Sweets by Karen

3935 N College Ave, Bethany
(405) 456-9927

Recent Reviews

Angela Thomas

ordered a $200 cake that was not cooked all the way making it doughy. Beautiful on the outside but cooking technique needs work.

Andrew M (AFTW)

I ordered a custom Burnt Almond Cake. I sent in a desired look a like photo. They made it nearly exact! The pricing was right in my budget. I set the time and date and it was done exactly by the time I set. They also kept in great communication with me. Great service and friendly staff! Definitely will be my go to for my next cake orderParking: Parked in the back less than a minute walk to the front door

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Douangsavanh Barrett

The Best canoli we've ever had! Sweet and fluffy cream in a crispy shell with chocolate chips, simply delicious ❤️ The shop itself was small and cute and the man that helped us was kind ?.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Cannoli

Desiree’ Rodgers

Very responsive and respectful in the beginning when taking your deposit. After i paid the rest and picked up the cake there wasn’t any other communicationThe bottom of the cake was burnt and everyone at the party said it tasted 5 days old. This is little bit more on the pricey side for the creativity i thought would be moreShe put M&M’s on the cake and they were falling off as well A completely different color. Tried to follow up with her but no response but a like on social mediaProbably won’t go back as well as recommended1/2 sheet double layer cake $100!!!!!!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 2

Service: 4

Renee Webb

They have delicious sweet treats!! The employee on 12-16 was so sweet and kind. The spot is small but the vibe is perfection.

Meli Gutierrez

Sweets by Karen has great, friendly, and quick customer service! It was easy to order a cake through online communication. They answered all my questions quickly and kindly throughout the weeks leading up to the pickup date. Sweets by Karen offers a lot of cake flavors. The 8” vanilla cake I ordered was tasty and soft. And the expected servings was more than enough. I was asked to send an inspo picture of the cake design I wanted. I sent several, just to give an idea of what I was looking for. But I was asked to choose the exact cake I desired. The day I picked up the cake, my friend and I were pleasantly surprised that the cake looked exactly like the inspo picture. Pickup was easy and the storefront is clean and well stocked with many cakes and pastries. The birthday girl’s mommy and I kept gushing about how cute the cake was. We were extremely satisfied. We did not get a picture of the cake in good lighting, so the pictures doesn’t do it justice . I definitely recommend Sweets by Karen!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Kara Swindell

I absolutely love Sweets by Karen ??It's so delicious. Yesterday I had the raspberry moose shot!It was so tart , creamy and delicious.I also picked up the churro cheesecake so so so BOMB. amazing in every bite. My son and I loved the churro cheesecake ? We will be back . Sending love and appreciation ❤️ ???????????

Nicole Bolinger

This shop happened to be open on a day when I went to pick up dinner from the restaurant next door. Thought I'd pop in and see what it was all about. Wow, I am happy that I did! I bought a couple of amazing sweet treats. I also bought some salsa came home and put it in the fridge. Today, my husband asked me where I got the amazing salsa. I didn't know what he was talking about until he showed me the jar. I of course had to try he was correct, it is amazing! I can't wait to go back and get more! I don't live anywhere close but I will make the drive to Bethany for this place alone. There are a few hidden gems in that town, this place is certainly one of them.

Jaimie Calalay

Amazing cannolis, And great atmosphere.

Celeste Flemming

Cake was great. Kids were thrilled with their custom Roblox cake. Ready on time. Great experience.

Jaely Deleon - Wright

Love their cakes! Karen is so kind and helped make my event special. Will definitely continue recommending and look forward to coming back in the future!

Emilia Perez

The churro tres leches mini cake was so yum. They have the cutest lunchbox cakes!

Double Jam

I always have to stop here for a dessert after a great dinner at Birrieria Diaz. Such friendly service

Robert Byrd

The best sweets you could imagine. The owners are very nice and kind some of my favorite people around , we love everything about this place. Amazing mini cakes , cheesecakes cookies all kinds of stuff always a pleasure coming in here even if it's a guilty pleasure ?.

Butterfly Babe

Tres Leches cake is amazing!!

Load More