Cibelli's Pizza

820 NW 9th St, Corvallis
(541) 286-4311

Recent Reviews

Adam T.

this place is disgusting, my pizza was soggy and cold and the olives looked moldy?? i tried to get a refund and the manager told me that they don't care and to leave if i don't like it.

Elle J

Called in to place an order and could barely get my order in (kept getting interrupted). Anyways, disappointed that the fresh basil was overcooked. Otherwise decent but not spectacular

Sydney T.

Ordered a half combo, half Greek pizza for $31.95. It's not all that special--your average pizza with maybe some special toppings. I was a bit disappointed to find that only 3/8 slices were Greek, especially because they were the better tasting slices. Overall, not sure that this pizza was worth the price point but I'm all about trying things at least once.

Jennifer H

I used to love this place. They have changed their sauce and now it is bland, but even worse than that - I rolled up to pick up my pizza recently to find everyone in the store with their masks down under their chins. Only the guy at the front counter thought it would be good to at least fake it by putting his back up when he saw me moving towards the door, all the others just left theirs down. I don't know what is more worrisome - a bunch of people cooking food in the middle of a pandemic without masks or someone moving their mask on and off then not washing their hands. Gross!

Ethan Johnson

Awful, overpriced garbage. The hiring manager is notorious around town for harassing his female employees. Go anywhere else, there's much better pizza in Corvallis served by much better people.

Russ F.

updated store hours monday - closed tuesday - 11-8 wed - 11-8 thurs - 11-8 friday - 11-9 sat - 11-9 sunday - closed

Mike S.

We're regulars getting a couple of pizzas and a pizzone at least once a week. Their pizzas are good not great, a welcome alternative to the eclectic California styles and the best of the basic, honest pizza shops. It's the declining service that garners two stars. Folks working here used to be friendly and sincere, but now it's consistently bad. Tonight was the last straw, downright hostile. Screw me? Screw you.

Eric

Excellent pizza. Great service.Killer selection and pies..10/10

teresa hess

Great pizza, great crust! Tried the Vampire Slayer and it did the trick.

Melissa Cochran

It's okay. Good, but a little spendy for how good.

Roman Guenther

Ginormous pizza, good crust/sauce. Employees are friendly, helpful

Kareem

That thang is good as hell. Pepperoni taste a lil freaky, tho

Kate Jones

We used to love this place but the last few times it’s been awful. The pizza has been undercooked each time and we had to take it home and cook it since it was dough… we ordered Hawaiian pizza the other night and it was the most disgusting thing. There used to be thin slices of Canadian bacon but instead there were thick and fatty chunks of Canadian bacon that were so fatty and chewy you couldn’t eat them. I thought they made the wrong pizza and even asked and they said it was Hawaiian pizza- just nasty. I would rather have a frozen pizza. I don’t know what they’re thinking. I’m sad that this place has gone downhill- it’s a pizza place why can’t they cook a pizza all the way through? I miss the thin and crispy crust of their pizza and I’m bummed they have changed it.

randy willard

I really lIke their huge pizza when I know I am going to eat a.lot of.pizza

Patrick Fortunato

They have great pizza and descent prices. The only odor I have is that they are closed sometimes randomly, and you don't find out until you get there. I know I could call first, but they don't always answer when they are open so that doesn't help.

Load More