They used to have the best pizza in town. Unfortunately all that has changed. Their new pizza is not for me and their new business model is not customer friendly. The staff was very friendly and helpful at the Stillwater location.
Kaite Kane Gibbs
I love the staff. Love them. they are fabulous kind, funny hard working individuals. Especially Lindsay and John. We have become regulars that come in at least once a week and if we are a day off the staff notices. However, as of July 26, 2021 you all went cheap. you got rid of the Traditional crust and the BYO and left it with just the Roman style. I am not a fan of the crust. My husband and my father are not a fan of the lack of choices. Unless you go back to the original way you opened in Stillwater, we will not be back. We said goodbyes to the staff and wished them well.
Alan L.
I picked this place because of its price point and the fact that they were similar in format to Pieology and Pizza Mode. When I arrive there is sign on the door instructing me to take a seat and that someone would be with me and that they were no longer offering build your own pizza. The restaurant was completely empty. I sat at a dirty table. I don't know how this could. No one was in the restaurant. I server but the name of Kayla walks over to me and I ask her what is going on and why the change. She said that she does not know and that it was a directive from the owner. I asked her if the customers like the way it was before. She said they loved it and that they were always busy. She hands me a menu with literally six maybe seven options with no substitutions allowed. Get this: a supreme style pizza is not an option. I was disappointed. I was looking forward to trying this place out. I asked Kayla if she liked the changes. She said no. Apparently the public does it either. I asked her if she likes any of the pizzas on the new menu. She said no because of the new crust. The crust changed too?! Wow! I asked her if she had any recommendations on other pizza places in town. She recommended papa John's. I said I wanted a sit down place like Fire. She thought of Just Waffles. I told that l have been there and enjoyed the place immensely. Then l asked about Hideaway. She said the pizza is awesome there. I told her that l was on my way there an apologized for not being able to eat here. She said that is was ok and I told her that I was going to write a review. She then gave me her name. Lesson here l think is to ask your employees what the public likes before making a big change on the menu. Off to Hideaway for dinner.
Natalie B.
This place is so good! I hope it sticks around. The pizza is so fresh and tastes homemade. We got the hot sweet brisket (unsure of actual name) and the chicken Alfredo. Both are so good and will definitely be coming back!!! Downside, no gelato at this location. Apparently because not enough customers for it while they've been open which is unfortunate.
Tara Linder
Food was good but they gave me a small salad when I ordered a large. Did get corrected and got to keep the first salad. So it was a win.
Robert Ballinger
Excellent pizza super good very friendly I give it a 10
Joseph Garza
Been here like 6 times. It's hit and miss with the crust, but when it's good, it's real good. Just hope you get a good crust cuz I've gotten a couple dense ones before.
William Matthews
Great pizza place! The atmosphere is nice, the staff are friendly, and the food is great. I’ll definitely be coming back again
Gregory Keyes
Great food and friendly service. Pizza was crazy good!
Libby S
Fresca Roman-style: Just so nice. Capers and Kalamata olives on a Margherita style pizza. ??And: I forgot the name of the dessert pizza, but Nutella, bananas, and whipped cream are a winner on a pizza crust.
Price was good. Pizza was GREAT!!!! Staff was awesome!!! Definitely coming here again!
Aubrey Cantrell
Had an afternoon date with my husband. Service was fast, friendly, and helpful! Will definitely be back!
Anthony Croff
Didn’t eat inside but picked up a to-go order. The service was fast and friendly. An employee at the window noticed one our pizzas was a bit burned on the crust and re-made the pizza without us even requesting it! I’m pleased with the quality of pizza we received and the extra-mile customer service.
Barb Wire
Ambiance was great. Staff was great. Alfredo Roman crust pizza was amazing
J S
Friendly staff. I really like the pizza here. Price wasn't bad neither. Good pizza place and kid approved.
They used to have the best pizza in town. Unfortunately all that has changed. Their new pizza is not for me and their new business model is not customer friendly. The staff was very friendly and helpful at the Stillwater location.
I love the staff. Love them. they are fabulous kind, funny hard working individuals. Especially Lindsay and John. We have become regulars that come in at least once a week and if we are a day off the staff notices. However, as of July 26, 2021 you all went cheap. you got rid of the Traditional crust and the BYO and left it with just the Roman style. I am not a fan of the crust. My husband and my father are not a fan of the lack of choices. Unless you go back to the original way you opened in Stillwater, we will not be back. We said goodbyes to the staff and wished them well.
I picked this place because of its price point and the fact that they were similar in format to Pieology and Pizza Mode. When I arrive there is sign on the door instructing me to take a seat and that someone would be with me and that they were no longer offering build your own pizza. The restaurant was completely empty. I sat at a dirty table. I don't know how this could. No one was in the restaurant. I server but the name of Kayla walks over to me and I ask her what is going on and why the change. She said that she does not know and that it was a directive from the owner. I asked her if the customers like the way it was before. She said they loved it and that they were always busy. She hands me a menu with literally six maybe seven options with no substitutions allowed. Get this: a supreme style pizza is not an option. I was disappointed. I was looking forward to trying this place out. I asked Kayla if she liked the changes. She said no. Apparently the public does it either. I asked her if she likes any of the pizzas on the new menu. She said no because of the new crust. The crust changed too?! Wow! I asked her if she had any recommendations on other pizza places in town. She recommended papa John's. I said I wanted a sit down place like Fire. She thought of Just Waffles. I told that l have been there and enjoyed the place immensely. Then l asked about Hideaway. She said the pizza is awesome there. I told her that l was on my way there an apologized for not being able to eat here. She said that is was ok and I told her that I was going to write a review. She then gave me her name. Lesson here l think is to ask your employees what the public likes before making a big change on the menu. Off to Hideaway for dinner.
This place is so good! I hope it sticks around. The pizza is so fresh and tastes homemade. We got the hot sweet brisket (unsure of actual name) and the chicken Alfredo. Both are so good and will definitely be coming back!!! Downside, no gelato at this location. Apparently because not enough customers for it while they've been open which is unfortunate.
Food was good but they gave me a small salad when I ordered a large. Did get corrected and got to keep the first salad. So it was a win.
Excellent pizza super good very friendly I give it a 10
Been here like 6 times. It's hit and miss with the crust, but when it's good, it's real good. Just hope you get a good crust cuz I've gotten a couple dense ones before.
Great pizza place! The atmosphere is nice, the staff are friendly, and the food is great. I’ll definitely be coming back again
Great food and friendly service. Pizza was crazy good!
Fresca Roman-style: Just so nice. Capers and Kalamata olives on a Margherita style pizza. ??And: I forgot the name of the dessert pizza, but Nutella, bananas, and whipped cream are a winner on a pizza crust.
Restaurantji Recommends
Price was good. Pizza was GREAT!!!! Staff was awesome!!! Definitely coming here again!
Had an afternoon date with my husband. Service was fast, friendly, and helpful! Will definitely be back!
Didn’t eat inside but picked up a to-go order. The service was fast and friendly. An employee at the window noticed one our pizzas was a bit burned on the crust and re-made the pizza without us even requesting it! I’m pleased with the quality of pizza we received and the extra-mile customer service.
Ambiance was great. Staff was great. Alfredo Roman crust pizza was amazing
Friendly staff. I really like the pizza here. Price wasn't bad neither. Good pizza place and kid approved.