The Frosted Cupcake

524 Lake St, St. Catharines
(905) 934-0003

Recent Reviews

Katherine Diniz

I’m so thrilled with how this came turned out! Thank you The Frosted Cupcake, my daughter is going to be so thrilled when she sees her cake ?

Melanie Driedger

My favourite cake/cupcake bakery in the region!! I’ve probably tried every flavor at this point and love them all. Is the carrot cupcake the best??? Possibly! HahaI struggle with finding a moist cake with a not too sweet icing and this one is just the best!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Cupcakes

Jim

Best cupcakes

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Darian Burke

Absolutely killed it! The cake tasted sooooooo good!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Derek Moore

We had the Frosted Cupcake supply our cake and cupcakes for our wedding and they were incredible! Everyone absolutely loved them. The apple cinnamon cake tasted incredible and they did a wicked job on it. Just wish they would offer the apple cinnamon in cupcake form.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Cupcakes

Hayley “Jacob” Nichols

I've been going to this cute well priced shop now for about 2 years as my boyfriend is anaphylactic (highly) Allergic to all nuts and we've been to countless different bakeries from Niagara area to all the way to mississauga. And they have nothing but more accommodating to all our needs.Their cake pops are a great way get to taste all their amazing flavors that they have to offer. I would support this bakery even if they worked out of their home.I'm looking forward to my next order that I will be putting in for my daughter's birthday.

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Cupcakes

Elizabeth Baxter

Best Cupcakes in the region! A great variety in flavours that are switched up from day to day. I love that for the various holidays they will add cute decorative touches to make you smile. I have be patron to their delicious goodies for years and have even gotten birthday cakes and even my wedding cake. 10/10 recommend!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Ashley Berti

My family and I absolutely Love these cupcakes!! They are so moist and delicious! So helpful that they are all nut free, which means peace of mind for my kiddos!Highly recommended the chocolate After 8 cupcake, it's my favourite!Dietary restrictions: Nut free!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

KSJ Sports

Very friendly staff. Owner is incredibly caring about her business and customers. Best place to treat yourself to a sweet treat!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Lisa Michelle

Beautiful cupcake shop, amazing cupcakes and friendly staff

Jessica M.

I call the frosted cupcake for all my events and when I have company over; they always not only look beautiful but taste incredible! they are even flexible enough to text when you have questions and place your order and staff are always friendly. I will definitely be buying my wedding cake here -Jessica

Ace Driver99

The Frosted Cupcake advertises: " Our Bakery and Shop are Nut-Free!" Well that's a big virtue signalling whoppee do! Hold me back!!! Maybe they should also list their ingredients so we can see what's in their pricey cupcakes.I was about to buy a bunch of cupcakes for Christmas and I asked my standard bakery question: " Do you use margarine or butter? Well the poor girl looked like her head was about to explode after being asked such a difficult question. After looking at me with a blank stare for a few moments she finally stammered: "Butter I think". Then I replied: "But you're not sure?" "I don't really know," she confessed.Well, margarine is essentially poison and is one molecule removed from plastic so no thanks. My guess is that they use margarine and/or lard. Why else would they not list their ingredients? They're really proud about being "peanut free", right? Avoid.

Jordan Shantz

We hired the Frosted Cupcake to make our wedding cake and cupcakes. We were so happy with the quality and taste of everything, especially our cake! We’ve frozen most of the cake and we’re already looking forward to eating more on our first wedding anniversary! :) Trudy was also a treat to work with! Thank you SO much for everything!

Amber Crystal

Cute clean and enticing shop. Sadly the cakes are not the most tender, the icing is grainy and overly sweet, frosting seems like american buttercream, similar to grocery cupcakes but a tad bit more upscale. (I asked the counter attendant what type of buttercream they put on the cupcakes and she gave me a blank look and said politely, “ what do you mean?”… so i explained. And she had no clue. She went inside and asked… but i wasn’t able to get a straight answer.) I inferred after I tried 8 flavours.Good if you enjoy the nostalgic taste of very sweet cupcakes.

Meghan Henderson

I didn’t enjoy the cupcakes from this place at all. I tried the key lime and coconut cupcakes and personally found both to be unpalatable. The frosting was too sweet a bit dry, the cake itself was similar to boxed cake mix baked sale cupcakes and the filling inside of the key lime cupcake had the consistency of watered down icing sugar. The frosting definitely has way too much icing sugar. Not for me…

Load More