Empire Slice Shop - Mayfair Village

4723 N May Ave, Oklahoma City
(405) 768-4707

Recent Reviews

Connor Burke

The best pizza places in oklahoma hands down

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Ghostface Killah, Evil Empire, Joezilla, Mushroom Pizza, Pink Sauce, Fat Tony, Rocksteady, MCA White Pie, Half House Salad, Half Cheese Half Pepperoni Pizza, Lazy Mongolia Southern Pican, Loaded Garlic Knots, The Big Easy, 20 No Sleep Till Brooklyn, Daily Pizza Slicesq, Parmesan Cheese

Angela

I am from New Jersey and there are only two places where I will eat pizza here and this is one of those places. Everything is fantastic. I have loved every slice of pizza I have tried. And the side salad is quite amazing. I gave the atmosphere a 4 star only because the location doesn't have a lot of available seating, considering the number of patrons they serve.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

d m

Disgusting pizza. We barely managed to eat a slice it was so bad. Threw it out. Cheap heavy spices on a cheese pizza are just gross… but the aftertaste is even worse than that. Pricey pizza so we hoped it would be good but it was just nasty.Service was fine, prices are high, location is convenient. But this pizza is gross and inedible. We liked the pizza at the original location but this location tastes different.We wouldn’t try this location again… gross pizza so bad it went in the trash. Undercooked, excessive cheap spices on a cheese pizza is gross.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 4

Kristi Sunderland

This is our perfect spot for slices. We eat here about twice a month. Used to be more, we have had to lay off the pizza. Their slices are plenty for supper or lunch. The price is about the same as everyone else. The only thing I don't like, is they charge you $1.00 for carry out boxes. I do understand, I think it's crazy.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Clay Croy

Good quality Pizza... Only bad thing that they offer only one type of crust and only offer one size of pizza.... That's unless you want pizza by the

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: MCA White Pie

Scott J. Hamilton

Simply the best pizza in OKC.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Caleb C.

It's my favorite pizza place in the Metro and I am usually very pleased with my experience, however, at this location specifically, I have had a bad experience the past two times I have ordered a pizza. I wasn't even able to eat the pizza due to the crust being CHARRED throughout the entire bottom of the pizza. Not a good look when the pizza is fairly expensive compared to other places. Will not be back.

Robin E.

Nice pizza! The location is very convenient. Easy to get in and out of the parking lot. This is a big plus! I got slices - cheese, pepperoni and my new favorite - Rock Steady. Whoever came up with this combination of marinara, mozzarella, blue cheese crumbles, red onion, bacon and balsamic glaze is brilliant! It's a really wonderful slice! Thank you!!!

Misty Hopkins (Misty Day)

This location new york style pizza is cooked a little differently then the other locations. Its like it's a little undercooked. The crust is thin but not the crispy bottom. The full pizzas are massive! Less busy than the orginal location. I'll take a busy location over sacrificing the integrity of consistency in empire brand! No fountain sodas. The sodas come in a can. They do have good crushed ice next to the water.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 2

Service: 3

Lance S.

I visited Oklahoma City to see some old college friends. We had a surprise party with some cake and drinks, but after the party cleared out the three couples that have been friends for almost 30 years decided to hang out for a little while longer and some of us hadn't had supper so we decided to try to find a place to eat, not too many places are open in Oklahoma City at that time of night, but this place was open until 11 PM which gave us about an hour to be able to eat and hang out a little while and catch up with each other lives. The restaurant was clean and there was only a couple of tables taken, so there was plenty of places to sit, immediately we were greeted and explained how the menu worked and how we could get individual slices or a whole pizza. There are several different types of pizzas to choose from. My wife ordered a slice of pepperoni, and my son and I split a pizza. They said it would be a little while to cook the pizza so we also ordered some loaded garlic Knots with the jalapeños on the side. The girl at the counter was extremely friendly and helpful even though we were unintentionally making it difficult by special ordering our foods. The drinks are available as cans so my wife got a can of Coke my son and I got waters. The water is dispensed in a separate fountain light contraption with ice on one side and water on the other. The food was average at best maybe three stars at the most. The pizza was very bland tasting, and even the garlic nuts were fairly bland. Maybe I'll order ranch next time if I go backbut the pizza itself left a lot to be desired for all three of us. But the service was awesome and it would make me want to return if I needed a late night spot to grab a meal.

Mistyday H.

This location new york style pizza is cooked a little differently than the other locations. Its like it's a little undercooked the bottom crust is too thin too be soggy. The crust is supposed to have a crispy bottom. The full pizzas are massive! Less busy than the orginal location. I'll take a busy location over sacrificing the integrity of consistency in empire brand! No fountain sodas. The sodas come in a can. They do have good crushed ice next to the water.

Blake Waldo

$45 for 4 slices of pizza/ salad and coke? NEVER AGAIN ✌️

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Kendra Kinnamon-Parker

I've only ever had great experiences here! Everyone is always so nice and the pizza is ALWAYS on point ? highly recommend the Ghost Face Killah pizza ???

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Ghostface Killah

lenea Blue

It smells so GOOD when you walk in. As soon as you come in someone will great you which is great. Smiles on the faces and everyone is busy but still nice. That was my first time eating there and the pizza is so big nice BIG SLICES. It was like being in New York but we in okc go try you will fall in LOVE.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Fat Tony, Full House Salad, No Sleep Till Brooklyn

misty jordan

Nothing

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 4

Load More

Empire Slice Shop - Mayfair Village

4723 N May Ave, Oklahoma City, OK 73112
(405) 768-4707