Mazzio's Italian Eatery

1916 W New Orleans St, Broken Arrow
(918) 664-4444

Recent Reviews

Tom Masengale

I read some of the other reviews and feel for these people. Pick up your pizza. The drive through is fast and the employees work hard to get your orders right. If you are lucky enough to deal with Susan on your trip to Mazzios, you will have a better day from that point on. The car you drive will get better gas mileage, and your clothes will retain an unrealistic luster for, at least, three and a half months.Dietary restrictions: Gluten free crust

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Coke 20 Oz Bottle

Katherine Conner

I ordered 2 sandwiches and made sure that they were served with creamy Italian dressing. Customer service advised yes. So disappointed that creamy Italian was not on sandwiches. That’s what makes it

Food: 1

Service: 2

Shavon Whitlock

Ordered food at 6 and they said 30 to 40 mins. Got an email said food left store at 644 and 710 rolls around no food. Call customer service they say with an order that big it takes a bit. Um I leave 5 mins from the pizza place they left at 644. Comes back on discounts food tells me it will be here in about 10 mins. It did arrive and the food was smashed pizza toppings on top of box and cold.

Food: 1

Service: 1

Gary Fiegel

I didn't like the pizza i received. There was not enough cheese.

Brett Magee

Pizza good yesTranscendence??

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

John Robinson

Very Good Pizza Pasta... ?

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Kristie Robertson

We had the Alfredo Chicken Bake, it came with garlic toast, the Bake could've had more chicken in it, but overall, it was mighty tasty.

Food: 5

Service: 5

Austin S.

This MAZZIO'S is the worst one I've dealt with. This is the 2nd time I've put my order in and when I get there to pick it up I was told they close at 10pm but my order wasn't ready to be picked up until 10:50pm. Shitty management and poor customer service.

Felix Hutchins

I love the deep pan crust. It is the best! The salad was great as well.

Jennifer Hendrick

Unfortunately, new to BA, now I know not to order on the weekends. Food took 80 minutes to arrive (60-70min window), wings weren't crunchy, barely seasoned, pepperollies we're barely warm, and even the kids complained about the pepperoni pizza being hard. The cinnamon sticks were almost plain, they weren't even brown in color. $70 order including tip, definitely not worth it.

John F.

This is the second time I have been disappointed but it was so egregious I had to leave a review. The pizzas were luke warm and pathetic looking. They were in a Medium box and sliding all around inside the box. TOO small for the box? The pepperoni had 12 slices of peperoni on an undersized medium pizza. I don't know who was managing this store tonight, but that person needs a new job. The ONLY thing they didn't mess up was the bread. On top of all this, they were over cooked. I want a refund. Take your $20.00 credit & shove it. They also charge a $4.49 "delivery fee" even though we have always tipped 20% & we live less than a mile from the store. You JUST lost a good customer. We're not coming back ever. F/O

Betty B.

Love going to Neosho Mazzios. The salad bar is always clean and well stocked. Pizza is fresh and if you want one that is not on the buffet they will make it for you. The deserts are So.... Good and you leave feeling happy because the cost is so reasonable. Restaurant is always clean and the staff is great. Kudos to the management.

MC Fontenot

Waited over an hour for delivery , when the pizza arrived it was burnt .This will be the Last time we will order from Mazzio’s.

Glenda Harjo

Scored major cool points with the grandkids with your stuffed crust pizza's and cinnamon bread!

Eric B Mitchell (E)

Really Great Service and good Pizza!? ????

Load More