Make a Wish Cakes

322 Andrew St, Exeter
(226) 980-7807

Recent Reviews

shikha singh

Sherri made a gorgeous semi-naked red velvet cake for our wedding!! She was very professional and patient with all my questions and request. She even made the cake lactose-free as requested and it still looked and tasted great. She even decorated it with flowers in the colours I requested.All our guests were surprised at how delicious and yummy the lactose-free red velvet cake turned out!The price was also very reasonable and the cake turned out absolutely amazing just as we had imagined!!Thank you so much! We highly recommend Make A Wish!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Sarah Keddy

Went camping as a family at the pinery and my twins were turning 4. Sherri made a wonderful birthday cake that wasn’t too far from the campground. She even included a little surprise of a sparkler and it made their day! Thanks so much !

Shari Becker

We left the design for the birthday cake up to Sherri after just a short conversation and she NAILED it! Not to mention how delicious it was too. The sparkler candle she added was a hit too!!

Barb Hall

I ordered a slab cake from Sherri for a 60th birthday. It was pretty short notice, but she was able to squeeze us in. The cake was fantastic. It was very moist and delicious! I forgot to take a picture, but it was also beautiful! Thank you Sherri, we will be back again.

Shari Becker

Sherri came up with the perfect design after a short conversation and it was a HUGE hit while celebrating! the flavour was amazing too! Thank you so much!!

Donna Becker

Sherri made our daughter and son-in-law’s baby gender reveal extra special with a beautiful and delicious cake!! Her cakes are the best!!

Jennifer Wolfe (LunarDream)

Sherri created a custom Wedding Cake for me and my husband and it turned out absolutely incredible!! Not only did it look amazing but it tasted amazing as well! I couldn't have asked for a better outcome and the price was reasonable! Would definitely recommend for custom cakes. Sherri is also very kind and worth your time!

Danielle Mahood

I come back every year for birthday cakes for my family! Chef Sherri makes the absolute best cakes (and cupcakes, squares, donuts.. pretty much everything!). She is so helpful and puts so much thought and work into everything she makes. Did I mention her salted caramel cupcakes!? Try them - Thank me later.

Kelly Butt

I ordered a variety of flavours including some gluten and dairy free for a baby shower. They looked and tasted awesome! Thanks so much Sherri!

Amy Wilhelm

We have worked with Sherri and Make A Wish Cakes for the past 2 years for a major fundraiser for Big Brothers Big Sisters of South Huron. They have created us delicious, eye catching branded cookies to hand out to our guests. Needless to say, the team is amazing to work with!

Jane Lynd

A big THANK YOU to Sherri, for the beautiful 60th Anniversary Cake you made for my parents. It was absolutely perfect! The cake was moist and delicious, the icing and filling were very tasty but not too sweet and the decoration was beautiful, right down to the 2 tone purple roses and a touch of sparkle.The custom made "60" diamond cake topper was the finishing touch and it already sits in my Mom's china cabinet. I will definitely recommend your talents to family and friends.Thanks again,Jane Lynd

Bonnie Sitter

Just enjoyed a caramel/pecan shortbread bar. Better than any butter tart I have made or tasted.

Anneliza Brito

Very excited that she got the theme right on point. Such a beautiful and delish cake.

Samantha Jenkins

Great people and cakes!

Lori Hicks

She is a baker with great detail she puts alot of thought into each item she bakes.. Love her beautiful cake that she made my hubby and I for our Wedding it was delicious, beautiful and everyone loved the flavors of cake and icing. It was great with wine a beautiful combination. And her creativity is always outstanding in the Baking I see on her websites they are just very awesome.

Load More