Bluestone Steakhouse and Seafood

10032 S Sheridan Rd, Tulsa
(918) 296-9889

Recent Reviews

Jordan Hayes

I am seasoned when it comes to fine dining. This is a far cry from fine dining with insanely High prices for what you get. From the start there was a terrible singer on the piano who had no business singing. It took 10 minutes for us to be greeted because the server wasn't informed of our arrival. Which seems odd because although polite, he was inattentive. Items left on the table, took my fork when he brought my food and I had to use my girlfriends extra. I ordered 2 appetizers to begin. The bruschetta was the first dish to arrive and it was actually good. Not great but good. Then we ordered the truffle fries and it came out and literally looked like a plate of McDonald's fries with a side of ketchup. No seasoning nothing. I've gone to non fine dining restaurants and the truffle fries were better. After 30 minutes and we got our appetizers, we finally got our bread? Really? At this point with the Terrible singing and the subpar food, I realized my 2 64 $ steaks were not going to be good. And I was right. I've never had a worse filet in my life. It was chewy, had fat in it, I truly do not believe that steak was even worth 20$. Texas roadhouse has a better steak than this restaurant. Even my 10 year old son, didn't like his steak. This was supposed to be a birthday celebration for the woman I love and I wanted to give her a special night and instead I got a 300$ bill and bad food bad service and a night full of regret. If you want to spend good money and get a GOOD STEAK, Pryme, Mahogany, Fleming, Bull in the Alley, these are all restaurants I wouldn't think twice about spending 300$ because I do it often. The meat there is not worthy of any praise, and the service was polite but inattentive. This restaurant needs new management, and a chef that knows what he's doing. The restaurant got one star because I paid for an experience and got trash in return.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Lisa Gilbert

Service was great, food was delicious.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

JackM

Steak and steamed vegetables were outstanding. Sautéed mushrooms were good, but nothing special. Has bruschetta for appetizer but was not impressed. Wouldn't order that again.

A. C. Berry

My Norwegian Salmon was cold. As well as the the fresh scallops. Basically your over priced food is being served

Food: 1

Service: 1

Scott

Very nice little family owned and operated business hidden in the corner of a strip mall. Great high end atmosphere, with interesting decor and lighting. Live music and the smell of candles made for a great ambiance to the experience. My wife had the pork chops and said they were out of this world. I had the chicken fried steak, which was good but not great. Garlic potatoes and mixed veggies made up for the middle ground CFS though, they were perfect. Ending with fantastic crème brûlée made for a very good meal overall. $140 for two including tip. High end, but not too bad. Lots more menu to try on our next trip.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Apple Crush, The Chop with Lotus Potatoes and Sautéed Mushrooms

Great food, had an awesome musician playing and came by to see if it was too loud or if we liked the music he was playing, our waitress was very helpful in describing the menu and making suggestions which was delicious. Great experience, we will be going back.

BurtS

First they hurried us through our meal. The food was cold. Their menu no longer had our favorites. The waiter said they were too expensive. The waiter told us our choice of salad dressing was considered a side. I use to highly recommend this restaurant but not only will I never do so again I will never go back there to eat again. Find another place to go eat, like McDonalds.

TD

Nice quiet romantic atmosphere with live music. The food was good having the in bone steak. Good place for a romantic laid back night.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

Amanda C

Went her for a belated Valentines day. They had balloons and our table reserved and ready to go. Waiter was attentive to our needs. Live music and casual to fine atmosphere. Folks from jeans to suits.We got an appetizer, steaks, and wine. Fried cheese curds were really great. Would have forgone the salad I got. I got the filet and it was medium (pink) vs the medium rare I wanted. My boyfriend got the Ribeye and it was a perfectly cooked. Wine was great (BR Cone Cab).

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 3

Service: 3

Recommended dishes: Cheese Curds with Thai Chili Sauce

Kimberlie Daylene

Love this little gem! It's small but mighty amazing. The staff is so welcoming and professional. The atmosphere is romantic and the have live music that's not intrusive. The food is delicious and worth the money. This is our second time here and we will be back for my husband's birthday next month. Thank you Tasha for taking such good care of us.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: 8oz Steak

KimberlieL

Love this wonderful little place. The food is so good and the portion size is worth the money. We got in on Valentines Day last minuet even though there was a glitch with the reservations system. They were so accommodating and seated us right away. Our waitress Tasha was amazing and attentive. This place is our go to date night restaurant. We will be back for my husbands birthday!

SunnyB

Delightful evening! We had the Valentine's Day special meal, and it was superb! Tender filet, succulent lobster....The restaurant was beautifully decorated for the occasion. Live music, excellent service....We'll definitely be back.

DrCJH

Took forever for our food to be served at no fault of our server. Seems the kitchen overlooked our order. Our server was wonderful and tried his hardest to get the chef to honor our order. We waited 45 minutes. Also, on your special occasion menu it would be nice to have more vegetarian selections. I'm a vegetarian and all I was able to order Valentines Day was a potato and veggies.

Cindy Galbreath

We have eaten here multiple times in the past, but last night will be our last time. The moment we sat down, I felt like I was going to fall out of the chair, it was very wobbly and in need of repair. Our waitress appeared to be put out, and in a rush from the get go. We placed our order, we had to wait for our drinks, and our glasses were not refilled throughout the night. We waited a long time for our appetizers and salad, and within two minutes of our salads arriving, our meal came out. I also asked for salad dressing on the side, it came on my salad. We ordered two pieces of cake for dessert, that are around $17 a slice, the waitress dropped the two pieces of cake off and seven forks on the table, we asked for a couple extra plates, and she said it would be a while. We started splitting up the cake, and there were 2 long hairs, baked into one slice of the cake. We let the waitress know and she took the cake away. She didn’t ask if we would like another piece, or if we would like a different dessert, she just walked away. She came back and asked how our checks needed to be split, my daughter spoke up and said she and her husband would be together, and again, the waitress rushed off without even hearing how the remainder of the check needed to be split. Once we left, and we talked about such poor service, and other issues, I decided to call and talk to the owner, I gave them the benefit of the doubt, that maybe they were short-staffed, but no, the owner told me everyone was there last night. I told her we have been there before, and last night was not up to par. She said they were very busy last night so everyone was hustling. I went through everything that I was disappointed in, but she didn’t seem to worried about it. She did say they don’t bake the cakes on site, so she plans to talk to the bakery. She also said that the cake had been eaten so that’s probably why the waitress didn’t offer a different dessert. I let her know that the cake was not eaten. It was on multiple plates and they needed to look at all the plates. Also, the owner said most people eat off of the same plate, so that’s probably why the waitress was surprised that we asked for a couple extra plates. Needless, to say we won’t be going back. When you spend that much on what is supposed to be a nice steakhouse, I expect better than subpar service and food.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 2

Service: 1

Scott McEachin

Highly recommend for fine dining! Food was excellent and the dessert, a Sea Salt Caramel type cake was marvelous! Courteous and attentive staff.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Lotus Potatoes, The 45 Day Prime KC Strip

Load More

Bluestone Steakhouse and Seafood

10032 S Sheridan Rd, Tulsa, OK 74133
(918) 296-9889