Papa Johns Pizza

10908 N May Ave, Oklahoma City
(405) 302-0123

Recent Reviews

Monica Leon

I was really skeptical ordering but it’s the closest one to us. The bad reviews seemed endless and I feared our food would end up the same outcome. To my surprise the pizza was fantastic!!! No joke! Our pizzas were hot, it got to us quickly and I got extra garlic butter at no cost! I tipped the driver when I ordered online but gave him extra cash as well since he arrived so quickly and was kind. Not sure if I happened to order on a good night or if service has gotten better. Either way, I’m grateful for their fast, efficient and DELICIOUS pizza!Vegetarian options: Ordered the Veggie pizza

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Stuffed Crust Pepperoni Pizza, Pizza

Chris Terrill

I'm not sure but requesting a square cut pizza that is well done. Is a pretty easy customer request? Right? Wrong blew my mind they could screw that up. So another words don't order from here unless you want your order messed up.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Alberto Aguirre

Good thin crust

Food: 5

Service: 5

joshua engelbrecht

Was wondering why my pizza box was so soggy and caught a stomach bug I love papa John's but don't eat at this one for

Food: 1

Justin Abel

I do like their pizza. I like their prices, but I certainly don’t like the management. That’s why they’re not getting a five.

Christopher Jennings

Didn’t realize they had stuffed crust! Now my wife wants Papa John’s -only- :)

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Stuffed Crust Pepperoni Pizza

Josh James

Hate to say it but this place is just bad. Sure you might get lucky every once in awhile but 9 times outta 10 you’re gonna be disappointed. This place only makes pizza and wings… for you to mess up pizza or wings just tells everyone that you don’t care about the product you put

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 1

Jason Starks

It's always a crapshoot with this location. Pizza is often underdone and not properly cut.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 2

Service: 3

Victoria Kymack

I would like to give a special thanks to Brandon because he was absolutely amazing and polite and I think he’s an all time blessing in disguise. If you see this hopefully you remember me. Thank you for looking out on a gloomy day. Full disclosure-I paid for my food but he will know what this is meant for. He’s a good person with a good soul!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Isabella Wedel

i was upset because i made a call and the gurl was rude, but the delivery lady was very very nice and pizza was warm and perfect, so that made up for it!

ΒΑΣΙΛΗΣ ΖΗΣΟΠΟΥΛΟΣ

Taste is good but not something special. Staff was helpful and polite and walked me through the choices of pizza.The place looked dirty and untidy.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 3

Service: 5

Jennifer Fielder

This is the 2nd time in a row that my pizza wasn't cut, wasn't cooked well done like I requested, and there wasalmost no toppings. (Bacon and tomato is what I ordered.)

Brandon Winter

Waited 2 hours for a delivery. Got tired and had to go down and get it. I don’t know who owns this place but they need to make some changes before they’re out of business. Don’t know why there was only two employees for a Saturday night.

Bennia Johnson

Placed a order online and when I arrived to pick it up i was told the oven is broken we’re not going to be able to serve you and i’m going to cancel the order….he walks to the computer, cancels the order, no apology and never made anymore eye contact with me. One guy walked by, looked at me and gave me a ??. Everyone was standing around and laughing doing absolutely nothing. Unfortunately I can’t give zero stars.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Sarah Hall

This place is not up to meeting the needs of its community. As a doordash driver I expect some delays but when you watch several customers come in the door to bring back their food because it wasn't even what they had ordered and then it needs to be remade I believe we may have some problems here. Orders are backed up to hour long wait times past the original expectation time, and from what I've seen some of them don't even get cooked all the way. I advise you that if you want cooked and done in a reasonable amount of time you should probably not go here.

Load More