26 Best Pizza Restaurants near Bartonsville

“Delicious food and outstanding service.Restaurant felt very welcoming and had that warm local feel like atmosphere. Ashley was our waitress, really sweet and outgoing personality. She recommended perfect vegetarian option for me, penne alla vodka and eggplant rollatini. My husband had chicken alfredo; both were delicious choices. BYOB if you want your favorite wine with dinner.We enjoyed that place and will recommend it!“

“The food was AMAZING. Very flavorful, lots of options, and extra seasonings offered at the table.The service was outstanding, they went out of their way to accomidate our large group. Disability friendly parking and seating options. Server was friendly, checked in just enough to not be overbearing, but ensured we had everything we needed.Place was clean, well lit, intriguing decor, friendly and fun environment vibes, but best of all they had a great choice of music playing overhead.“

“Do not judge a book by its cover on this place. Inside is very cozy and the food is freshly home made not packaged. Quality is hard to come by these days and this place has it. Started off with chicken sausage gnocchi soup, and was blown away with the flavor served with a warm piece of rosemary bread. Then finished with the cheese steak not your average cheese steak, the way the flavors married together was amazing . Everything from the food, the portions to the service was divine. This is definitely our new go to place, when in the area.“

“We got a catering order from Nick's and it was awesome! 4 ft Italian sub was delicious. Antipasta had a great presentation and tasted great. The eggplant parm we ordered I never got to try because everyone was going back for more! Nick and staff were personable and friendly as well! I would definitely order from here again. Thank you for supplying us with great food for my birthday party!“

“Called at 3:30. Continued to randomly call 40 more times. Got through at 4:00 ish. Ordered a pie and a cannoli. Got our dough for 8:00pm pick up. Coming from Jersey, 95% of local pizza shops are trash in PA. Sorry it is what it is. I can honestly say this is the best pizza I’ve ever had. Just knocked Al Santillos in Elizabeth to #2. Sorry Al. The cannoli was banging too. Super friendly and nice. If you got the time I recommend giving them your business. Totally worth it.“

“Food is decent, pretty expensive tho. The wait times are absolutely ridiculous. For cheese steak wings salad and fries it took all of about 1hr. From entering order to leaving the restaurant. They tell you 30 minutes at least when you order then take your 10-15minute drive there and then wait another 10 minutes. Yeah there was a couple customers in there. But I can order the same amount of food right down the road at another restaurant and wait 20-30 till I’m home with food not 1hr. Good people in there though.“

“New Yorkers bunked at great wolf lodge for our 4 day weekend approved!Definitely the best pizza in town. We ordered pizza and wings, way cheaper (and better) than we found in the resort. Absolutely no complaints. Thanks for your hard work guys. Took time out a busy mommy with kids weekend just to leave this here ✌️ ? ?“

“The service here is amazing the women who greets you is so awesome. I would come here just for her kindness one of a kind for sure. Great food great bathrooms cash only. Bathroom has very very soft toilet paper which I like alot. Food is reasonably “

“Great food, service and atmosphere ! Not sure what to make of the recent review about a bad drink and service ??? I know for a fact that the Hideaway is always quick to correct a mistake and accommodate all patrons. Furthermore, that old lady with the corrective lenses is the finest Hostess in the area !!! Who uses the term four eyes anymore ? I wear glasses and I'm gorgeous !!!“

“Pizza was fantastic! Crust was soft, not too soft just perfect. Sauce is very good. Today our shop ordered 3 lunch specials. Definitely great prices for the amount of food. Cheesesteak was delicious. Guys enjoyed their chicken parm. Definitely recommend trying them out. Staff very nice and courteous.“

“Heard about the cheese steak sandwiches and how good they are. Inexpensive also! Our friends were RIGHT!!!Great sandwich great prices! Also picked two pies. One sausage one just cheese. Another excellent choice price and taste terrific! 40 minutes in the rain to get there. Worth it!!!Will be backHighly Recommend“

“Today was my first time at the Sorrenti Estate. I'm honestly not much of a wine drinker, and there are a few wineries in the area, so it's taking me a while to get to all of them. They were holding their Annual Adult Easter Egg Hunt, and it was sooo much fun. The event was well organized, and all of the staff was extremely friendly and helpful. The prizes were fun, and it was nice to explore the property.The slushy flight (Easter themed) was delicious, and they have a good variety of drinks to choose from.Everything was really nice, but I think what I liked most was the atmosphere. It was very relaxing and really inviting. It was a great place to catch up with old friends. I'm sad I did not get to try the food, but my friends and I will definitely be returning soon!“

“I can't say enough good things about the service. On vacation, ordered food and my phone died. Couldn't find the delivery driver who waited on me forever. Finally, got to call and they brought the food right back. The lady on the phone was so sweet. The food was yummy. My kids were happy. Couldn't ask for more.“

“Amazing place ! Love all the food here ! Waiters are hit or miss , the good are great , the bad are terrible. Can walk from the winery building to pizzeria and bring your flights over as well , or buy by the bottle inside pizzeria. Sangria here is great as well! Honey on the cheeseboard is local and amazing !“

“I really like this place, the people who work there are very friendly, from the boss, to the waiters, to the cooks, they are all very cordial and helpful. I recommend you go and everything is too delicious, the pizza, the pasta, the salads, ufffff everything, everything is really delicious, you can Eat at the place, you can take away, they do delivery, this restaurant is very complete.Parking: It is very wideKid-friendliness: Yes, grade birthday parties can be heldWheelchair accessibility: Yes, there is an entrance for wheelchairs and there is space for them in the dining room.“

“Good food. My daughter loves the wings and I some pizza slices. More spices could be added to the wings though or they need to package and sell those seasonings ?? but overall they’re great! My daughter loves the wings! The best seasoned wings on town! The atmosphere is amazing as well. They also have a bar with their own made beer. Its a nice spot where Ive went to for years! ❤️Vegetarian options: Please add more. Its hard to find good vegetarian places around PA. This should be a good one too.“

“Pizza was delicious, both regular and gluten free, one of the best pizzas I've had outside of Italy, very fast and friendly service, it's a family run business . Crust, sauce and toppings were all very delicious , what not to love?!!Dietary restrictions: Gluten free amazing pizza was freshly baked for us“

“I picked up and order to go. Foolishly enough, I had never ordered or gone there before. I ordered 1/2 plain, 1/2 pepperoni and an order of garlic knots (4). The garlic knots are huge. Never seen ones that big. The pizza was really good. Cooked very well. Stood up by the time I got back home (10 minutes). Plenty of pepperoni on the one half. Crust was crispy. I will be ordering again. Unfortunately just a little bit out of range for delivery ($5, within 5 miles, but does Kalahari and some other places)?. Didn't really look around the restaurant for atmosphere. Prices are currently more expensive when you get there than on their website (ex: 13.99 is now 14.99 for a 16"). I mentioned it to the nice girl who helped me and she said she would tell someone! Now time to try other dishes, next time! I'll be back!“

“Benvenuto is by far my favorite pizza place in the area. The staff is very friendly and the food is phenomenal and well-priced! Their margarita pizza is the best I’ve ever had. I would eat it everyday if I could! If you are planning on dining in during the summer, it gets a little hot in the dining room.“

“Just got this delivered for dinner 2 nights ago and must say even though there was a mix up the pizza and calzone were delicious. We order a special by and got a plain by mistake. The situation was solved quickly. We got the special which included a lg pie, calzone, and hoagie. The hoagie was dry and not of the same quality as the pizza and calzone. Nice crust on the pizza calzone as stuffed to the max. We will be back“

“Great pizza. Literally the best in the area! They do local deliveries too. They cook everything quickly but to perfection. We love their stuffed pizzas too and their garlic knot chicken parm sandwich was phenomenal and the price was awesome for the size of the sandwich. Everything tasted phenomenal and we will be back!Parking: Tons of parking right at the location.Wheelchair accessibility: Ramp available“

“Is this Chuck E Cheese? No. The pizza is better here at half the price. Basically very similar to Little Ceasar's older recipe, sauce, dough which I think was better than the current version. Plenty of toppings to choose from, along with hoagies, fries, wings, bread sticks, salad, mac and cheese, other offerings.Tokens are 25 cents each or 25 for $5, which is affordable on a budget. There is a large ball pit for the kids with slides, pass through, etc. TWO bounce houses and they are both relatively new. There used to be one that had seen better days until replaced. The staff? The kids that work there are friendly, patient, hard working.The place is usually not crowded, except maybe Saturday afternoons, so very manageable for the kids, most customers are locals and the other customers are usually friendly, kids get along.I have been coming here nearly 25 years. First with my kids, now with my grandkids. They love this place. I love this place and the family that owns it. Many good times over the years.Negatives? I'm not taking any stars off but the games are older, may not always work. Yes as others have said there are stained ceiling tiles from previous leaks.Can they compete with Chuck E Cheese or Dave and Busters for toys? No. Then again you won't spend $100 here for 2 or 3 kids and can go buy toys after with the money you saved.It is a local family owned business not a multimillion dollar national attraction. The bathrooms may only have one handicap toilet, two sinks not be up to the standards of Chuck E Cheese or Dave and Busters.The decor is dated. Unless your kid is an interior decorator, a stickler for high fashion the bounce house, ball pit will make it a clear winner over the national chains listed.Kid-friendliness: It is a kid's amusement place. The only thing that could be improved is a barrier between the actual play area and the front entrance/exit of the store.Parking: There is always plenty of parking outside. The parking lot asphalt could do with some repairs, an update.Wheelchair accessibility: Curb cut outside, front door wide enough for 20" wheelchair, bathroom door, stall doors may have been 36" wide. Definitely had no problems navigating an adult in a wheelchair.“

“Clean, bright pizzeria. Large menu selection, specialty pizzas and much more than pizza. Friendly, smiling staff. Food is delicious, portions are large, and prices are reasonable. This was my first visit, and I'll be going back!Vegetarian options: Greek Salads are huge.Wheelchair accessibility: No steps to get in nor inside.“

“The pizza was amazing! Just had a plain slice with black olives, my husband had pepperoni and my little had a plain regular slice. By the time my husband looked up half my pizza was gone! I can honestly say, coming from a Jersey girl, it's no Jersey pizza but man it's a close second! So delicious, flavorful, and light!Kid-friendliness: The one guy, assuming the owner, was very friendly to our little one and was actually having conversations together. Definitely doesn't happen all the time so it was nice to have someone talk to our little.“

“A great local pizzeria in the Poconos. Parking available.Service was great and friendly. The pizza was very good too.The slices are just the right thickness- not paper thin but also not like a deep dish. No soggy bottoms either. It was crispy and crunchy and a good amount of cheese.I would come back here if in the area again.“

“This place serves a great old-school NYC style pizza. Thin crust, crispy, nice sauce and right amount of cheese. We like to stop by for a quick slice. Nice guy. The comments about the place not being clean are ridiculous. It’s fine. A rural PA location. What were people looking for? The Waldorf Astoria? I am a chef. I know what I am talking about.“