He also brought out our food and checked on us later on. Didn’t get his name, but he deserved all the credit for at least a nice experience. This place is pricey for a hole in the wall local pizza joint that uses canned veggies on their supreme pizza. Maybe it was a bad night, but it was not great at all.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 5