20 Best Pizza Restaurants in Newmarket

“We had heard about Pizzaiolo but they were always too far away. Great to see one open in Newmarket. Shared a Shredda Roni and thoroughly enjoyed it. Best crust we've had from a chain restaurant. The sauce and toppings were mild, but worked very well together. Prices were reasonable and the staff/owners were extremely friendly.We said we'd be back and we have been, several times. Just as good as the first time and just as personable. Great pizza.“

“Integrity and kindness! Uber Eats dropped off someone else’s pizza order at my door (I ordered from another store entirely) and I wasn’t able to get in touch with Uber or the driver. So, I reached out to Papillon on messenger, and even though it was after hours, they responded right away to make it right for their customer. It wasn’t their mistake at all yet they still went out of their way to do this! They told me to enjoy the food while they make another one fresh for their original customer. I just thought that was so kind. And the food is great! I will be ordering from Papillon in the future.“

“seriously I cannot say enough good things about this place! The restaraunt is very clean in appearance. There were fresh flowers at every table. The staff were very warm and inviting. Everything on the menu looked so good that it was a tough to choose just one thing! the portions are large and flavorful. I ordered the bomb burger and it was amazing! I know the menu says that it's bologna on the burgers and some of the other dishes it it's not your typical bologna.... mine had chicken and beef bologna and the quality of the meat was wonderful. we ordered a side of sausage and cheese fries and honestly we probably could have just gotten the mains without a side , we were so full but kept eating because the food was so good. the bomb burger is a double patty cheeseburger with sandwich sliced chicken and beef along with mushrooms , onions, tomatoes and peppers all baked into a bun which is light and fluffy in texture.... sort of like a really good pizza pocket... there was a bit of a language barrier but the people were so friendly that it didn't really affect anything. the staff even gave us a few extras ( coffee and cookies while we waited for our food and samples of some of the ingredients that were going into our food). they also have pizza which we fully intend to try on our next visit. great people and great food are a rare combination but this place has it all!“

“Authentic Italian shop! We were skeptical because it looks like a fairly simple spot.Read the reviews and decided to give their famous veal sandwhich a try.The lady who greeted us was sweet and funny and gave us a real Italian Homey feel.I wish I took a picture of the sandwiches but we inhaled them!The bread was moist and fluffy not dense and dry like lots of veal sandwhich we’ve gotten elsewhere.The tomato sauce was so flavorful and sweet yet simple.The veal was so tasty and stayed crispy even when coated in the delicious tomato sauce. Our first but not our last visit. We’ve lived in Aurora for 8 years and can’t believe we didn’t find this spot sooner!If you’re looking for authentic Italian food made with love…this is it! ❤️ ? ??“

“So freaking good! Ordered just a basic cheese pizza for my little guy and myself. Was delish! I also really appreciated the gent on the phone who took the order, as well as the gent who delivered it. Great service. Will definitely order again (and again and again)!“

“Thin crust pizza that’s simple not fancy and tastes good. Closer to the NY style compared to the trend of Neapolitan or Tavern style pizzas that other Newmarket shops are going for. Owners were friendly as I had ordered just before close.“

“Love love love this place. Fills the food void I miss from my Nonna. Everything is delicious. But my go to every time in the veal on a bun. Mmmmmmm. Eat one of those you’re good for the day. Puts me in a food coma. My vegan sister devours the eggplant on a bun. Staff is very polite. I haven’t eaten in the restaurant. I gotta take food home cause I usually wear it ?. Location is convenient central. I also appreciate how they package the to go meals. Packaging is recyclable and placed carefully in carry out bag. Come with stretchy pants cause the portions are huge“

“This is regarding customer service I received from Pawan at this store. Pawan greeted me with a smile, very pleasant when she took my order and asked if she could help me with anything else I might want. In this day and age when face to face contact is very limited it was my pleasure to be served by Pawan. She is the window that I see your company and franchise. Good job Pawan.“

“It’s a family run restaurant with delicious food and impeccable service. We got a chicken tikka pizza, a meat pizza and wings drizzled in their sweet/heat sauce. Everything was fresh to order.Highly recommend this place for pizza and wings!“

“This is the underdog restaurant of downtown NewMarket. Staff are pleasant and accommodating. The restaurant itself isn't particularly hospitable for indoor seating. But, it offers a great takeout option. Their burgers were juicy and the fries looked homemade. The Mac and Cheese offered a HUGE portion. Honestly, I will probably return here again.“

“First time having Pi Co. and my mind was blown at the fact that I could build my own pizza and add unlimited toppings for just $18!I went with the basic tomato sauce, mozzarella cheese, pesto, pepperoni, bacon, ground beef, some veggies, seasoned potatoes, sautéed oinions and garlic, and a lot of pineapples!! The dough was just the perfect thickness and everything just tasted great! The down side to this pizza is it’s pretty oily and if you add too many toppings, it won’t hold when you pick it up; everything flops/slides off the pizza. So don’t be too greedy with the toppings or just deal with the consequences! ?The staff were very friendly and helpful. As it was my first time, I was overwhelmed by the options and took a little longer to decide on my toppings but the staff was very patient. Overall, the whole process went by pretty quickly; from prepping, to cooking, to paying. Would definitely build my own pizza again! ?“

“Had the most wonderful dinner celebrating my kids birthday. She loves vivo, sadly the bradford location closed down so we made the drive and oh my gosh it was AMAZING. everything was so fresh and delicious. We all got different pizzas, pasta, salad etc. The service was excellent and the food was absolutely amazing. Restaurant is super clean. 10/10 we will definitely be going back“

“Nice little build your own pizza place in the Upper Canada Mall. Definitely fits the sports bar genre but with a cross of Pi Co and a splash of mom and pop's soda shop. Their build your own stone fire oven baked pizza is pretty delicious as far as pizzas go. Definitely a good sharing opportunity for a casual day out. They also have lemonades and their own beer which is a type of amber beer. The service was also very friendly and welcoming. A surprisingly nice restaurant in the mall with so many options.“

“I recently had the pleasure of ordering at Square Boy Pizza, and I must say it exceeded all my expectations. The quality of their pizzas is exceptional, with a perfect blend of fresh ingredients and a delicious crust. The menu offers a wide variety of options to suit every taste, and the staff's friendly service only added to the overall enjoyable experience. The ambiance is welcoming, and with their attached grocery store, it allows a perfect opportunity to grab a few things while waiting for my order. I highly recommend Square Boy Pizza for anyone seeking a top-notch pizza experience. Five stars well-deserved.“

“I must admit that I often eat pizza. It is a favourite food of mine. I have been ordering in from Gino's Pizza on Leslie Street near Gorham in Newmarket for the last two years. Delivery is fast and courteous. Pizzas are delicious. They are generous with their toppings. I rate them 5 out of 5.“

“The [bar?] manager was so attentive. I sat at the bar and had a front row seat to his competence. He stretched himself as thin as possible to make sure that every aspect of the restaurant was operating as it should. Think his name as Jesse? Thank you Jesse!!!! ?“

“Variety of hot and cold Persian style sandwiches plus different types of burger. Well designed restaurant area with very friendly staff.Sandwiches are full of stuff tomato lettuce meat and filled with mayo and also potato chips sticks.One sandwich is good for two people.Overall good food with reasonable price.“

“Very nice, kind and helpful staff! Good quality pizza and pizza bread( which is really important)! I ordered food with doordash and my order got cancelled last minute from doordash side, little ceasers called my to let me know my food is in the over to keep warm and I can pick it up! Many thanks and appreciate your professionalism!“

“This store is an absolute gem for the city. The service is exceptional, staff are super friendly and also know the craft of creating the perfect pizzas. What sets this place apart is the bold creativity in their pizza offerings. Each pizza features a unique flavour combination that showcases their commitment to pushing the boundaries of traditional pizza.The ambiance is inviting and trendy creating a delightful atmosphere for enjoying the food. If you're seeking a distinctive and memorable pizza spot, this is the place to be.“

“Exactly what you want, when you want it! Pizza is a pretty common food when you have kids. Our son is extra peculiar when it comes to his pizza.We have tried almost every pizza shop in town, and our son just keeps wanting the Brooklyn Pepperoni. It's truly awesome!“